So I went through every post in this thread so far and tallied up every single song that's been mentioned and how often they were submitted as part of the contest. Allowing some room for error, this is the result:
78 - Iron Maiden
77 - Wasted Years
75 - Stranger in a Strange Land
71 - The Writing on the Wall
71 - Hell on Earth
70 - Days of Future Past
69 - Alexander the Great
66 - The Trooper
66 - Fear of the Dark
63 - Heaven Can Wait
55 - The Number of the Beast
55 - Hallowed Be Thy Name
52 - Caught Somewhere in Time
52 - The Time Machine
47 - The Parchment
41 - Sea of Madness
33 - Stratego
22 - 2 Minutes to Midnight
14 - Senjutsu
12 - Futureal
12 - Death of the Celts
9 - Run to the Hills
9 - Darkest Hour
7 - The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner
6 - The Evil That Men Do
5 - Sanctuary
5 - Running Free
5 - Phantom of the Opera
5 - Deja-Vu
5 - Brave New World
5 - Lost in a Lost World
4 - Wrathchild
4 - Children of the Damned
4 - The Prisoner
4 - Only the Good Die Young
2 - Remember Tomorrow
2 - Killers
2 - The Clairvoyant
1 - Prowler
1 - 22 Acacia Avenue
1 - Total Eclipse
1 - Reach Out
1 - Sheriff of Huddersfield
1 - Infinite Dreams
1 - Can I Play With Madness
1 - Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
1 - Afraid to Shoot Strangers
1 - Sign of the Cross
1 - 2 A.M.
1 - The Clansman
1 - The Wicker Man
1 - Blood Brothers
1 - Dream of Mirrors
1 - Out of the Silent Planet
1 - Rainmaker
1 - Dance of Death
1 - Face in the Sand
1 - The Reincarnation of Benjamin Breeg
1 - The Book of Souls
1 - (New Song)
Some notes:
The fifteen most submitted songs actual perfectly fit the 5 samurai / 5 cyborg / 5 classics design that a lot of us have been using as the framework for our submissions:
5 Samurai
"The Writing on the Wall"
"Days of Future Past"
"The Time Machine"
"The Parchment"
"Hell on Earth"
5 Cyborg
"Caught Somewhere in Time"
"Wasted Years"
"Heaven Can Wait"
"Stranger in a Strange Land"
"Alexander the Great"
5 Classics
"Iron Maiden"
"The Number of the Beast"
"Hallowed Be Thy Name"
"The Trooper"
"Fear of the Dark"
What surprised me was that only two peoples' setlists comprised in full of just this list of songs:
my own submission, and
the first one posted in this thread. It makes me feel a little bit better about my setlist, although at the same time I did play it fairly safe. But the selection of songs pretty much hit the spot for everyone involved and some songs like "Fear of the Dark" would be enhanced if slotted into the set in the right fashion (I think the flow of the setlist I made is phenomenal, with each song complementing the next; "Time Machine" bringing us to "Fear of the Dark" would refresh an overplayed staple).
At the same time, besides the two of us, everyone else had something (at least) slightly different from this core list. Those four Harris epics are definitely going to be wildcards. Most people think that "Hell on Earth" is set in stone, and that "Lost in a Lost World" is the least likely, but it's just gonna come down to how they feel once they start doing rehearsals. I think that "The Parchment" will be one that Bruce and Steve will fight for, because its sprawling nature gives the singer a much-needed break and the dark energy of the song will come across massive through the speakers, especially once we cross the finish line into the gallop break towards the end. Think along the lines of "The Red and the Black". But who knows right now. Some have included just one of the big epics in their submissions; others included three. It's anyone's guess as to what the band will go for in the end. Even "Hell on Earth" may not be the pillar a lot of people think it is.
And beyond that, there are numerous little shifts that one could make with some of these songs - including "Trooper" and not "Fear", or vice versa; including "Number" and not "Hallowed", or vice versa; "Caught" and not "Sea"; etc, etc. And then there are songs that I think must've been included under the influence of illegal substances. No way they'll play "Sign of the Cross" and "The Clansman" after the previous tour. "Face in the Sand"? "2 A.M."? Really? And this isn't even getting into the shitposting of "Sheriff of Huddersfield" and "Reach Out", which I still included to be entirely fair. And no, there will not be a new song debuted, certainly not in this leg of the tour.
Interesting that nobody submitted "Rime", despite it being a staple from the SoTour. But with so many
Senjutsu monsters to sort through, I definitely doubt that they'll include it.
Anyway, just a fun little project for an afternoon to give us some scope with what we're dealing with. Ultimately nothing is secure until we finally see the result come May, but it's been a lot of fun coming up with plausible scenarios for what the boys will decide on.