Mafia: Game 1: Mafia wins!

Did you enjoy this game?


  • Total voters
    12
I don't trust RTC either and would strongly encourage the Cop to inquire about him. (Perun too.)

I'm not sold on Mosh's innocence, but this feels like a calculated hit to me...
It's definitely calculated, but based on imperfect info and lots of speculation.

Let's just say I hope I'm right about Mosh.
 
I'm so confident in my innocence that I will even vote yes in my own poll!

Now that is a pretty convincing argument. If it's a stunt, it's a hell of a ballsy stunt.

Also, I would be very careful trusting any thing RTC says. Sure his opinion seems well informed, but it seems like he is just eager to see someone lynched. He was the first to nominate SMX for example, and look how that turned out. He was also a yes voter for Collin who didn't seem to care whether or not he was innocent because we'd get information out of him. Y'all might not mind this now, but what are you going to do when he comes after you with the lynch mob?? Or even worse, when he kills you in your sleep as a member of the mafia?

I'm inclined to agree with you at this point. RTC seems highly suspicious.

I don't trust RTC either and would strongly encourage the Cop to inquire about him.

It's definitely calculated, but based on imperfect info and lots of speculation.

Let's just say I hope I'm right about Mosh.

Let's hope you are, too.

Either Mosh and Cornfed are innocent, or they are doing a very good tag-team effort to appear innocent.
 
@LooseCannon, can Mafia talk during the day in this setup?

I do admit to being hyper-aggressive, yes, but that's my playstyle as a whole, and I find it works for me in finding scum. If you would like to see my previous meta both as town and scum, you just need to ask.
 
I'm not entirely sold on Mosh being mafia, he has been suspicious, however I'll vote No.

I think Stardust and Knick are more suspect than him.
 
I feel like Mosh's "I'm not Mafia so I'm gonna vote for myself to prove it" is his last effort to try and stay alive. Well, I DON'T BELIEVE YOU!
 
I feel like Mosh's "I'm not Mafia so I'm gonna vote for myself to prove it" is his last effort to try and stay alive. Well, I DON'T BELIEVE YOU!
Maybe, but in the end it's your loss when it turns out I'm not mafia. Or maybe not, if you are mafia. o_O
 
I'm sorry, but it's just to hard for me to tell who is acting suspicious and such and put clues together. I just can't follow all of this. I am withdrawing from the game. Maybe if LC will allow it, someone else can take my place.
 
....and there's another villager lost. Not to mention whoever they decide to kill. If you're gonna lynch me you might as well just surrender to the mafia. :p
 
Well it looks like I'm gonna be lynched anyway. :facepalm: Here's some last minute speculation before I get to see all the answers. Maybe it'll be useful later on for y'all or maybe not. Plus baseless accusations are fun. :p

After I'm lynched and the mafia has their next kill, five villagers will have left the game or have been killed. Including the doctor, which means no heal. Of the remaining eight, three are mafia which leaves the village left with 5. Which means at this rate the mafia will win by the next "night".

Of the remaining players, these are the ones I'd be most suspicious of:

RTC - Has been eager to lynch right from the start. Not only was he the first to throw a nomination out there (for a villager no less), but he seems oddly suspicious of those who don't want to lynch people. He switche his focus from SMX to CFH merely for stating the valid concern that lynching someone early could put the town at a disadvantage. He then went from no suspicion of me to "90%" solely on the grounds that I too felt cautious of lynching someone on the first round after already losing one and about to lose another. I assume at least one member of the mafia is tasked with the role of riling the town up and encouraging them to lynch one of their own. Take my lynching as a learning experience and stop going after people he is suspicious of.

He's also the only member left who (at least claims to) has prior knowledge to this game. He could very well be using that to take advantage of those of us who are new. This might also have something to do with UO's murder, the other player familiar with this game.

Ariana - Quick to point fingers but has been quiet ever since. Strangely, RTC hasn't drawn attention to that, but drew attention to me being quiet. Also voted yes for Collin's lynching.

As for the others....

Night Prowler is the cop, because Barlow is a cop.

The wildcard here is Stardust who is just being Stardust. I think it'd be safest to let him live until two mafia are found. If everyone else seems innocent enough, then draw the focus to him.

Since many of us are new to this game, I think the ones asking questions about rules in public and generally following what everyone else is doing are innocent. The mafia members would be more likely to do that sort of thing privately with LC. So that eliminates Mckindog, Knick, and Collin from the equation. Would've also eliminated Travis had we not known already.
 
Since many of us are new to this game, I think the ones asking questions about rules in public and generally following what everyone else is doing are innocent. The mafia members would be more likely to do that sort of thing privately with LC. So that eliminates Mckindog, Knick, and Collin from the equation.
Don't make this assumption. I have directed all rules questions to this thread, except for Mafia-specific ones.
 
7 votes are in - more than half.

Mosh has been lynched by the village, tossed from a cliff to splatter unceremoniously on the rocks below. Poor guy.

Mosh was a villager. You all have innocent blood on your hands.

Night now begins!

It should be noted that I am going to talk with Travis regarding his role in the game - until I post that someone has withdrawn, they haven't. Keep this in mind.
 
Back
Top