Metallica

Behind-the-scenes of "Here Comes Revenge" songwriting/recording. I love these types of videos. Metallica releasing this kind of stuff during The Black Album was one of the reasons why they became my favorite band as a youngster: they show you everything. It's so cool to have an inside look at the writing process inside the studio. Originally known as "R L 72 - Riff Lord 72" and one verse being described musically as the "Faith No More verse."


Conspicuously absent from the entire songwriting-to-arranging process? Kirk "I Want To Contribute More" Hammett.
 
Last edited:
Conspicuously absent from the entire songwriting-to-arranging process? Kirk "I Want To Contribute More" Hammett.

Summer 2015, San Rafael, California

Kirk: "Hey James, I read on Blabbermouth that we're writing a new record, but I don't know anything yet."
James: "Listen Kirk, Lars and I have started already. Actually, we're about done. We've already written twelve songs. Soon we'll start with recording. When it's time for you to record your solos, we'll give you a call OK?"
Kirk: "But I haven't had a chance to let you hear my ideas."
James: "Those ideas of yours, yeah we know that already. The last usable riff you've made up was the one for Creeping Death. And then you still played in Exodus!"
Kirk: "But... but..."
James: "Sorry Kirk. You'll hear from us."
Kirk: "But I've told all my friends that I'm bursting from inspiration. I have great riffs."
James: "You know what you do? Tell all your friends that you've recorded all those fantastic riffs with your phone. And that you've lost it. We'll play the game along. This way, Lars and I can work on quietly. Meanwhile, maybe you and your wahwah-pedal can make up twelve solos."
Kirk: "Okay then James. See you soon."
James: "Later Kirk!"



From the last Aardschok magazine, translated by yours truly :)
 
Last edited:
I wish Maiden did extensive studio behind-the-scenes stuff for their records, especially given all of the parts/arrangements. I always like hearing how the songs come to fruition (working titles/how they evolve/how they decide to flesh out certain sections etc...). Metallica is awesome in that regard.
 
Agreed. I would adore some behind the scenes studio footage from Maiden. We get writing credits and some tidbits from interviews, but I wanna see the arrangements and ideas happening the way we get to with Metallica!
 
I am holding out hope for some TBOS footage like the DoD doc that didn't surface until the Death on the Road DVD. They've done a documentary in some form for every album since and TBOS was extra special even before Bruce's cancer so it would be appropriate.
 
Behind-the-scenes of "Here Comes Revenge" songwriting/recording. I love these types of videos. Metallica releasing this kind of stuff during The Black Album was one of the reasons why they became my favorite band as a youngster: they show you everything. It's so cool to have an inside look at the writing process inside the studio. Originally known as "R L 72 - Riff Lord 72" and one verse being described musically as the "Faith No More verse."


Conspicuously absent from the entire songwriting-to-arranging process? Kirk "I Want To Contribute More" Hammett.

Very cool video!

There was a pretty good interview in this months Metal Hammer magazine. I've written this out very fast from the interview as it deals with Rob and Kirks involvement in the writing process. Spelling mistakes may occur ;)

