Nicko McBrain retires

What a night! Performance-wise, I honestly think they nailed every song, but the atmosphere was so intense that I don’t fully trust my judgment tonight. Too much emotion. For example, I had the impression that Bruce gave his best performance ever on DOFP, which wouldn’t make sense since it’s like his 100th show this year. But hey, I can assure you it was, at least, very good.

Anyway, what a night! God bless Nicko, Maiden, and all of us so we can keep following this band that makes our lives lighter.
 
Nicko left in one of the classiest ways possible, the man had a stroke, 5 months later is on tour, at the end of the first leg announces the stroke explaining people's doubts in his performance, then nearly 2 years after his stroke announces that he will retire following 1 more show. It was a privilege to see Maiden 4 times (all since 2019) and while it may be different seeing Maiden without him, Nicko had nothing more to prove.

Up the Irons! From those who've rocked, Nicko we salute you.
 
Yes, a cute gesture. I think they have grown even closer this year for more than just one reason.

I can understand the arguments some posted why it is difficult for Nicko to appear on stage now and then and play one or a few songs with Maiden.

But I had the weird idea he could be (one of) the opening bands with Titanium Tart now and then. What do you think about that?
 
You can only pay Nicko the greatest respect for the way he worked his way back and how he had the strength to retire at the right moment for him.
But it must be painful that he can't end his career after the Anniversary tour, don't you think?
That would theoretically have been more fitting.

But I already wrote many pages ago that there must be an acceptance in the band for a live band without Nicko for a while already. As a professional band, you don't announce a huge two-year tour when the drummer has had a stroke and just hope for the best.
 
Yes! I couldn't add anything about Nicko that hasn't already been posted.


Absolutely. In my humble opinion, it is somewhat contradictory how on the one hand the big shoes that need to be filled are emphasised, but on the other hand Joe Lazurus often is mentioned as the favourite.
When disappointed fans say that he would never be in Iron Maiden if he was any Joe Miller, he couldn't even dismiss them as stupid haters because that is true.
You could only hope that he is a mentally very strong guy.
That's one of the reasons why I want someone more recognised. Someone who knows what he has already achieved and won't be so easily thrown off course by the criticism that surely will to come his way.

I agree with you on that topic.
That is why I proposed someone on Mickey Dees level, where no metalhead would have to look up who on earth that is and what he already has acomplished.
 
