Kalata
Out of the Silent Planet
Shame indeed. One can have an opinion ofc, the original has its charm, and BTP's new mix isn't perfect (a bit muddy, thin drums), but Roy doesn't like it because he wasn't part of the production team. And the band now. He/we know that some songs benefit from the heavier sound, and iirc, he and Bruce have said before that they would like to remix it, so. Also, such a work is better than a remaster, like a curious bonus.
More or less, this. The thing is, BTP and maybe AOB/TCW are his solo albums that overall will benefit from, so to speak, some heavy power in the mix (like other 70's, 80's even 90's albums, it's normal). SW has its own specific style and sound. TM and TOS are perfect, what a drum sound in the latter.
Last edited:
If Roy hadn't been making comments this whole time I'd agree that it's just a guy having his opinion, but he just can't stop being negative. I don't think he cares, it could have sounded incredible and he'd crap on it.
Jer
'Til Tomorrow
So unprofessional. Who would ever want to work with this guy after he’s repeatedly behaved this way?
TheTalisman
Ancient Mariner
The best version!
Yax
Ancient Mariner
Well, he is right about this. I do not like what they did with "Tears..."
Though if I were him, I would not post that online.
redandtheblack92
Time to meet your maker
Heard a few tracks off more balls. My thoughts:
Cyclops - sounds okayish
Gods of war - sounds kinda similar to original
Laughing in the hiding bush - bye bye vocals. Too muffled and sounds bad
Change of heart - too much disturbance and the quietness off the original one got destroyed
Fire - decent
Tears- destroyed
Cyclops - sounds okayish
Gods of war - sounds kinda similar to original
Laughing in the hiding bush - bye bye vocals. Too muffled and sounds bad
Change of heart - too much disturbance and the quietness off the original one got destroyed
Fire - decent
Tears- destroyed
Vaenyr
Ancient Mariner
Absolutely!
