Invader said:I didn't find Blood Brothers or Dance of Death nearly as disappointing as you said, though they definitely were better in 2010 (partly due to the novelty factor, partly because it was such an exceptional gig then). The Trooper was disappointing as always; it's always cool to see Bruce wave the flag and it does get the crowd fired up, but it's never worked for me live. On the other hand, The Wicker Man was really great and worked perfectly after The Trooper (also completely surprised me by being included, especially at that point). With The Talisman, what really surprised me was the intro. On record, it always feels slightly dull, a bit forced and "not part of the song". Live, it was one of the most atmospheric moments of the gig, and in a way I enjoyed it even more than the main part of the song (which was also great, despite Bruce's slight problems).
Wild Wind was good, but I really would have preferred Starblind or Avalon instead. My guess before the gig was that they wouldn't play more than 1-2 new epics, and both Avalon and Starblind are too complicated to go well with the mainstream crowd. The Evil That Men Do was a nice addition since I hadn't seen it live before (except for the new songs, the only Maiden song I hadn't seen live before). Fear of the Dark didn't live up to the magical performance in 2010 at Sonisphere. In daylight, it just isn't the same as with darkness and fog. The final five songs were highly unsurprising and exactly the same as last time, big minus to Maiden for that.
And Satellite 15? Best fucking intro ever. Last fall, I thought it might be too long for an intro, but I was dead wrong. It simply worked. Mars, Bringer of War was great last time and better even than Churchill's Speech, but Satellite 15 beat them both hands down. The Final Frontier also rose in my eyes, though as an actual starting song Aces High and The Wicker Man are better.
To a certain extent, I'd agree with you that the gig was "routine". My biggest gripe with it was that of the 16 songs, I'd seen 11 before (three gigs, two tours). There was very little "new" to the gig. There really wasn't anything exceptional about it, either. Last time I saw Maiden at the venue, it was the biggest gig they had done in Finland up to that point, and last Sonisphere was completely exceptional with the storm and all. That showed in the performance of the band, who weren't quite as much into it as at earlier gigs. Then again, I can't call it routine in that it felt rehearsed or that the band was just doing their job: there were little touches that kept it far from that. E.g. Bruce calling out "albatross" pointing at a seagull in the sky in the middle of The Evil That Men Do, which was referring to his speech before Rime in 2008.
That being said, it was still an awesome gig. It's hard to give it full credit simply because the 2010 Sonisphere show in Pori was so exceptional, but so far definitely the best concert of 2011.
With DoD, I didn't mean the performance was disappointing - not at all! Just that it didn't click the same way with me as it usually does, and that disappointed me. I wouldn't say the problem lied with the band. Wicker Man was also good, but I think it would have worked better elsewhere on the set. I agree with The Talisman though, the intro worked better, but it hasn't ever really sounded forced to me. I can see how FotD couldn't just really be the same, but with it I wasn't really bothered by how much better it could be; I've never experienced it in dark. Next time I'm going to see Maiden a couple of times (when they come to Finland they'll probably have an outdoor concert once again) and then at a smaller venue someplace else, to experience the lightshow and probably much more intense atmosphere.
As for WTWWB, despite the great experience, I too could have probably had another epic instead (in a perfect world, I would have had it and the other epics). Starblind, preferably, but Isle would have been awesome too, seeing as they are my favourites from TFF. Yet I had little expectations for WTWWB and high for DoD. Perhaps their surprising impacts were because of that, I don't know. I should probably keep the setlist as a surprise next time, I think that was something that greatly affected my experience.
When it comes to the setlist and whether the gig felt "routine", I think you are spot on.
As for WTWWB, despite the great experience, I too could have probably had another epic instead (in a perfect world, I would have had it and the other epics). Starblind, preferably, but Isle would have been awesome too, seeing as they are my favourites from TFF. Yet I had little expectations for WTWWB and high for DoD. Perhaps their surprising impacts were because of that, I don't know. I should probably keep the setlist as a surprise next time, I think that was something that greatly affected my experience.
When it comes to the setlist and whether the gig felt "routine", I think you are spot on.