"Given that Rob Trujillo echoes the excitement about the new material that his band mates have thus far exuded, we can't help but ask about the fact that he and Kirk Hammett, on a creative level at least, have seemed to have had very little to do with it. Lars earlier mentioned that it was very much he and James at the core of the creative process this time around, and indeed a quick glance at the writing credits corroborates this - there's only one nod to Rob - on the track ManUNkind - and none at all for Kirk. What's going on there exactly? "For some reason, Lars felt it was really important to connect with James" Rob offers diplomatically. "It was evident that there was a surplus of riffs that were coming from James and I think Lars focused more on simplifying the creative journey, and locking into James and really bringing him in for this album.But I was still there every day. It's not like they're over there by themselves writing the album - I'm with them and I'm there supporting them with my bass But no, I didn't sit there and show James my [ideas]. Death Magnetic was a collaborative album, there were a lot of Kirk riffs in there, and there were a lot of my ideas, too. This isn't like that. It's Lars vision, and I'm happy to support whatever we need to do" So, Hardwired...is officially the Lars and James show. While Rob comes across as genuinely happy to toe the company line on this one, Kirk seems marginally less impressed, if still decidedly philosophical about the situation, when we raise it with him later on. "For me, being in this band, I always want to contribute, " he shrugs. "I always have a lot of musical concepts and ideas to bring to the table. Obviously, that was not meant to be [this time] and I had to accept that fact, even though it was a very bitter pill to swallow" Given that Kirk had already had to shrug off the artistic trauma of losing hundreds of riffs he'd written for the album after the phone he recorded them on went AWOL - Kirk has also had to sit back and accept that his influence on Hardwired...was to be relatively minimal. When he emphasis that it was not a situation of his making, he seems to have begrudgingly accepted that, if Metallica are to progress into the next stage of their career, it's one that has to happen. "I want to write for the band, because it's part of what I do, but if it's not meant to be, OK I really didn't have much of a choice", he offers. "And so, I focused on my solos, and just making sure that my playing on the album was at its best, at its full potential. Hopefully I can bring my ideas to the next Metallica album. I just hope it's not another eight years..." It speaks volumes of the place Metallica are at in 2016 that Lars and James can assume almost total creative control without too much tension rising in the ranks, and as Rob notes, it marks a stark difference from the atmosphere he found himself stepping into when he joined the band in 2003. "
 
From a creative standpoint, Metallica has always been the James and Lars show. Reading Rob's answers in that interview, I agree with Lars. Having him and James connect on a basic songwriting level is what Metallica has been missing for nearly 20 years. Not all players are created equal. James Hetfield is a songwriter who happens to be in a metal band and Lars Ulrich is a music producer who happens to play drums. They are what built Metallica into what it is - those two heads in a room battling out structure, riffing, and melodies.

Now, I don't want to hate on Hammett too much (God knows I do plenty of it) because the guy has contributed more to Metallica's sound than anyone else barring the main two. Kirk wrote some of the bands best classic riffs (including the bridge of Creeping Death, the main riff in Master of Puppets, and Enter Sandman). However, his recent contributions have been less than inspired.

Rob doesn't need the writing credits because he already has more than any other Metallica bassist. Here's a breakdown of the total number of Metallica writing credits:

James Hetfield - 113
Lars Ulrich - 112
Kirk Hammett - 55
Rob Trujillo - 15
Cliff Burton - 11
Bob Rock - 10
Dave Mustaine - 6
Jason Newsted - 3

The only person who ever got screwed hard in Metallica was Jason Newsted. If we use writing credits as sole example, Jason is less important in Metallica's history than either Dave Mustaine or Bob Fucking Rock. Jeez.

I personally think that Metallica is at their worst when they are acting as a democracy (re: St. Anger and Death Magnetic). IMO the albums made with shared writing credits and equal input, even when they are good, great, or amazing, sound like they work in spite of the input rather than because of it. When it comes to songwriting, James Hetfield is and always has been the beating heart of Metallica and Lars is the guy who knows how to get James' blood pumping. Every one else is either a helpful batch of firing nerve endings or a clogged artery (depending on the year).
 
More making-of videos!

Hardwired (working title: Riff Charge), in which James hilariously tries to scream and Lars tells Kirk how to play his solo:

Moth Into Flame (working title: Plow), in which Lars literally constructs a song out of spare parts and learns how to play wah-wah from Kirk:

Dream No More (working title: 91), in which Rob teaches James how to play riffs, Greg Fidelman (producer) hopes Kirk stays away from the wah, and proof of Rob singing appears:
 
Confusion. The first 3 minutes and (roughly) 40 seconds are so great. Sadly the two last minutes feel not very necessary. My level of enthousiasm goes down in this segment. But back to what comes before that. Every riff, (harmonic) guitar line and vocal is so excellent. And that short solo, starting in the third minute! What a beauty. I love how that last tone flows so well in the next verse. And then it pops up a few times around James lines. No wah if I'm mistaken. :)
 
Holy crap - I knew that Jason didn't have many writing credits, but when you put it in context like that, it really hits that point home.

Those behind the scenes clips are great. I wish I could do that for a living! (Well...maybe not the intense pressure of the business side....but showing up with your mates and making music with nearly limitless resources every day. Oh and driving home after the studio to a mansion in a posh sports car wouldn't be bad, either).
 
