Clue #1: I want my, I want my, I want my
Clue #2: Masturbating on Sundays (for Christians)...it's true!
Clue #3: America trove
Clue #4: it is a post-reunion song that has never been played live
Clue #5: working at Chai & Church
Incorrect guesses: Iron Maiden/ Charlotte The Harlot/ El Dorado/ Weekend Warrior/ Holy Smoke/ Be Quick or Be Dead/ Lord of Light/ Prowler/Sign of the Cross/ Starblind/ Pass The Jam/ New Frontier/ Age of Innocence