Oof, is it Fear Of The Dark, due to "
Are You Afraid of the Dark?" ?
It is!
Clue #1:
View attachment 34343
< The Scooby Gang in
Buffy The Vampire Slayer, "debating witches and folklore".
Clue #2: "Up here in space, I'm looking down on you"
< "You've sensed that something's watching you"
Clue #3:
Iron Maiden
< on the single, the logo is in yellow:
Clue #4:
View attachment 34376
<"the unknown troubles on your mind"
Clue #5: DR DR DR DR DR DR DR DR MG
< after 8 album covers made by Derek Riggs, the ninth one (the FOTB album) was made by Melvyn Grant.
Clue #6:
View attachment 34378
< the last shot from the
Blair Witch Project, which echoes pretty much all the song lyrics, but especially:
"Sometimes when you're scared to take a look
At the corner of the room
You've sensed that something's watching you"
Clue #7:
View attachment 34382
< the goalkeeper from Real Madrid was born on May 11th, 1992, the FOTD album release date.
Clue #8: the song we're looking for was released the same year as a Canadian-American TV show whose title and theme are quite similar.
< see Vaenyr's answer.
Clue #9: the song we're looking for is much more popular than those of the same album that appear among the incorrect guesses.
< You've named "Chains of Misery", "The Apparition" and "Weekend Warrior", which are mostly unpopular songs, especially compared to the title track.
Clue #10: a matter of glasses and font
Congratulations,
@Vaenyr ! Your turn.