I've given this album a few spins now, and I must say I think it's their strongest since Carolus Rex. There's some obvious complaints, such as the songs not breathing enough before lyrics enter (a problem the band has had since Heroes), but this album is incredibly consistent. Even the few tracks I think are weaker than the others are not filler, as they contain either infectiously catchy choruses or glorious instrumental sections - and often both.
I'm going to agree with
@Diesel 11 quite a bit in my review (happy birthday by the way!)
01. Sarajevo
Musically, this kicks off an album that sees the band diversifying their musical palate quite a bit. I
really don't like the narration, though, as it breaks up some really neat music. Cool instrumental bit in the middle. This will eventually fit in with the closing track in a pretty cool fashion. Also I have zero clue what the band was thinking leaving this track off of the version of the album that 99% of people will hear.
02. Stormtroopers
This sets the world (and probably the battlefield) on fire! I love the neoclassical guitars, and did not expect this at all. This is a fun, energetic, technical song that will probably kick all sorts of ass live. Definitely reminiscent of old-school Sabaton.
03. Dreadnaught
Now this is my kind of song! It may not reach the "naval battle god tier" of Wolfpack and Bismarck, but it fits in nicely with those tracks. The band has flirted with odd time signatures before (see Cliffs of Gallipoli and Wehrmacht), but this is more complex. An even pulse of 4 is broken up with alternating meters of 5 and 6, respectively. I think it perfectly captures the unpredictability of the ocean. I also love it for having some breathing room before the vocals enter (I would have played the entire riff twice first, to be honest, but I'll take what I can get). Great chorus with a catchy synth line, and another excellent instrumental section with stunning solo. This is one of the highlights of the album for me, even if it's essentially a dance song!
04. The Unkillable Soldier
When I first heard this song, I thought it was Sabaton-paint-by-numbers. But now I can't get it out of my head! That chorus - especially the intensity of it and the brilliant key change at the end - is an incredible earworm. The rapid-fire style of lyrics in the chorus really emulate bursts of gunfire on the battlefield, and the drumming is powerful and bouncy (all those tom rolls in the pre-choruses is an example). Another highlight.
05. Soldier of Heaven
I was thinking a weak song would have to pop up soon, but nope! Another killer here. The whole thing is beyond cheesy, but you can't beat that chorus or the building nature of the verses. I'm a sucker for cheesy '80s synth, and this song delivers it in buckets. There are times when the song reminds me of The Final Solution (in the second verse and solo) or that sweet mustard gas song from the previous album. This will be another fun one live!
06. Hellfighters
Well, since Iced Earth won't be doing much for a while, it's only fitting that Sabaton decided to pay tribute to them (unintentionally, I'm sure). It's a punchy, dynamic track that never lets its foot off the gas pedal, even if it is the weakest song yet (aside from the opener). I don't like the vocals starting so soon, but here it doesn't really bother me given the nature of the song. Neat instrumental bit in the middle with the key changes, and sick shredding, too.
07. Race to the Sea
I
really don't like the immediate start to the verse, but this song's chorus is another earworm. It reminds me of something from Carolus Rex, and while it's probably the weakest non-Sarajevo track yet, it's not filler. The constant bass gallop is catchy, and the solo and bridge delivers. I love the buildup with the snare drum, too.
08. Lady of the Dark
Well, this is different. I love punchy, dynamic, start-stop riffs that breathe, and the harmonics are a nice touch. Again, the vocals enter too soon (this album could be a good five minutes longer if it had proper intros for each song), but this is a fun little track. Once again, the instrumental section shines here, with a melodic solo over a refreshing locked-in bass groove. Another chorus key change, too, which the band is pretty solid at. The ending sucks, though.
09. The Valley of Death
This is the only song that hasn't really hit me yet. It's fun and energetic (is it weird calling songs about war "fun?"), but I feel like it's missing something. The chorus buildup is cool, and the chorus employs that rapid-fire lyric style again. This sounds like older Sabaton, though, like something from The Art of War or Coat of Arms. Can't complain there. I get a lot of similarities to the vibe of Soldier of 3 Armies on this album, and I'll never complain about that! The best part of this song is easily the instrumental section, which is melodic and has a solo that opens Symphony X-style!
10. Christmas Truce
From an overall compositional standpoint, it's hard to argue that this isn't the strongest song here. This is a magnificent song - from the piano to Joakim's passionate singing, to the choral chants, to the instrumental section - just wow. It has that "group sing-along" vibe that reminds me of Gott Mit Uns, although obviously with a different feel. I can't say enough good things about it. I even cracked a beer open as I write this because this song practically demands it!
11. Versailles
Ugh, that horrible narration again. Then we get into Maiden territory (The Legacy?) before hinting at WWII by turning increasingly darker after the second chorus. A guitar solo acts as a bridge to this ominous change of tone, which recalls the chorus of Sarajevo. This track (and the opener) would be
so much stronger without the out-of-place narration; I can't stress that enough. Stuff like that was fine when it was a sentence or two on The Art of War (even though I didn't like it then), but it comprises like half of these songs!
As I said before, this album could have benefitted from an extra five or so minutes by giving many of the songs proper introductions. When a song gets to the verse too soon, in my mind the songwriters are saying
our music isn't catchy enough on its own, so let's get to the vocals quickly or else people will lose interest. That's just not what I look for in music; remember that this is
metal, not pop. Nevertheless, this is a
really good album, and it caught me by surprise! I was expecting another half-filler effort like the previous album or the even weaker Last Stand, but I'm quite impressed!
Highlights:
Dreadnaught
The Unkillable Soldier
Soldier of Heaven
Christmas Truce