Forostar
Ancient Mariner
I see. Normally I'd only count the first post (rating) but if you are willing to change the rating (as soon as this is possible) by following these 14 May updates/posts then I am willing to use these latest ones.
Maybe it's handy for you to make your own overview of songs which had changed ratings, while you are doing this. Then you can correct the votes accordingly. Thanks in advance!
I made this exception for you (hopefully other members don't mind) because we're getting nearer to the moment when LC will make the "change" of vote possible.
Maybe it's handy for you to make your own overview of songs which had changed ratings, while you are doing this. Then you can correct the votes accordingly. Thanks in advance!
I made this exception for you (hopefully other members don't mind) because we're getting nearer to the moment when LC will make the "change" of vote possible.
Tron
Trooper
i didnt really make a post on it and i dont even remember making most of these votings... a blank spot in my memory. im sure people wont mind discounting 1's and 3's. later ive made smaller changes in powerslave area but feel free to discount them as you see fit because what they had been were still reasonably ok. eg changng 7's for 8's
so when is it that the change is to be made possible? today?
so when is it that the change is to be made possible? today?
Forostar
Ancient Mariner
The problem is that many people want to change their grades, and all the time I said: no, let's wait til you can change your vote.
Would you terribly mind if I still follow the old rule, because that would be more fair towards the others.
(on the other hand: more work for you and for me.)
My advice is: stop now, and continue with the rest of the albums as soon as the vote change is possible.
If you rather continue and keep changing your ratings, then I need to consider how to deal with this.
That's up to LooseCannon. I think it won't be long but I can't speak for him.
Would you terribly mind if I still follow the old rule, because that would be more fair towards the others.
(on the other hand: more work for you and for me.)
My advice is: stop now, and continue with the rest of the albums as soon as the vote change is possible.
If you rather continue and keep changing your ratings, then I need to consider how to deal with this.
jonnytron said:so when is it that the change is to be made possible? today?
That's up to LooseCannon. I think it won't be long but I can't speak for him.
Tron
Trooper
yeah ill go for whats easier as a whole... i dont want to cause civil unrest 
ill say ignore my votes as a whole for now until a vote change is allowed then ill catch up, no point in rocking the boat
thanks and at least ive put my votes down in posts so its less work when the time comes around.
ill say ignore my votes as a whole for now until a vote change is allowed then ill catch up, no point in rocking the boat
thanks and at least ive put my votes down in posts so its less work when the time comes around.
Forostar
Ancient Mariner
That's very nice from you! Thanks for your patience!
Of course you can still continue with all the songs which had no previous voting/posting actions (unless you think you'll change them soon again
).
If you haven't mention a re-rating in the IM-, Killers-, NOTB-, POM-, PS-songposts, does that indicate it was a first post and vote?
Of course you can still continue with all the songs which had no previous voting/posting actions (unless you think you'll change them soon again
).If you haven't mention a re-rating in the IM-, Killers-, NOTB-, POM-, PS-songposts, does that indicate it was a first post and vote?
Tron
Trooper
its not so much that i plan to change my mind anytime soon... just that currently the albums are peppered with these kind of nonsense votes i dont remember doing so ill rectify that later 
and correct if i havent mentioned ive reworked a vote then it means they are my first... actually notb ive made no changes to previous votes while still completing it
and correct if i havent mentioned ive reworked a vote then it means they are my first... actually notb ive made no changes to previous votes while still completing it
Forostar
Ancient Mariner
I also saw no reworked ratings in IM, correct?
You know what? Please choose between these options:
A:
I'll collect all your rankings, apart from the reworked ones (I leave these empty, so some songs are not taken into consideration in the stats and the albums are incomplete). As soon as your vote can be changed, let me know (e.g. in the album judgment topic) that you did change them, and mention which songs are changed, and mention the new ratings. Then I'll collect the new grade, and at a certain moment, this will be incorporated in the following stat update (the updates won't be often, maybe once or a couple of times per year).
B:
I'll collect all your rankings, including the reworked ones, but as I've done with other members, I will choose the old ranking (which will have influence on the stats). As soon as your vote can be changed, let me know (e.g. in the album judgment topic) that you did change them, and mention which songs are changed, and mention the new ratings. Then I'll change the old grades into the new ones, and at a certain moment, this will be incorporated in the following stat update (the updates won't be often, maybe once or a couple of times per year).
In any case:
As said before, you may continue with all other albums, but please keep mentioning the changes (old and new), if there are any.
You know what? Please choose between these options:
A:
I'll collect all your rankings, apart from the reworked ones (I leave these empty, so some songs are not taken into consideration in the stats and the albums are incomplete). As soon as your vote can be changed, let me know (e.g. in the album judgment topic) that you did change them, and mention which songs are changed, and mention the new ratings. Then I'll collect the new grade, and at a certain moment, this will be incorporated in the following stat update (the updates won't be often, maybe once or a couple of times per year).
B:
I'll collect all your rankings, including the reworked ones, but as I've done with other members, I will choose the old ranking (which will have influence on the stats). As soon as your vote can be changed, let me know (e.g. in the album judgment topic) that you did change them, and mention which songs are changed, and mention the new ratings. Then I'll change the old grades into the new ones, and at a certain moment, this will be incorporated in the following stat update (the updates won't be often, maybe once or a couple of times per year).
In any case:
As said before, you may continue with all other albums, but please keep mentioning the changes (old and new), if there are any.
and thanks
D
Deleted member 7164
Guest
6
edge of darkness
Trooper
9. I've always loved this upbeat tune!
Revelations85
Trooper
7/10. It is a decent rocker.
MrKnickerbocker
clap hands
6.
It gets better whenever I hear Bruce sing it, especially on Hammersmith. As always, it's nice to hear a Maiden tune with some bluesy licks.
It gets better whenever I hear Bruce sing it, especially on Hammersmith. As always, it's nice to hear a Maiden tune with some bluesy licks.
AndrewLaeddis
Prowler
Underrated tune. Love Clive's intro, and the guitars are solid throughout. The lyrics are good enough, but the song just doesn't have anything that special to offer. 7/10
22 The Avenue
Nomad
Here's where the album falls flat on it's face and never really gets back up. It's okay, at best. I'd fall asleep if they played this song live. 5/10
TheSpectreWithin
Pirate of the Undergorund
A quick piece of filler. The only part I usually remember is the odd timed harmony, which is pretty cool.
Decent tune, but nothing great.
6/10
Decent tune, but nothing great.
6/10