Clue #1: either a sharp or flat
Clue #2: "Anne, sister Anne, do you see anyone coming?"
Clue #3: Annuit cœptis
Clue #4: last played in 2005
Incorrect guesses: The Number of the Beast/ The Evil That Men Do/ The Angel and the Gambler/ Age of Innocence/ Phantom of the Opera/ Sanctuary/ Black Bart Blues/ 22 Acacia Avenue/ For the Greater Good of God/ Empire of the Clouds/ The Apparition/ Hooks in You