Mafia: Game 1: Mafia wins!

Did you enjoy this game?

  • Total voters
    12
Cornfed Hick said:
Since there are so many new players, I'm guessing that at least one or two mods are Mafia, as they already have offline discussions anyway and it's easy to discuss amongst themselves. So, SMX is a reasonable guess, as is Perun and NP.
Click to expand...
It would only make sense.

I nominate SMX to die.
 
Last edited:
SMX is too obvious. I nominate Knick since he's clearly trying to draw attention away from himself.

Also second CFH if that's an official nomination.
 
I only count bolded marks as nominations. Which is why SMX is not on the block right now.
 
I'm nothing more than a simple villager who enjoys fine ale. Believe what you will.

I haven't heard enough from the other players to make a nomination yet. When does this first day round end?
 
LooseCannon said:
All roles were randomly assigned.
Click to expand...
Well, in that case, I'm not seconding SMX. No basis for RTC's nomination. (LC, it was in bold, btw.)
mckindog said:
Cornfed Hick is a lawyer.
By definition, he can't be innocent.
Click to expand...
Hurtful. Didn't say I was innocent, just said I was a villager. Not Mafia. No comment whether I am a Doctor or Police.

I continue to think the odds aren't in villagers' favor -- likely to kill one of their own -- on day 1. Remember, Mafia know who the villagers are. So, people making nominations at this point are likely Mafia members trying to thin the herd. Mosh is awful quick on the nominations...
 
Last edited:
*Sees SMX drop a piece of paper, look around with a worried look on his face, and quickly pick it up again*

Oh, I am the town doctor in case anyone needs medical attention.
 
Last edited:
Cornfed Hick said:
Since there are so many new players, I'm guessing that at least one or two mods are Mafia, as they already have offline discussions anyway and it's easy to discuss amongst themselves. So, SMX is a reasonable guess, as is Perun and NP.
Click to expand...

Nope. Haven't checked the forum or communicated with anyone since my last post.

Being new to this sort of thing, I feel like I should throw some wild unfounded accusations around.

Ariana is immune to the Rush Bias that has got hold of the rest of us. Clearly her mind is clouded and we should not trust her.
Brigantium has a Latin name but lives in England. Evidently an infiltrator with an agenda.
Collin was seen with a box of batteries, two magnets and blueprints. He's building something dangerous.
Cornfed Hick is a lawyer. Enough reason to kill him right there.
mckindog makes all our sentences look wrong because he didn't start his name with a capital letter. Mr. DICKtionary is twitching.
Mosh can't play an F minor scale at 160 bpm faster than I can. Kill him so he can practice more.
MrKnickerbocker is neither a knicker nor a bocker. Discuss.
Night Prowler is awake all night all the time. Probably an assassin.
Perun would kill to have his degree done with. Too dangerous to be left alive.
RTC rushes to judgement. This proves he has inside information and is a cheater.
SinisterMinisterX is the only sure villager. I wouldn't trust the lot of ya with a burnt out match.
Stardust is Stardust. I have no clue.
Travis The Dragon is a bandwaggoner. No true Minnesotan is a Packers fan. This is an abomination.
Unknown One is too mysterious. Undoubtedly hiding something.

In the name of all that is Green And Gold, I nominate Travis.
 
Cornfed Hick said:
Well, in that case, I'm not seconding SMX. No basis for RTC's nomination. (LC, it was in bold, btw.)
Click to expand...
I know, we need a second before we move to a vote.

Current nominations:
SinisterMinisterX by RTC
MrKnickerbocker by Mosh
Travis by SMX

I'm not counting Collin's second because it's an edit. I recommend reposting it @Collin.
(No editing, good thing Foro didn't sign up!)
 
Cornfed Hick said:
By the way, might we be better off letting the mafia get the first kill, as opposed to lynching one of our own and potentially going down 0-2? The first round is pretty much blind luck anyway.

Yes, I'm a law-abiding villager. Don't expect you to necessarily believe that, but there you have it.
Click to expand...

I'm a raw rookie and maybe shouldn't be asking, but how can you let somebody do anything at this point?
Or are you basically saying don't lynch anyone? That's allowed?
 
Travis The Dragon said:
*Sees SMX drop a piece of paper, look around with a worried look on his face, and quickly pick it up again*

Oh, I am the town doctor in case anyone needs medical attention.
Click to expand...

And Travis could easily be lying, right?

(Sorry for the dumb questions)
 
@mckindog, we don't have to lynch anyone. If three days go by without anyone being put up then it will hit the next night phase. And even if someone is put up, we don't have to find them guilty.

If Travis is actually doctor, then it was pretty bad coming forward like that. Of course he could be lying, and if he is lying then he's much more likely to be Mafia than a Citizen. And the real doctor will know 100% that he's lying which would be useful later.

That said, I'm all up for gathering more info, so I'd like to second Travis because it is sus that he willingly comes into the open this early.
 
I think it's pretty obvious the way SMX tried to fool us into thinking he's right-handed.
 
There are many people who have gotten service from me at my office and they will attest to that.

I nominate SMX. He did look pretty damn freaked out when he dropped that piece of paper.
 
Plus, I was told I'm a doctor:
b0d9eHL.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top