Official Football Thread

Sergio Ramos
_81738062_risitas.jpg
 
I fear the first 10 of the 2nd half. If United can frustrate PSG for some time, they might get nervous. PSG know they should go through with that result from the first leg, it is theirs to lose.
 
Touche, Wizard.
Well, pen or not? Im a Utd fan and I feel sick. Never a pen in my book. BT Sport referee said it was definitely a pen under current rules.
 
In my book it is right on the edge of pen/no pen. You can see he throws his arm out, but it is a natural part of his movement (jumping in order to block with his body). If it becomes the standard that such situations are considered deliberate handball, defenders will have to make all movements with their arms held firmly against their sides (an unnatural position).

It is not an obvious error to give a penalty, but a subjective decision - of a kind that has caused heated discussions for decades. I have participated in many such discussions myself as a player, against people who think that any contact ball-hand is a free kick. Even if the ball hits your hand when you don't even see the ball, as long as you have an advantage of it.

No, based on my understanding of the handball rule (and its intention) I think that sort of situation should not be penalized. But based on precedence in today's top level football, it should.
 
Back
Top