Well, it's a very interesting album, IMO. The first four songs are masterpieces (for Alestorm), and then the songs take a little dip and don't come back up until the final song. It's a very noticeable thing, too. Maybe it's just because "1741 (The Battle of Cartagena)" is one of my favorite songs of all time and literally nothing could top that which makes it jarring, I'm not sure.
But that being said, what filler is there is still some damn good stuff. The album features their best production, best use of keyboards, best vocals, best guitar.... best overall. And it's one of those albums that literally grabbed me and forced me to listening to it again and again and again. Despite the drop in quality. The last time I heard it the drop wasn't too apparent.
Despite these inconsistencies, what I'm trying to say is that it's a very weird album because the high note ("1741") comes early on, but as a whole, it's still their best album and one of my personal favorites.
I'm half asleep, this post probably makes no sense at all.