CriedWhenBrucieLeft
Meme Only Account
We had a "solos" survivor on this forum. Pretty sure there was 99% consensus on who played what.
I did this since 1998 on the Baeleron website, later Iron Maiden Commentary. You're not going to tell me that you, that group of fans, or that Italian had not noticed nor used that. I also was the first with solo information (posted on this very forum) on new albums since the Commentary stopped being active.When I started the research (in the hand written notebook) I started doing notes of the solos. Then I would say around 97-99, a group of fans and me on the IM forum (when it was free) decided to compare notes and try to come up with the complete list of solos until. I specifically remember there was an Italian fan that had done an awesome job and it was the general consensus that his list was the most accurate.
I seem to remember also that there's some interviews where Steve says who plays what (for a specific album in the 80's) and there are a couple of Guitar Worlds & Guitar Magazines where either they deconstruct some songs and say who played the solo or where Adrian, Dave &/or Janick are interview and say who plays what.
For some of the latest albums I had help from a couple of guys from the IMFC.
I did this since 1998 on the Baeleron website, later Iron Maiden Commentary. You're not going to tell me that you, that group of fans, or that Italian had not noticed nor used that. I also was the first with solo information (posted on this very forum) since the Commentary stopped being active.
You can copy paste job away, mention vague sources or deny them but it is seriously questionable when you
A: say you were a fan of the biggest Maiden fan site (with information),
B: made something including comparable information,
C: did not use anything of it.
On the one hand I am curious to learn how that solo info looks like, on the other hand, I question your sources and credits.
I had, but as often too late, edited my post somewhat, before you posted:
= =
I find it questionable when you
A: say you were a fan of the biggest Maiden fan site (with information),
B: made something including comparable information,
C: (or your sources) did not use anything of it.
On the one hand I am curious to learn how that solo info looks like and naturally all the rest (so shut up Foro buy the book), on the other hand, I still question your sources and credits and feel reluctant.
= =
I don't understand why you are reluctant about being more open and concrete about sources and credits out here.
Bud, I have the book, nobody other than you is crazy enough to put all this stuff in one location. That said, Foro, if you're that concerned, you should buy it and write a detailed critique.Ok, let me see if understand. You basically want me to post here ALL the sources from my book? If that's so, I'll could reveal all the open sources if that would help anyone to see the amount of work
I'm specifically curious about the solo info content. Who made the info, how was it made, and when.
edit: and I wonder if you did mentioned Baeleron's site / Iron Maiden Commentary (only as inspiration or more?).
At least as interested in the following, from my fan perspective:
I am also curious about how much of the book contains direct info from all the people you mentioned. I assume, direct meaning: you cannot read this anywhere else. I understand you did a huge job, and collected lots of information. The thing is, I have read a lot of information, and I am curious about new information. So forgive me for especially focussing on the new stuff, the stuff you had received from people in the band, ex or current band members and people close to the band.
Do you also have an overview of concert data in the seventies?
I realise that it may be off topic from the title (discography) but you never know. ;--)
Bud, I have the book, nobody other than you is crazy enough to put all this stuff in one location. That said, Foro, if you're that concerned, you should buy it and write a detailed critique.
Is this just guitar solos we're talking about here? As we're making it sound super, super complicated. Unless there is documented evidence of who played what (e.g. Steve Harris says so in that guitar book) then all anyone can do is listen. And... that doesn't take six months. That would take literally a couple of hours.
Foro did the solo survivor (here on MFans) with the help of myself & others. I think that's why he's asking.