Re: 'For The Greater Good Of God'
Maverick said:
"Without the Americans, we'd all be speaking German by now." "Without the Crusades, women would be completely covered." What else? "Without Hitler we'd be under Jewish law"? "Without the Soviets, the American flag wouldn't be on the Moon"? *sigh*
Maiden Forever said:
This showed your true colors! You support anyone who hates Jews.
I think, Maiden Forever, that what Maverick meant (correct me if I'm wrong)
is that some people make sweeping and (incorrect) generalizations about groups of people, be they Muslim, German, Jewish, American, etc. Stereotypes are dangerous because they lead to bigotry and hatred. By the way, Maverick, do you have a special folder dedicated to all these impressive quotes?
I agree with Perun's reasoning about current global issues, in the sense that both the eastern and western sides are morally and politically at fault to some extent. I just have one thing to add, with the risk of getting political.
I agreed with the war against Osama Bin Laden, because of his
direct and lethal involvement with the murder of thousands of innocent lives. By virtue of Taliban's harbouring Bin Laden, that government needed to be taken down, simply as a matter of self-defence and no more. I don't know what exactly possessed the American government to stop pursuing Al-Qaeda and switch the majority of their focus on Iraq. (Some say oil, some say revenge or WMDs, which we later learned was a complete lie). They could have cought him if they did not falter, and if Bush did not start denouncing any and every country that does not practice Western democracy as "part of the axis of evil". That was not very smart to say the least.
The war in Iraq is a sham. Most Americans now believe this, as well. There is no way out now without having the US government, particularly Bush, looking like complete baffoons. USA can win militarily, but with their actions they cannot win morally or practically as many Iraqis remember Bush Sr.'s betrayal. I'm referring to the fact that Bush Sr. promised to help Kurds fight Sadam Hussein, but backed out only to leave them at the Iraqi dictator's mercy. The current forceful method of convincing Iraqis that "democracy is better" does not change anyone's opinions. With the exception of Fox News, the un"fair" and un"balanced" far right propaganda, most media outlets are showing that the situation and support within Iraq is diminishing. Furthermore, USA's foreign policy makes this global power less and less diplomatically influential in the world today, both in western Europe and elsewhere.
By the way, the term Islamo-fascism is technically not correct and I don't know why Bush keeps calling it that. Perhaps it is because America is moving more and more into fascisim themselves. For example, as Perun points out, many American companies rub elbows with dictators in order to establish a strong presence there. Of course, the US government benefits as this gives them tax money and indirectly controls the poorer countries as they can threaten "economic embargo" when it suits their needs.
As far as the song is concerned, Maiden Forever, here are my reasons why it is not just about fundamentalist Islam. I'll use only one verse, as it'll suffice.
A life that's made to breathe destruction or defense
A mind that's vain corruption bad or good intent
A wolf in sheep's clothing
Or saintly or sinner
Or some that would believe
A holy war winner
This could be about America, or better yet (as I think that most Americans are good people) it could be about George W. Bush. Is the current war in Iraq about self-defense or about selfish motives? Regardless of the motives, though, Bush's vanity will lead to corruption. At first, he seemed like a sheep, meek and defenceless. Is he a wolf now? Will he be a holy war winner? Yes, I do believe, Bush is waging a holy war. His fundamentalist views on such issues as abortion, gay rights and evolution are typical of an extreme rightist philosophy. He'd be more vocal, too, if he was not worried about losing votes (and I'm not being cynical).
The reason why Maiden does not mention either fundamentalist Bush or Islam is twofold. First, one can write a deep song without getting into personal names. This also makes the song more timeless as it can be more relevant to the future generations. Secondly, it is wise not to cause unnecessary harm by calling out against a particular group of people when they are not the only guilty ones. Any intelligent person will be able to interpret that FTGGOG is criticizing fundamentalist Islam as much as any fundamentalist religion. Also there are many people, both in the Middle East and the western world, that just learn to hate just because "they're different". This conflict will go on and on, sadly, and decades from now most people will not even bother to point out or remember that it was religious at one point. Some people will hate, simply because at one point in history "those people" harmed us. Even Pavlov's dog learned to stop salivating at some point. (Now I am being cynical).
I think it was Thomas Jefferson who said that if America's great democracy fails, it will fail within and it will fail because Americans have unwittingly let fascist ideologies take root. (I'm sure someone will correct me here if I'm wrong). Except, if my mind is not tricking me, I believe, Jefferson used another word akin to but not "fascism"; it could be what Mussolini later called "corporatism" where large businesses and governments are really one and the same. Before the Vietnam war, most Americans supported their politicians and believed in the democratic process. Ironically, today when Bush wages war in the name of democracy, most American citizens (62% by the latest vote I saw) do not believe that their democracy is functioning properly. There is something both wrong and scary about that. The rising of Hitler is reminiscent of this phenomenon.
By the way, Maiden Forever, I'm neither a "conservative" nor a "liberal". I'm a libertarian in the political spectrum and as a Canadian, and hopefully I'm not generalizing here, I can say that I feel more sympathy for Americans than most of the non-American world.
OK, so it was more than
one point I wanted to make. This is not the first time I've done that.
I would really appreciate a response from you Maiden Forever and from anyone else.