Canadian Seal Hunt Controversy

Status
Not open for further replies.

Forostar

Ancient Mariner
Interesting news.(video: click on "sealing showdown", 12 April) As we all know Canada kills tons of seals. Here some photos of this job.

The Canadian seal season began at the end of March. An estimated 2,500 hunters have permission to kill 275,000 seals. Apperently some ship wanted to photograph how this is being done, something which wasn't very appreciated. By the way, that federal fisheries minister talks like some uneducated nitwit.

Anti-sealing ship operated by environmental crusader seized by federal officers
13 hours ago

HALIFAX — An RCMP tactical squad stormed and seized the anti-sealing vessel Farley Mowat on Saturday, in a provocative move the federal fisheries minister said would prevent "a bunch of money-sucking manipulators" from interfering with the annual hunt.

Paul Watson, head of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, said the seizure of his ship and the arrests of two senior officers amounted to an "act of war" because the vessel is registered in the Netherlands.

Watson, speaking from New York, said armed officers from two coast guard vessels scrambled aboard the Mowat at around 11 a.m. ADT in the Cabot Strait - the body of water between Cape Breton and Newfoundland.

"(They) took command of the vessel, and .... they were screaming at people to lie down on the deck."

The environmental crusader said a communications officer aboard the ship was relaying details of the boarding via satellite phone when the connection was suddenly lost.

Later in the day, Fisheries Minister Loyola Hearn said the ship's captain and chief officer were arrested for allegedly violating Canada's marine mammal regulations and the Fisheries Act.

He said those charges were related to a high-seas confrontation in the Gulf of St. Lawrence between the Farley Mowat and a coast guard icebreaker two weeks ago.

"We did the right thing," Hearn told a news conference in Ottawa. "I'd rather act when nobody is hurt, rather than react when somebody got killed."

The minister bristled at Watson's suggestion that the seizure represents a public relations coup for his movement as the European Union contemplates a ban on the importation of all seal products.

"These are a bunch of money-sucking manipulators," Hearn said. "They're sole aim is to try to suck as much money out of the pockets of people who really don't know what's going on," he said.

Last week, the department brought forward charges alleging the Farley Mowat's captain, Alexander Cornelissen, and First Officer Peter Hammarstedt broke rules that prohibit anyone without a valid observation licence from coming within 900 metres of the hunt.

Cornelissen is also charged under the Fisheries Act with obstruction or hindrance of a Fishery Officer or inspector.

However, Watson maintains the Farley Mowat doesn't have to submit to Canadian regulations.

Hearn rejected that claim, saying the Mowat was seized legally in Canada's "internal waters," without providing the specific location of the seizure.

Watson has argued that his vessel never entered Canada's 12-nautical-mile territorial limit, but Hearn said the Fisheries Act gave him the authority to take action beyond that line.

"This is just more mouthy talk by people who want to use this to their advantage," Hearn said. "Paul Watson is quarterbacking from his nice, posh hotel room in New York somewhere."

Still, the Fisheries Department later confirmed that on March 29 the Foreign Affairs Department issued a diplomatic note to the Netherlands requesting assistance to deter unlawful activities by the Mowat "as it is flying a Dutch flag."

A spokesman for the Dutch ministry of foreign affairs at The Hague, Netherlands, said his government was attempting to learn more about the incident.

"For the moment, we are still verifying the facts, and seeking the opinion of the Canadian authorities and how they justify their acts of today," said Ahmed Dadou.

In Ottawa, Hearn noted the crew of the Mowat were "safe and unharmed" following the boarding, and their vessel would be taken to Sydney, N.S., by early Sunday.

Those charged were expected to appear in a Sydney court.

Watson said his group has plenty of graphic footage of seals being slaughtered and he believes the pictures will be damaging to Canada's reputation.

"I think we've embarrassed the hell out of the Canadian government and they're desperate," he said.

Hearn said the seizure had nothing to do with censorship and insisted the move was not aimed at boosting the federal Conservatives' flagging fortunes in his home province of Newfoundland.

"It is time something was done and something has been done and it has nothing to do with Newfoundland or what kind of shape we're in. This won't affect me politically one way or another," he said.

Meanwhile, the European Commission, the executive branch of the European Union, is awaiting a second report on the seal hunt before making its recommendation to the European Parliament, likely this summer.

The annual hunt started March 28 in the southern Gulf of St. Lawrence, then expanded last week to include a portion of the gulf west of Newfoundland. The main hunt, in an area north of Newfoundland known as the Front, started Saturday.

