MindRuler
Ancient Mariner
I really thought it was Pass The Jam. Do you want jam on your bread? No I'll pass this time. I'm on a diet.I usually become less cryptic from the fourth or fifth clue, depending on the number of players.
I'll wait for a third guess now but I'll post a new one in a few hours anyway.
PS You should have seen @Diesel 11 's earliest rounds from a couple of years ago!![]()