The Best Iron Maiden Song Never Played Live Results

Satisfied

  • Total voters
    17
  • Poll closed .
Eliminated:
Flash of the Blade
The Prophecy
Face in the Sand

We have now reached the top 10!!!! In other news I forgot to add Judas last round. :facepalm:
 
Last edited:
Why does Judas get a free pass? I would've most certainly voted for it last round, over a couple that got eliminated too.

Collin you can edit your polls now, if you forget something just add it in.
 
Mosh said:
Why does Judas get a free pass? I would've most certainly voted for it last round, over a couple that got eliminated too.

Collin you can edit your polls now, if you forget something just add it in.
Click to expand...
I know but I didn't know that I forgot it until now. I'll make a proposition, if enough people cry farce then I'll close the poll and make a new one and bring Montsegur back in.

Edit: Or I could just add it now.... I'll do that.
Edit #2: Fixed..
 
Last five apart from Isle of Avalon.

Good Judas Be My Guide is in because it wasn't eliminated, so the "free pass" comment is a bit inappropriate imo.
 
Last edited:
Why? It got taken out of the game for a round and thus was immune from getting votes.

Somehow I get the feeling you wouldn't be so okay with it if it was a song like Montsegur.
 
Collin, advice:

When you're updating the game, just copy/paste the remaining songs from the previous round and count them before posting it. I do it like that and I never forgot to add songs.
 
Is he able to edit the polls like we are? I could've sworn that was a feature for all members.
 
Mosh said:
Why? It got taken out of the game for a round and thus was immune from getting votes.

Somehow I get the feeling you wouldn't be so okay with it if it was a song like Montsegur.
Click to expand...
No, no. We don't know if it would have been eliminated last round. That's why it would be more unfair to elimate a song than to not eliminate it. A song should get a chance to be voted on, but it should also have a chance for survival.

edit: by the way, at the moment it's doing at least as "good" as no less than four other songs.
 
Last edited:
For the record, I would have voted Judas last round too.

There's a thin line between Only The Good Die Young and Mother Russia. Almost as thin as the one between love and hate.
 
Accidentally voted 4, could you discount my vote for Deja Vu, if it's not too much trouble :)

I also would've voted for Judas last round. But, regardless of whether it would or wouldn't have, saying it's good that it got to skip a round is ... well ... I don't think I need to really elaborate.
 
Crimson Idol said:
saying it's good that it got to skip a round is ... well ... I don't think I need to really elaborate.
Click to expand...
:grumble:

You really read too much into my comments. No one said it's good that it got to skip a round.

Because it skipped a round by accident (it was forgotten), I think it is good that it has another chance.
 
Forostar said:
:grumble:

You really read too much into my comments. No one said it's good that it got to skip a round.

Because it skipped a round by accident (it was forgotten), I think it is good that it has another chance.
Click to expand...

I'm clearly not the only one though as Mosh said the same thing. Saying "Good it has another chance" comes across as saying that it wouldn't have had a chance had it been left in, which - imo looking at the votes - it wouldn't have, so it's got further than it should have done because it was skipped. If you mean "another chance" for something else, then what? because that's the only extra chance it's gotten.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top