You have the old school folks who tend to put the classic trilogy at the top. Then you have the folks who love the more recent era. There are also those who really appreciate the mid to late 80s glam type era, which seems to get more love as time goes on.
Yes, a lot of newer fans start with the classic trilogy too. It’s quite a good trilogy, Wheels of Steel I believe was the best they sounded during that time. Strong Arm and Denim and Leather play like one album to me, they sound very similar.
It’s almost shocking how well the “glam” stuff Saxon did has aged. A lot of bands like Saxon from that time went too poppy in an attempt to capture mainstream success but Saxon really hit a good balance between staying fairly heavy and putting bigger melodies into their songs. A couple years ago when I listened to Destiny I hated it, I thought it was boring and uninspired. Upon relisten I was really struck by the AOR elements and excellent song writing. Destiny also is probably Biffs best sounding vocals!
Rock the Nations is more metal than a lot of people think, although it is a step down (quality wise) from Innocence. The second side of Rock the Nations also drags a little bit but there’s gems throughout the album like Waiting For the Night, Runnin Hot, and We Came Here to Rock (awesome riff).
I find a lot of the more recent stuff sounds a bit basic and repetitive to me, but still good in its own way.
I am with you on that. If you played a couple of songs each from Battering Ram, Thunderbolt and Carpe Diem all back to back I probably wouldn’t be able to tell you their names or what albums they were from. With a lot of Saxons albums from the 2000s and onwards, I think they would’ve been better off releasing albums at a slower pace with higher quality material or just releasing EPs or singles with a few songs. Randomly they’ll have an awesome song buried in each of their recent releases. Lady in Gray off Carpe Diem is excellent, and I don’t see it talked about much.
Also the hype for the newest album was real, that album is really, really good.
1. Unleash the Beast (1997)
2. Crusader (1984)
3. Dogs of War (1995)
4. Lionheart (2004)
5. Solid Ball of Rock (1991)
6. Power and the Glory (1983)
7. Killing Ground (2001)
8. Thunderbolt (2018)
9. Sacrifice (2013)
10. Strong Arm of the Law (1980)
11. Wheels of Steel (1980)
12. Rock the Nations (1986)
13. Forever Free (1992)
14. Metalhead (1999)
15. Destiny (1988)
16. Denim and Leather (1981)
17. Innocence is No Excuse (1985)
18. The Inner Sanctum (2007)
19. Call to Arms (2011)
20. Battering Ram (2015)
21. Into the Labyrinth (2009)
22. Hell Fire and Damnation (2024)
23. Carpe Diem (2022)
24. Saxon (1979)
Very interesting and unique rankings. We see Strong Arm of the Law and Solid Ball of Rock very similarly. Unleash the Beast at 1 isn’t very surprising, that one drew a lot of fans back into Saxon it seems. There’s a light speed metal edge to that album too in a lot of the riffing. Good songs on there like Bloodletter and Circle of Light (great guitar on Circle of Light).
Also do you have Saxon in last because you have not heard it? It’s worth checking out if you like the classic trilogy. It has a little more of a pub band feel, but there’s standouts like Backs to the Wall and Stallions of the Highway. My favorite off there is Militia Guard, which is surprisingly mature and very well written.