Confusion. The first 3 minutes and (roughly) 40 seconds are so great. Sadly the two last minutes feel not very necessary. My level of enthousiasm goes down in this segment. But back to what comes before that. Every riff, (harmonic) guitar line and vocal is so excellent. And that short solo, starting in the third minute! What a beauty. I love how that last tone flows so well in the next verse. And then it pops up a few times around James lines. No wah if I'm mistaken. :)

That's the thing with Kirk...large moments of ineptitude with occasional moments of brilliance:cool:.
 
Studio efforts aside, Kirk is really, and I mean really struggling live lately. It's the arthritis bothering him I think. He absolutely butchered Orion in one of the recent shows. Played at least 6-7 consecutive wrong notes to start the first solo.
 
Studio efforts aside, Kirk is really, and I mean really struggling live lately. It's the arthritis bothering him I think. He absolutely butchered Orion in one of the recent shows. Played at least 6-7 consecutive wrong notes to start the first solo.

Absolutely. His album performances are mediocre at best, but his live performances are just plain sloppy. Both lead guitarists in Metallica (Dave and Kirk) seem to have hit the wall in being able to actually play most of their parts anymore. At least Dave has the excuse of massive drug addiction, arthritis, nerve damage, surgery, and literal death. Kirk only has laziness to blame.

I read in a yt comment that the song wasn't prepared. It was put on last second on the setlist.

Which would make sense. Not everyone can have the encyclopedic memory of John Petrucci.

However, I also read in a YT comment that James Hetfield is a gay fish fagz0rz hoo cant play gutar & dosnt rite songs for Mettalica.
 
I read in a yt comment that the song wasn't prepared. It was put on last second on the setlist.

Could be true, but it's not like they haven't played Orion before. I think he was just scrambling after missing the first note and just couldn't figure it out. He tried to improvize his way out of it in the latter part of the solo but even that didn't work.

That's just a recent example anyway, Kirk has been incredibly sloppy in general.
 
Absolutely. His album performances are mediocre at best, but his live performances are just plain sloppy. Both lead guitarists in Metallica (Dave and Kirk) seem to have hit the wall in being able to actually play most of their parts anymore. At least Dave has the excuse of massive drug addiction, arthritis, nerve damage, surgery, and literal death. Kirk only has laziness to blame.
Kirk does have arthritis to blame though. It's probably the biggest single contributor to his deteriorating ability to play his solos, actually. It's pretty obvious too since you can see him struggling to simply move his fingers fast and accurately enough to do his solos.

That said having high action on his guitar and a really awful lead tone make him sound even worse. That and the fact that he seems to play his guitar ridiculously hard, he manages to keep getting them out of tune live pretty consistently.

e: But yeah, he does have a tendency to seemingly forget the occasional solo and improvise (poorly) instead. He also uses the wah to hide some of his sloppiness in a fair few solos.
 
I wasn't aware of his arthritis, but yeah - he definitely hits that thing way too hard. Lower the action and learn to play with ease and I bet he'd be able to compensate for a lot of his physical issues.
 
I mentioned his arthritis in my earlier post.

Studio efforts aside, Kirk is really, and I mean really struggling live lately. It's the arthritis bothering him I think. He absolutely butchered Orion in one of the recent shows. Played at least 6-7 consecutive wrong notes to start the first solo.
 
Negative people!
Not liking some Metallica songs doesn't justify labeling someone a negative person.

Honestly, there are many people who liked Metallica up until (maybe including the black album), since then most of their songs have had little appeal to some people (myself included). Others got into Metallica's catalogue from the black album onwards and perhaps that is their tastes.

Personally, I've grown a bit sick of Hetfeild's voice on TBA, Load, Re-load, DM etc. I don't listen to St Anger (it's pretty horrible). On this latest album I think the more listenable songs are where Hetfield's voice is quite different from the last 25 years of albums. But mostly this new album still fits in the TBA, Load ilk, apart from that last song it's not really a thrash album (which is fine, I listen to Maiden, Black Sab, JP, Within Temptation, Nightwish etc).
I'd say the album is OK for a few listens, I will get sick of it (well actually I haven't listened to any of the songs for about a week now).I probably wouldn't mind putting Spit out the bone on my mp3 player, but that's about it.
 
Back
Top