Well I'm not saying this guy is better than that guy, I'm talking about this particular cover. It just sounds too flat, there's no drama and urgency, and you can hear it best and most immediately in vocals and drums. Moreover, they went for the original sound and feel instead of trying to make it in their own style (unlike the already mentioned Tool's cover of NoQuarter, which is a fine example of taking a song and making it yours). Its just too... "štreberski" (don't know the right term in english but NP will understand)