Clue #3: The song we're looking for has not been played live. The two songs mentioned in clue #1, on the other hand, have been played live.
Previous Clues:
Clue #1: The song we are looking for references a character in the lyrics. The same character is referenced in a song on the previous album. A few albums earlier there was even a song about that same character and titled after them.
Clue #2: Multiple songs on the same album as our mystery song have the same exact songwriting credits as the song we are looking for.
Incorrect Guesses: Back In The Village, The Prophecy, Fates Warning, Hooks In You, From Here To Eternity, Judas Be My Guide