I have seen several posts about the role of media. On 2 January
PJ Harvey was guest editor for
BBC 4 Radio Today and a great deal of her programme was about
censorship. Lots of people found the programme (which was highly political) controversial, disliked it, or loved it.
It was slammed by listeners, MPs and even BBC staff over left-wing rants. More about the reactions here:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ds-Thought-Day-Ecuador-Embassy-bolt-hole.html
Now you may agree or not with the criticism on this programme, but I think that it says a lot about what is normally going on, on the radio (or at least: BBC radio), or even on media in general. Many people are not used to criticism, especially not at criticism on matters that stand so close to themselves.
Apparently, what she did was very different, or unusual. Her introduction:
When I was invited to be guest editor on Today, I saw it as an opportunity to try and do something unusual with the format and content of the programme.
I began by thinking of people I consider to be highly articulate, stimulating and extremely interesting to listen to – people who challenge us and move us to examine our deepest beliefs and feelings. I wanted to fill my programme with their voices.
Most importantly, I wanted to let them be heard in a manner of their choosing, whether that be a monologue, a poem, or interviewing others. What I didn’t want was for them to be restricted from saying what they wanted to say.
Before I accepted the invitation to be guest editor, I asked Today to agree to this, as well as agreeing not to edit my contributors pieces without their full consent.
I hope that the programme you hear, is the programme I wanted you to hear – I have come to realize that a great deal of its content is about censorship in one way or another.
As ideas for titles and topics to be discussed took shape, many poems and songs came into my mind. For me, music and poetry can be as persuasive and as powerful as a fine speaker and a fine speech. You will hear songs and poems supporting and highlighting the content of this programme.
I would like to thank my contributors for the time and care they have put into this project, and for the willing spirit with which they have entered into it.
As an artist, I try to make sense of the world through my work. I just try to get something down – look at it up close, from different angles. These people, these voices, help me make sense of it all.
Link to full programme:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b03mhyzh
Parts from PJ Harvey's Today programme, on BBC Radio 4, (not everything was broadcasted in this order):
- PJ Harvey spoken piece explaining her choice of contributors to the programme.
- Mark Curtis: 'Arming Repression', followed by 'Ladies of the World' song recording by Flight of the Conchords.
- Denis Halliday: 'The U.N. Security Council - Dump The Wolves'.
- Clive Stafford Smith: 'Is the N.H.S. the best thing about Britain?'
- Bruce Springsteen '57 Channels And Nothin' On'.
- John Pilger: 'Is the media now just another word for control?'
- Dr. Rowan Williams: 'Thought for the Day' in the form of one of his poems.
- Charles Simic poem, 'Austerities' read by Ralph Fiennes.
- Giles Duley: 'Behind The Faces Of War: the realities for injured servicemen', followed by Joan Baez, 'Johnny I Hardly Knew Ya'.
- Phil Shiner and Ian Cobain: 'How Britain taught the world to torture', followed by 'They Fight For Peace', a poem by Shaker Aamer, read by Ralph Fiennes.
- Julian Assange's 'Thought for the Day' followed by Woody Guthrie song lyric 'Ticky Tock' read by Ralph Fiennes.
- Weather/Business/Sport Sections
- Weather Section - Tom Waits 'Strange Weather' acoustic demo version.
- Business Section - John Rees: 'How the city of London rules the world', followed by the poem 'London' by William Blake, read by Ralph Fiennes.
- Sport Section - Dave Zirin: 'The effects of money and vested interests on sport'.
I haven't heard it all yet, but at the sixteenth minute, in the Business Section, there's an interesting view at the
City of London.
'How the city of London rules the world', followed by the poem 'London' by William Blake, read by Ralph Fiennes.