So the story so far:
Clue #1: "When in Rome my reflection is upon four"
Clue #2: "Speaking of romans... fact is we are six."
Clue #3: "Keep your vynil, flip to play, don't you pray, but please do stray, and a lead you'll obtain."
Wrong Guesses: (The Evil That Men Do/ Lord of Light/ The Red and the Black/Dream of Mirrors/ Still Life/ Sign of the Cross/ The Book Of Souls/ Caught Somewhere in Time/ When the River Runs Deep/ Wildest Dreams/ Running Free/ Ghost of the Navigator)
Time for a new one:
Clue #4:
"I'm prior to your wisemen, I'm prior to your breed,
I'm prior to the first sounds of the torturing machine,
I even come before the blessings of the lord,
Yet I don't lie when I say I'm the youngest of them all"