Theres contracts already signed. Steve and Rod can not simply tell that they are not doing anymore. Thats why they decided (mutually probably) to go on with a new drummer. At least for this upcoming tour.
Ok, but I think they knew about Nicko's retirement before announcing the new ''50th anniv'' tour. I also think it was mutual.
If they will keep going after run for your lives, no one here knows.
True. But I think they will because of the huge change.
I think Nicko would have told the band to continue for as long as they would like.
He already said that a few years ago.
Nicko, on the other hand, mentions some unspecified projects, and I think he's referring rather to things like a documentary or some interviews for the fanclub. There's probably a chance of him playing a song or two at a concert in Florida or London, but I'm not expecting too much.
No, Nicko will not be Maiden's drummer on any future studio material. His ability to perform at the level he and the band require and are accustomed to has been affected by both age and the effects of his stroke. Those chops will not return. There are patterns and strokes he simply cannot play any longer at tempo.
Read the announcement again; Rod clearly says how much the band will miss him and that he'll always be part of the family. You don't miss someone whom you plan on spending time with in the studio. It's done.
As for future guest appearances at any live shows, doubtful. Leaving the band after forty-two years is like leaving a marriage. You don't want to see your ex getting along with the new guy...and in the case of the band, they're going to want to make the new drummer as comfortable as possible so he can give his best performance. Having the musician you replaced hanging around isn't conducive to fostering such an environment.
Its time for Nicko to enjoy his family and his life. Once you break that routine of recording/rehearsing/performing/traveling/practicing/exercising to stay fit and in his case, intensive therapy to try to regain your ability, it's impossible to just get up onstage at a show as coordinated as is Maidens and just bash out "The Trooper" for old times' sake when you couldn't play it properly when you left.
Good points, but would Steve want to record in the studio with another drummer?
I don't think Maiden is stopping anytime soon. The band is still playing at a very high level live. What I am surprised by is that obviously Steve and Rod knew this day was coming and prepared for it by already have a new drummer in place. When I saw them in November I thought that Nicko was the one member that Steve would not replace when he retired. The band can most easily survive the loss of a guitarist; any combination of two of them can carry on (despite criticism of Janick yes, the man can play). Adrian already left once. Bruce has stated that if he couldn't carry on, he would want them to continue and would help in finding a great replacement singer. That leaves Nicko. With this news, apparently it is a whole new world as far as retirement goes. I don't think Steve has any consideration of doing so any time soon.
They are not ready to retire, the thought of semi-retirement should be out of the question now. I still can't believe they replaced a band member from this lineup and especially now, although it's best for Nicko. They won't do it again.
This may be a new age for the band, lets see how some new energy into the bands affects them
A new (younger, not Simon Dawson) drummer will bring energy, but I wouldn't call it a new age for the band. Nicko's groove is the key. I'm not sure if the band will want to write new music now, although it's kind of expected, even with the new drummer.
I can't imagine Nicko being completely out of the picture.
From Rod's statement:
"[...] and I am sure we can find a few more special ones around the Maiden family and FC!"
This is vague enough to mean anything, but it could also be read in a way that would allow another album with Nicko, or a couple of songs on future live shows. I imagine when the eventual final show will happen, given he's healthy enough, Nicko would play at least one song to mark the occasion.
This.
I want a session and professional guy with his own personality playing instead of a guy who tries to imitate Nicko
I think that's inevitable, but let's see.
I wonder if the guys have played with the new drummer already, without us knowing? Surely, they wouldn't hire a new drummer without knowing how well they perform together?
I guess so, but they have enough time.
This hits the nail on the head and is exactly what I was talking about when I said that Maiden without Nicko would be a different band.
100%!
Anyone else having "mixed feelings" about next year's tour?
Like, I love Maiden. They're my favorite band of all time but man the thought of seeing them live next yeat without Nicko pains my heart. The new drummer might be good and hey, they might even play songs Nicko couldn't have played anymore. But still.
Maybe it's the current emotion of today but I feel like it's really the end of a beautiful era. I probably can't listen to Maiden for a while now without having that same mixed feeling...
Same.
It seems, that Bruce's Freudian slip retirement sucks around TMP release, was not some random talk. He/they knew it already then...
Yeah...
But two things become clear: they did not change the setlist so it wasn't so taxing on Nicko, having to practice like 20 songs instead of 15, and it's also extremely likely that Alexander was included as a last hurrah from Nicko to the fans. The most requested song gets a proper live version featuring the lineup that recorded it, probably for the first and last time.
Probably.
I can understand the arguments some posted why it is difficult for Nicko to appear on stage now and then and play one or a few songs with Maiden.
Indeed.
 
Live from Sao Paulo:

Bruce before TWOTW (live from Nathalie Smith's Instagram):
"He is not leaving the band. He will just not be playing with us live anymore."

"Let this be the celebration of everything we have achieved together."
Well said, but it's still sad.
I love hearing those fills under Davey's solo. They're finally there and up to pace. Sure, he simplifies more than a few other things but considering the circumstances, it's more than enough. I'm glad his last gig includes the one song that he once cited as his proudest drumming achievement.
Yeah. Caught Somewhere In Time is for sure one of Nicko's best.
 
I personally would go for someone a little more recognizable with a professional experience (Maiden probably thinks the opposite). And younger. There aren't many such drummers, from the old ones too. Aquiles Priester is probably the best choice. But Nicko's groove is unique.
 
What would you say, how should the statement be understood?
The new drummer will be announced soon? Or maybe at the end of the year? New year, never era?
 
Back
Top