Either tonight, or when all three night roles have given me their targets.
Mafia: Game 1: Mafia wins!
- Thread starter LooseCannon
- Start date
Travis The Dragon
AFTERGLOW!!!
Well, I'm still in hiding and I hope I'll survive the night.
The day dawns and you are shy one person.
@Unknown One was cut by the Mafia in his sleep. He is dead.
@Unknown One was cut by the Mafia in his sleep. He is dead.
R.I.P. UO 
RTC
Libera et impera!
I assume that means he was a villager. Bit of an oddball kill in my view, unsure how it would play into Mafia's tactics, so I won't read too deeply into it.
I'll vote Mosh for his shenanigans during Collin's lynch. Tentative play and inconsistency leads me to believe his behaviour is not entirely natural.
I'll vote Mosh for his shenanigans during Collin's lynch. Tentative play and inconsistency leads me to believe his behaviour is not entirely natural.
He was so young.
Cornfed Hick
Ancient Mariner
You can lynch me, but it'll be your own loss when you've lost another villager. 
UO's elimination makes sense. He never said anything that would suggest him being innocent or guilty, so killing him provides no real clues.
Unless Collin is mafia, I think at least one of the people who voted yes for him to be lynched could be mafia. I doubt all three are yes voters though. For the purposes of archiving, that's:
RTC
Mr. Knickerbocker
Perun
Ariana
All four of these people have been suspicious. RTC seems to be taking advantage of my being new to this game by jumping on any "odd behavior", even though I'm not mafia. He doesn't seem suspicious beyond that, though. Other three I'll think about. Knick seems the least suspicious I think, even though I nominated him initially.
UO's elimination makes sense. He never said anything that would suggest him being innocent or guilty, so killing him provides no real clues.
Unless Collin is mafia, I think at least one of the people who voted yes for him to be lynched could be mafia. I doubt all three are yes voters though. For the purposes of archiving, that's:
RTC
Mr. Knickerbocker
Perun
Ariana
All four of these people have been suspicious. RTC seems to be taking advantage of my being new to this game by jumping on any "odd behavior", even though I'm not mafia. He doesn't seem suspicious beyond that, though. Other three I'll think about. Knick seems the least suspicious I think, even though I nominated him initially.
Cornfed Hick
Ancient Mariner
Spoken like someone who is NOT on our team.You can lynch me, but it'll be your own loss when you've lost another villager.
MrKnickerbocker
clap hands
We do all seem suspicious! Since I know I'm not Mafia, that leaves me these three people as potential Mafia candidates, assuming that Collin is in fact not Mafia. If Collin is Mafia, which I'm still not ruling out, then my pool of suspicions opens up to everyone who voted "no" and becomes much more murky.
Just looking at these people (who I suspected before and suspected working in tandem), Perun and Ariana seem the most suspicious to me because of their relative inactivity in the thread. RTC, on the other hand, feels suspicious because of his supreme over-activity.
Aggggghhhhhhh, I need time to process this. I'll be in the tavern.
Everyone is suspicious. The inactive ones trying to lay low, the super active ones trying to be active so as not to be suspicious for laying low, the passionate Mafia haters who are trying not to look like Mafia...
Anyway, I'm thirding the Mosh nomination. He seems most suspicious to me.
Anyway, I'm thirding the Mosh nomination. He seems most suspicious to me.
I take it we don't get to hear the outcome of the cop's investigations, assuming the cop asked any questions last night? Would it be up to the cop to publicly reveal the outcome of any question asked (and thus risk giving away his/her identity to the Mafia)?
MrKnickerbocker
clap hands
Someone sure is interested in finding out who the cop is...
Unless the cop is Travis, I doubt he or she will reveal his or hers identity
MrKnickerbocker
clap hands
I hope Travis comes out with a screenshot of a message stating that he is playing the cop.
Or is interested in finding out if anyone has been ruled out of being Mafia. We don't want to lynch an innocent. Incidentally....someone sure is making frivolous remarks instead of coming up with concrete theories.
RTC
Libera et impera!
Or is interested in finding out if anyone has been ruled out of being Mafia. We don't want to lynch an innocent. Incidentally....someone sure is making frivolous remarks instead of coming up with concrete theories.
He's not the only one who feels that way incidentally. Why would a cop claim just to clear an innocent, especially with a claimed doctor? And would that not put another target on 2 people's heads, along with Travis?
Also, looking into activity causes a headache with the WIFOM it brings. There are so many variables that it really isn't anywhere close to a concrete tell. Tells can lie more in the behaviour and tone of a person as opposed to any kind of activity .
Travis The Dragon
AFTERGLOW!!!
Just to get a better idea of how this game works, how was it decided that Unknown One was killed?