The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time COMPLETE

Who do you prefer? Grand Final

  • Black Sabbath

    Votes: 16 61.5%
  • Metallica

    Votes: 10 38.5%
  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    26
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Agreed, the whole thing is BS.


...Black Sabbath that is.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Black Sabbath...
I can't believe it's a draw so far...  :blink:
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

I thought Black Sabbath would have been dominating too.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Even Metallica guys would laugh really loud of the results. This forum is loosing credibility. Hope it doesn't turn into another MFU. :uhm:
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

The Birmingham lot for me.

Despite Man Utd drawing against both Aston Villa and Birmingham City this season.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Jeffmetal said:
Even Metallica guys would laugh really loud of the results. This forum is loosing credibility. Hope it doesn't turn into another MFU. :uhm:

What's a MFU?
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Black_Thunder said:
I don't think you should judge a band by certain albums. I think you should judge by their whole discography.

That's why Metallica should have gone a LOOOOOOOOONG time ago.
This is correct.
Have a praise
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Black Sabbath. And not only because of the Ozzy and Dio years.

Black_Thunder knows what I'm talking about. *hints at his avatar* 
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Black Sabbath. I can't believe Metallica beat Judas Priest. The finals would've been a lot more difficult for me if it was Priest vs Sabbath. :p
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Prowler_108 said:
This is correct.
Have a praise

Thanks for support. Have one in return. :)

Forostar said:
Black Sabbath. And not only because of the Ozzy and Dio years.

Black_Thunder knows what I'm talking about. *hints at his avatar*

Yup. Revolutionary riffs + Tony's powerful register changing = My 2nd favorite Sabbath album.  :edmetal:
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Forostar said:
Black Sabbath. And not only because of the Ozzy and Dio years.

Black_Thunder knows what I'm talking about. *hints at his avatar*  

I know, too and very well. Essential reminder, Foro. My band didn't know Devil & Daughter 'til I suggested it to our first batch of songs for the set list. Guess which song all guys, including me, are having the most of a blasting playing on rehearsals, and surely will feel the same on our first gig, next Sunday?

BLACK SABBATH RULES FOREVER!!! :edmetal:
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Cool man!

Good luck, and tell us how it went (post a setlist as well!)  :shred:
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

may Dio smite all who don't vote sabbath  :P Seriously I decided to vote for the band that DIDN'T sell out
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

Moonchild33 said:
Black Sabbath. I can't believe Metallica beat Judas Prisst. The finals would've been a lot more difficult for me if it was Priest vs Sabbath. :p

Yeah, that surprised me too, I thought it would be a Priest / Sabbath Grand Final all along. Let me just say, I voted for Metallica. My reasoning is I grew up listening to them, from KEA to AJFA and the Black Album. Sabbath came later for me and as much as I worship Sabbath, Metallica were the ones for me who just blew all else out of the water. Yeah sure we all know they sold out in the end, but fuck me, nothing in my life (apart from SIT and SSOASS) have grabbed my attention like Metallica did. For me they are only 2nd to Maiden.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

There are two ways of looking at it - you could look at the consistency of the band, in which case everyone would vote for Black Sabbath, but I chose to look at each of the bands best material (in their primes) and compare them. It was close, but as with vortex I was listening to Metallica before Sabbath, and I love every single song from their first four albums.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

6 hours remain on voting.

Current Score:

Black Sabbath  15 (60%)
Metallica  10 (40%)
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time GRAND FINAL

The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time is:​


2q3w1a8.jpg

As voted by you, the members of Maidenfans.com.​

Thankyou to all who participated:ok:

Stats to follow:​
 
Back
Top