The resident saudade aficionado
I would prefer the same format because I know for fact that I for one would not be interested in checking out the 100% extreme divisions. One of the best things about the way the GMAC was organized was that I got exposed to things I wouldn't normally touch with a pole.
The problem is when you get people who automatically are going to vote against the extreme metal in question in favour of the familiar. And I'm not a huge fan of the extreme genres in general, but I'm willing to be fair - and if everyone was, Loosey wouldn't probably have that idea in the first place.