I'm going to have to think. I lean towards Geezer, but I suspect Geddy is the more proficient bassist.
BEST BAND EVER: Results!
- Thread starter Night Prowler
- Start date
The Dissident
Ancient Mariner
Has to be Geddy.
Geddy.
Peart has a pretty good chance in the drummer game too.
This is probably a better demonstration of Nick Mason's drumming than Roger Waters' bass. Will Mason be in this game?
I actually cut him from the game today lol
But it's not a final list as that game is way ahead in the future.
But it's not a final list as that game is way ahead in the future.
Magnus
Pica Serdica
Hope to live long enough to see it.
For what it's worth, Geezer is the best bass player ever IMO, and since I value my opinion the most, I'd say he's the real winner of this game 
As this looks like a done deal, expect a start of the Vocalists game later today...
As this looks like a done deal, expect a start of the Vocalists game later today...
The Flash
Dennis Wilcock did 9/11
For what it's worth, Geezer is the best bass player ever IMO, and since I value my opinion the most, I'd say he's the real winner of this game
You're pretty much the last guy on the forum to be the authority on bass players though
Black Wizard
Pleb Hunter
He probably knows more than me to be fair.
You're pretty much the last guy on the forum to be the authority on bass players though
There you go, @The Flash
The Flash
Dennis Wilcock did 9/11
Possibly, but he's the only guy on the forum known to have admitted to not caring about bass and being unable to hear it most of the time.
That's an exaggeration, someone else must've said it too. I can hear it when I focus on it. Anyway, I'm gonna lock this now to transition between games, not because of the argument, you can continue when I unlock the thread
Best Bassist Ever - Top 10
01. Geddy Lee
02. Geezer Butler
03. John Myung
04. Chris Squire
05. Flea
06. Phil Lynott
07. Roger Waters
08. Bootsy Collins
09. John Paul Jones
10. Sting
01. Geddy Lee
02. Geezer Butler
03. John Myung
04. Chris Squire
05. Flea
06. Phil Lynott
07. Roger Waters
08. Bootsy Collins
09. John Paul Jones
10. Sting
Welcome to the Vocalists part of the Best Band Ever game!
We start with 25 groups of 4 singers; 1 winner from each group advances to the knockout stages, along with the 7 best non-winners from all groups combined. 32 remaining songs battle it out knockout style.
David Gilmour (solo, PINK FLOYD)
Freddie Mercury (solo, QUEEN)
Mike Patton (FAITH NO MORE)
Tony Martin (BLACK SABBATH)
We start with 25 groups of 4 singers; 1 winner from each group advances to the knockout stages, along with the 7 best non-winners from all groups combined. 32 remaining songs battle it out knockout style.
David Gilmour (solo, PINK FLOYD)
Freddie Mercury (solo, QUEEN)
Mike Patton (FAITH NO MORE)
Tony Martin (BLACK SABBATH)
Freddie Mercury is the winner here. Only a performer who is literally God can beat him.