Piece of Mind: individual album judgement by yours truly

Forostar

Ancient Mariner
Explanation -> here

Piece of Mind (1983) by individual members:

9,3 Jeffmetal
9,1 Travis_AKA_fonzbear2000
8,8 Fugazi
8,7 Perun
8,7 Vap
8,6 Nightprowler666
8,4 bearfan
8,4 maidenhead1996
8,4 _____no5
8,2 czgibson
8,2 mckindog
8,2 Stallion Duck
8,1 Eddies Wingman
8,1 Forostar
7,9 Jonszat
7,8 Black_Thunder
7,8 taker64
7,8 Unknown One
7,6 Invader
7,6 Zare
7,4 Albie
7,1 LooseCannon
6,9 Ranko
6,8 Genghis Khan
 

Genghis Khan

Ancient Mariner
Where Eagles Dare – 7
Revelations – 9
Flight of Icarus – 4
Die with Your Boots on – 10
The Trooper – 9
Still Life – 7
Quest for Fire -- 3
Sun and Steel -- 5
To Tame a Land – 7
6,78 average

This means PoM is rated lower than Killers and NotB.  Usually when ranking albums I rank PoM higher.  It goes to show that I usually rank it on past memory rather than recent opinion.  I gave it the lowest rating.  :(

Though if I were to use my past feelings, it'll be more of an 7,56 average.  Big difference with four songs getting a 10.
 

______no5

The Angel Of The Odd
Where Eagles Dare –10
Revelations –9
Flight of Icarus –10
Die with Your Boots on –8
The Trooper –10
Still Life –8
Quest for Fire –5
Sun and Steel –7
To Tame a Land –9

Average: 8,444
 

Edu_Smith

Eduardo
Where Eagles Dare –10
Revelations –10
Flight of Icarus –10
Die with Your Boots on –10
The Trooper –10
Still Life –10
Quest for Fire –9
Sun and Steel –9
To Tame a Land –10

Average: 9,78
 

The Flash

Dennis Wilcock did 9/11
Where Eagles Dare : 8
Revelations : 10
Flight of Icarus : 10
Die With Your Boots On : 8
The Trooper : 10
Still Life : 9
Quest for Fire : 4
Sun and Steel : 7
To Tame a Land : 10

Avg : 8,44
 

Perun

And the world, unheeding, turns
Staff member
Caught up with this one.

Where Eagles Dare: 9
Revelations: 10
Flight of Icarus: 8
Die With Your Boots On: 9
The Trooper: 10
Still Life: 10
Quest for Fire: 6
Sun and Steel: 6
To Tame a Land: 10
 

Eddie

Invader
Where Eagles Dare: 10
Revelations: 10
Flight of Icarus: 10
Die With Your Boots On: 8
The Trooper: 10
Still Life: 10
Quest for Fire: 8
Sun and Steel: 8
To Tame a Land: 10
 

Forostar

Ancient Mariner
Sorry Eddie, this is not the way to do it. Please post your review in the song topics, and mention your ranking in these topics as well.
 

LooseCannon

Yorktown-class aircraft carrier
Staff member
Eddie, I'd appreciate if you vote in the polls in each album thread if you haven't already. Thanks :)

Foro, at this stage of the game, if you just want to see where you lay amongst everyone else and don't have anything to add to the discussion, wouldn't it be easier on you to get people's rankings here, rather than have them make 8 - 12 disparate posts?
 

Forostar

Ancient Mariner
I see the votings and the reviews (posts) as the most important matters of our Commentary forums. The stats are purely something coming out of it, and these individual album judgements have some rules I was referring to.

I can imagine that most people prefer to write about the songs they are judging, and if people are new here, they might be unaware of that possibility.

Looking at the stats, I guess it's best to not update the tables too often (not after every change by every member).

But seen from a practical point of view, it might not be a bad idea if people only want to update their grade, that they can post this here, like you suggested. But if they wish to post it in the song topic, that'd be fine for me too, because there won't be as much updating as in the current "season". ;)
 

Saapanael

Breathe, it’ll be okay
Where Eagles Dare – 9
Revelations – 8
Flight of Icarus – 8
Die with Your Boots on – 9
The Trooper – 10
Still Life – 7
Quest for Fire -- 7
Sun and Steel -- 8
To Tame a Land – 9

Average: 8 and 1/3

Today I realised that this album doesn't have a single bad song.
 
Where Eagles Dare: 8
Revelations: 9
Flight of Icarus: 8
Die With your Boots On: 9
The Trooper: 10
Still Life: 10
Quest for Fire: 7
Sun and Steel: 8
To Tame a Land: 8

Average: 8.5
 
Where Eagles Dare: 8
Revelations: 10
Flight of Icarus: 9
Die With Your Boots On: 7
The Trooper: 8
Still Life: 10
Quest For Fire: 7
Sun and Steel: 8
To Tame a Land: 10

8.56. I thought for sure it'd be higher. Still, I think this album is pretty perfect.
 

harrisdevot

Priest of the Holy Wristband
Where Eagles Dare : 9
Revelations : 3
Flight of Icarus : 5
Die with your Boots on : 6
The Trooper : 7
Still Life : 7,5
Quest for Fire : 6
Sun and Steel : 2
To Tame a Land : 10
 

Collin

New Tool is coming!
Where Eagles Dare: 10
Revelations : 10
Flight of Icarus: 10
Die With Your Boots On: 10
The Trooper: 9.5
Still Life: 10
Quest For Fire: 3
Sun and Steel: 9
To Tame a Land: 10
Average 9.0
 
Top