Piece of Mind: individual album judgement by yours truly

Mosh

And I should contemplate this change
Staff member
10
10
8
9
10
10
7
8
9

9
 
Last edited:

Mosh

And I should contemplate this change
Staff member
Actually makes sense. Killers was my favorite last time I did this and Piece of Mind is my favorite currently.
 

desultory

1-2-3-compassion
Where Eagles Dare - 9
Revelations - 10
Flight of Icarus - 9
Die With Your Boots On - 9
The Trooper - 10
Still Life - 10
Quest For Fire - 7
Sun and Steel - 8
To Tame a Land - 10

9,1
Piece of Mind is my #3 album.
 
Last edited:

harrisdevot

Priest of the Holy Wristband
Where Eagles Date : 9,5
Revelations : 7
Flight of Icarus : 8
Die with your Boots On : 8,5
The Trooper : 8,5
Still Life : 9
Quest for Fire : 8
Sun and Steel : 4
To Tame a Land : 10

8

A great album, the best guitar sound they ever had, a fantastic cover illustration, but Revelations ans Sun and Steel should never have been there. And yes, I find Quest for Fire a lot more enjoyable than Revelations : decent riffs, good vocal melodies, great bridge, fantastic solos.
 

Cosmiceddie

Back From The Edge
1. Where Eagles Dare 10/10
2. The Trooper 10/10

3. Flight Of Icarus 9/10
4. Revelations 9/10
5. To Tame A Land 9/10

6. Still Life 8/10
7. Die With Your Boots On 7/10
8. Quest For Fire 7/10

9. Sun And Steel 5/10

Piece Of Mind is my #7 Maiden album
 

Forostar

Ancient Mariner
1. The Trooper 10/10
2. To Tame a Land 10/10

3. Die With Your Boots On 9/10
4. Flight of Icarus 9/10
5. Quest for Fire 9/10

6. Still Life 8/10
7. Where Eagles Dare 8/10

8. Sun and Steel 7/10
9. Revelations 7/10

Based on these ratings:
- Piece of Mind album score: 8,56
- Piece of Mind is my #5 Maiden album.
 
Last edited:

TheTalisman

Fågel
Where Eagles Dare - 8
Revelations - 10
Flight of Icarus - 9
Die With Your Boots On - 8
The Trooper - 8
Still Life - 10
Quest For Fire - 7
Sun And Steel - 8
To Tame A Land - 7

8,3
 

harrisdevot

Priest of the Holy Wristband
Where Eagles Dare - 8
Revelations - 10
Flight of Icarus - 9
Die With Your Boots On - 8
The Trooper - 8
Still Life - 10
Quest For Fire - 7
Sun And Steel - 8
To Tame A Land - 7

8,3
Wow, you rank Sun and Steel higher than To Tame a Land :huh:.
 
Last edited:

frus

Barbed Wire Hen
Where Eagles Dare 8
Revelations 10
Flight of Icarus 6
Die With Your Boots On 8
The Trooper 8
Still Life 9
Quest For Fire 6
Sun and Steel 6
To Tame a Land 9

Piece Of Mind 7,78
#4
 

Naty

Educated Fool
Where Eagles Dare - 9
Revelations - 10
Flight of Icarus - 9
Die With Your Boots On - 8
The Trooper - 10
Still Life - 10
Quest For Fire - 7
Sun and Steel - 7
To Tame a Land - 9

8,7
 

BeThyJames

Trooper
Revelations 10
Flight of Icarus 9
To Tame a Land 8
The Trooper 8
Still Life 7
Where Eagles Dare 7
Sun and Steel 7
Die With Your Boots On 6
Quest for Fire 5

Piece of Mind. 7.4
 
Last edited:
Where Eagles Dare 9
Revelations 9
Flight Of Icarus 9
Die With Your Boots On 9
The Trooper 9
Still Life 8
Quest For Fire 8
Sun and Steel 8
To Tame a Land 9

Album Average 8.67

I'm surprised at quite how good absolutely everything on PoM really is. What an album!

Album rankings per person thread >
 
Last edited:
Top