My last.fm profile tells me this:
1. Starblind
2. El Dorado
3. Coming Home
4. When the Wild Wind Blows
5. Sattelite 15... The Final Frontier
6. Mother of Mercy
7. Isle of Avalon
8. The Alchemist
9. The Talisman
10. The Man Who Would Be King
The last two are a tie: Both have been scrobbled 86 times, meaning I played the entire album on my computer 86 times; that's not counting plays on my MP3 player and mostly, my HiFi. The total number of rotations must be close to 200 by now.
However, I can only say that Starblind is certainly my favourite off the album, and I think The Alchemist is my least favourite. Also, consider that El Dorado has had a significant head start.