After giving some thought, I'm going ADTOE as well. Not only do I prefer the longer songs on FII, but I think it has strong shorter songs too. The only "short" song I care for on ADTOE is Beneath the Surface (unless you count OTBOA). FII on the other hand has Hell's Kitchen, Hollow Years, Peruvian Skies, and even Take Away My Pain. I can skip the three really bad songs and still get a pretty good album. With ADTOE I tend to just go for the epics and ignore everything else.