Yeah...I think we all agree that 'Arry indeed has made a lot of questionable decisions and some of his songs lately have been quite repetitive, but I always find it odd that there are lots of people in a Maiden forum genuinely "worried" or "disappointed" because goddamn Steve Harris wrote 4 epics.
I think it's because it hasn't aged as well as people hoped it would. On top of that, the production doesn't help it much ether. I like it but I go back to AMOLAD and TFF more than BoS.Yeah...
To be honest I'm kinda surprised with the amount of criticism that TBOS has received lately on this forum.
I joined this forum in 2015 to wait for TBOS release and then discuss/share my opinions about the album. At that time, my impression was that the vast majority loved the album. Six years later and it looks like the vast majority don't like the album at all.
For me, TBOS is better than anything they have released since 7th son, which makes me even more optimistic about Senjutsu.
And some of the songs just don't stick out enough. Shadow of the Valley is by no means a bad track for example, but do I get an itch to play it the same way I get about Brighter than a Thousand Suns? Not really, no. TBOS title track is epic though, probably the best reunion track.I think it's because it hasn't aged as well as people hoped it would. On top of that, the production doesn't help it much ether. I like it but I go back to AMOLAD and TFF more than BoS.
I agree that AMOLAD has a better production than TBOS. But what about TFF and its muddy guitars? What about Bruce straining on Mother of Mercy and on other tracks? I think TBOS production is much better than TFF - it feels alive, while TFF feels kinda dead for me.I think it's because it hasn't aged as well as people hoped it would. On top of that, the production doesn't help it much ether. I like it but I go back to AMOLAD and TFF more than BoS.
Really? Man, Shadows of the Valley is awesome.And some of the songs just don't stick out enough. Shadow of the Valley is by no means a bad track for example, but do I get an itch to play it the same way I get about Brighter than a Thousand Suns? Not really, no. TBOS title track is epic though, probably the best reunion track.
I was over the moon when TBOS came out because it was the first Maiden album released after I became a fan, but I do agree with that. TBOS title track is by far the best for me as well, followed by IESF. TRATB and EOTC are really good in different ways too imo, the first being a fun jam to hear and awesome live, while Empire is an intricate composition that I like to hear when I'm in the mood for it. I wouldn't mind trimming a few minutes from both but it doesn't bother me that much. Those 4 are the longer tracks on the album so I think I'll like what Senjutsu has to offer. Other than those, one that stood out for me is TOAC, such a beautiful song. The rest are good songs but I don't have the urge to re-listen to them very often. I'd put it below TXF, BNW and AMOLAD for post 80s stuff, and on par with TFF.And some of the songs just don't stick out enough. Shadow of the Valley is by no means a bad track for example, but do I get an itch to play it the same way I get about Brighter than a Thousand Suns? Not really, no. TBOS title track is epic though, probably the best reunion track.
Ok ok, maybe a bad example as I also think it is one of the better tracks. Let's say... When the River Runs Deep or TGU.Really? Man, Shadows of the Valley is awesome.
Use The Time Machine, travel back to Powerslave days and put it in the album.
Instant classic.
Actually, I'm pretty sure it has happened in an alternative universe. Shadows of the Valley is a part of "Play Classics!" right there and people think it's overplayed.
the prisoner
Also, not really related to your original thoughts, I always find it interesting that:Bruce co-wrote that one (uncredited).
22 Acacia Avenue, The Fallen Angel, Wildest Dreams, Paschendale, Different World, The Great Unknown, When the River Runs Deep and Tears of a Clown are all Smith/Harris songs.
Welcome back from your break! Shorter than anticipated but you are always welcome here.I think this album is one of those precious in my life time that I've waited the most. This is surely among those few.
Im hopefully that Harris epics will truly be epic and special, he must have gotten inspiration from different aspects and so..