Please consider using edits if you want to add a comment, rather than making a string of individual posts.
BEST BAND EVER: Results!
- Thread starter Night Prowler
- Start date
karljant
Ancient Mariner
Ok got it. Only broke it in three because it was referring to different matters... but I guess the quotes are enough to put things into context.Please consider using edits if you want to add a comment, rather than making a string of individual posts.
Black Wizard
Pleb Hunter
I always thought it was commonly known forum etiquette not to multi-post.
Regardless, we don’t want multiposting. Please don’t do it for any reason.
Jari barely edges Hansi for me. Hansi has relied too much on overdubbing for most of his career even if he's a strong live singer too. Jari is a brilliant clean AND harsh vocalist.
I should've cut Skin, this band doesn't sound too much like rock. Pop, more like.
Warrel Dane is underrated. He blew out his voice after Sanctuary, but his voice on this album is super emotional and expressive.
I should've cut Skin, this band doesn't sound too much like rock. Pop, more like.
Warrel Dane is underrated. He blew out his voice after Sanctuary, but his voice on this album is super emotional and expressive.
Eliminated after Round 88:
Jari Mäenpää
Skin
Warrel Dane
Promoted after Round 88:
Hansi Kürsch
James LaBrie (solo, DREAM THEATER)
Jon Anderson (solo, YES)
Klaus Meine (SCORPIONS)
Tommy Karevik (KAMELOT, SEVENTH WONDER)
KidInTheDark666
What's yours is mine and what's mine is mine too
LaBrie 
Tommy. I can't do LaBrie.
Tricky. I'm an Anderson fan, but not sure where his voice would fit in the ultimate band. Although it is a bit Rushy...
MrKnickerbocker
clap hands
Tommy, by far.
I love DT and I am LaBrie Apologist, but Tommy is simply astounding.
I love DT and I am LaBrie Apologist, but Tommy is simply astounding.
The Dissident
Ancient Mariner
Klaus is one of my favourite vocalists ever, an amazing performer and he held up for years.
LaBrie is great as well. But Klaus gets my vote
LaBrie is great as well. But Klaus gets my vote
Black Wizard
Pleb Hunter
James LaBrie and Klaus Meine shouldn't be in this game.
Collin
Chasing Ponce De Leon's Phantoms
Reported.
Black Wizard
Pleb Hunter
Neither of them are great vocalists. One of them will progress due to exposure bias, that is all.
LaBrie has a distinctive voice, but I don't think he's a particular brilliant singer. Meine can definitely sing, but I find his voice a bit rough, even when he was younger. Karevik is very decent. I'm going for my personal preference of Anderson, however.
