I just downloaded Crucible of Man (it leaked online.) I still need to give it time to sink in, but so far I quite like it. It's probably Iced Earth's heaviest and least melodic album, or at least second after Burnt Ofeerings. The riffing is great as always, as are the drumming and the bass. Barlow sounds excellent, though I think he sounded better with Pyramaze. It has some of the problems that Framing Armageddon had, like too much palm muting and layered vocals, but to a much lesser extent than on Framing Armageddon. It has some of the atmospheric qualities of Framing Armageddon, but mostly it's just straightforward metal. Overall, this album doesn't disappoint but I wouldn't put it up with Iced Earth's best work.