Maiden Albums: Head to Head

Vote for your favourite song from each pair


  • Total voters
    34
  • Poll closed .
I'm not a Russophile
putin_angry.jpg
 
Yeah. Great underrated song. That one and Bring Your Daughter need more votes IMO. (BYD is only winning because it's up against a bonus song, it's not very well liked here :()
 
NP hates Rime. I remember in the old forum his +/- rate was down in the shitter because of his negative posts about Rime :p

(And Paschendale too)
 
NP hates Rime. I remember in the old forum his +/- rate was down in the shitter because of his negative posts about Rime :p

(And Paschendale too)
I don't hate Rime or Paschendale, I'm pretty sure I gave them both 10's in the Commentary Forum (I have to redo that sometime though). I just think both are overhyped and overexposed here :P
 
An 8-3 win for the favourite, Powerslave.
Up next, Number of the Beast versus The X Factor
 
Invaders vs Sign of the Cross
Children of the Damned
vs Lord of the Flies
The Prisoner vs Man on the Edge
22 Acacia Avenue vs Fortunes of War
Prowler 88 vs Look for the Truth
The Number of the Beast
vs The Aftermath
Run to the Hills vs Judgement of Heaven
Gangland vs Blood on the World's Hands
Total Eclipse vs The Edge of Darkness
Charlotte 88 vs 2 AM
Hallowed be thy Name
vs The Unbeliever

A shock result: 6-5 to 'The X Factor'. :eek: I rate both these albums very highly but would say I prefer 'The Number of the Beast'. Bear in mind that two of the votes for 'The X Factor' songs were in match-ups against rubbish b-sides. Some of these were tough choices too.
 
If I was to make a top 16 I think these two albums would be right next to each other. Two opposite sides of the Maiden spectrum and NOTB is an album I’d probably go out of my way for more, but X Factor just barely gets the win.
 
6-5 NOTB. In this case, an album I rank higher (TXF) loses out to a lower one.

"Sign of the Cross", "Man On the Edge", "Look For the Truth", "Blood On the World's Hands" and "2 AM" from TXF. The rest is TNOTB.
 
6-5 NOTB. In this case, an album I rank higher (TXF) loses out to a lower one.

"Sign of the Cross", "Man On the Edge", "Look For the Truth", "Blood On the World's Hands" and "2 AM" from TXF. The rest is TNOTB.
On a second thought, I think "The Prisoner" actually wins over "Man On the Edge". Which makes for a 7-4 win for an album I rank lower. Huh.
 
Back
Top