Interesting question that my friend and I were discussing the other day; What artists have one album that really resonated with you, but nothing else in their discography managed to do the same?
These come to mind more or less immediately:
Obligatory Queensrÿche -
Operation: Mindcrime. A strange example as I tend to downright nearly hate the rest of the discography.
Green Day -
American Idiot
Bruce Dickinson -
Accident of Birth
Hard to say if they qualify, at first I was a fan of more, but over time Rush -
Clockwork Angels is more or less the only album of theirs I'd be voluntarily willing to put on.
Maybe Farewell to Kings or
Hemispheres on a particularily bright day, but that's about it.
Theocracy -
As the World Bleeds
Slayer -
South of Heaven
Chick Corea -
Return to Forever
The Smiths -
The Queen Is Dead (+ some singles, primarily Panic)
Coldplay -
Viva la Vida or Death and All His Friends
Tony MacAlpine -
Maximum Security
Stretching it to two ("parts"), but
Avantasia Part 1 + 2 is pretty much the only thing by Sammett (Avantasia + Edguy) I'm interested in ... and two of my favourite albums at that.
Wu-Tang Clan (and all its members, affiliates etc.) -
Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)
(Snoop Dogg -
Doggystyle, since we're at the hip hop)
Boston
- Boston
Clapton (outside Cream) -
Derek and the Dominos / Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs
Carrie Underwood - the debut
Danzig -
Earth A.D.
Lindisfarne -
Fog on the Tyne
Chicago - the debut (the entire first era with Kath is mostly good, but the first album is phenomenal and no other is)
10cc -
Sheet Music (+ cca 3 songs off
The Original Soundtrack and its reissue)
Avril Lavigne -
The Best Damn Thing. A stupid, but well-crafted pop with an attitude and certain feisty charm. Other than that, I don't like anything she put out except for My Happy Ending.
Howard Shore's LOTR and
Hobbit score is the best film score ever and the only film soundtrack that is in some ways comparable with actual classical. The rest of his work doesn't move me very much.
If I'm going to be brutally honest,
Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not announced one of the best bands ever and nothing else has really been up to that standard and we've been chasing the dragon ever since.