Forostar said:
I know it's getting more off-topic, but I'm curious what makes this video cool for you guys? There must be more videos with such ingredients?
I especially remember the black and white images, the close-ups of the double bass drum pedals, and basically the good edit-job. But perhaps the music itself helped a lot as well(?)
Like I said, it's simple, yet effective. Too many band videos are way too over-the-top, trying to throw in the kitchen sink in an attempt to get good airplay on MTV. With their budgets, they mostly end up appearing cliched and overdone. The very fact that the majority of the footage for 'One' is just the band playing in a warehouse focusses your attention on the little details, rather than overloading you with images.
As for other good metal videos...let me think.
Dark Tranquillity's 'Monochromatic Stains' has a good effect, with the entire video themed in black and white, and based on some film or another...quite unnerving (the band aren't in it). 'Lost to Apathy' takes the 'band playing in a warehouse' idea and adds in some nice effects, but it's a bit too basic.
Ah, yes. Motorhead. Killed By Death has a great plot...
-Chick comes out into her parent's living room, dressed in leopardskin trousers
-Dad berates her, then hears something, and turns to the wall
-Lemmy crashes through the wall on a motorbike
-Lemmy gets chased by police
-Lemmy gets beaten
-Lemmy gets shot
-Lemmy gets the electric chair treatment
-Lemmy bursts out of the grave on a motorbike
Also, the video for 'Sacrifice' is fairly metal. 'Volker, sing us the song of Death! We are prepared!'
Slayer's 'War Ensemble' works well in the same way 'One' does...B&W picture of the band playing. 'Seasons In The Abyss' is excellent, as well, as it just has the band in front of the Pyramids.
Other than that, most metal vids I've seen are either really overdone, really reliant on CGI, or some obscure and completely ridiculous storyline.