On March 30, some seal hunters called for assistance from the coast guard, complaining that the Farley Mowat was getting to close to them on the ice floes about 60 kilometres north of Cape Breton.

The Fisheries Department later said its 98-metre icebreaker Des Groseilliers responded to the scene and was "grazed" twice by the 54-metre Farley Mowat.

But the conservation group said its ship was rammed twice by the icebreaker.

The crew aboard the Mowat said they were told not to approach an ice-covered area where seals were being slaughtered, but the crew did not comply with the order.

On April 5, Hearn said charges had been laid, but he did not say how or when the summonses would be served.

The charges, brought forward in Nova Scotia, could result in fines of up to $100,000 or up to one year in prison, or both.

The captain of the Cape Breton sealing vessel who called for help said the arrests were long overdue.

"It's time, it's high time, it's past time that they did something with them," said Pat Briand of Dingwall, N.S., the 55-year-old skipper of the Cathy Erlene.

Watson has denied the Farley Mowat got too close to the hunt and has released a video that shows the two vessels travelling briefly in a parallel course and then colliding twice.

The Sea Shepherd Society and previous incarnations have long used militant tactics to stop hunters from killing seals, whales and other marine wildlife.

The group claims to have sunk six whaling ships since 1979, saying no one was hurt in those actions.

During the 1980s, Watson harassed Russian whaling ships and Japanese dolphin hunters. In the mid-80s, he was tear gassed off the Faroe Islands when he tried to stop the sport kill of pilot whales.

In 1995, he scuffled with an angry mob of angry sealers on Iles-de-la-Madeleine when he went there to stage a protest with actor Martin Sheen.

To be sure, the Canadian Coast Guard and the Fisheries Department are no strangers to confrontation on the water.

On March 9, 1995, as Spain and Canada were locked in an emotional battle over the overfishing of turbot just beyond Canadian waters, the coast guard patrol vessel Cape Roger intercepted the Spanish trawler Estai, which cut its nets and fled.

After a lengthy pursuit, the crew of the Cape Roger fired four bursts from .50-calibre machine gun across the bow of the Estai, which then stopped and was seized by RCMP and Fisheries officers.


Seal Hunt Chronology

HALIFAX - The federal Fisheries Department has arrested the senior officers of the anti-sealing vessel Farley Mowat for alleged violations of the Fisheries Act.

Here's a chronology of the vessel's encounters with federal officials, sealers and Canadian patrol boats.

March 20 - Transport Canada directed the Farley Mowat not to enter Canadian waters until it complied with international marine safety conventions.

March 24 - The Farley Mowat left Bermuda.

March 28 - It reached the Canadian exclusive economic zone, the area where Canada claims exclusive rights to the economic benefits from the ocean, including fish and seals.

March 29 - Canadian authorities attempted to communicate with the Farley Mowat south of St. Paul's Island, but say there was no reply.

March 29 - The Department of Foreign Affairs issued a diplomatic note to the Netherlands requesting their assistance to deter and prevent unlawful activities by the master and crew of the Farley Mowat, which flies a Dutch flag.

March 30 - Ottawa alleges the Farley Mowat engaged in illegal activities by approaching sealing vessels. The Farley Mowat and the Coast Guard ship Des Groseilliers collide on two occasions approximately 40 kilometres east of Ingonish, Cape Breton.

April 2 - The Farley Mowat docks at the French islands of Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon.

April 4 - The Farley Mowat leaves Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon after local fishermen cut its mooring lines.

April 5 - The captain and first officer of the Farley Mowat are charged with violating the Marine Mammal Regulations under the Fisheries Act. The captain is also charged with obstruction under the Fisheries Act.

April 9 - The Department of Transport say that the Farley Mowat entered Canadian waters. Transport Canada directed the Farley Mowat to depart and remain outside Canadian waters based on security concerns.

April 10 - Canadian authorities say they documented an incursion into the 12 nautical miles territorial limit by the Farley Mowat. A Transport Canada ministerial order to proceed to Sydney, N.S., was sent to the vessel Farley Mowat via the Canadian Coast Guard Marine Communications and Traffic Services.

April 11 - The federal Fisheries Department alleges the Farley Mowat came within approximately 100 metres of a sealer, which is in contravention of the Marine Mammal Regulations.

April 12 - The vessel is seized and boarded by Canadian officials.

(Source: Transport Canada, federal Fisheries Department)


---------------------------------------

+

Anti-seal hunt protesters decry Canada's 'act of war' in seizing their vessel

Organization head Paul Watson predicted the raid on the Dutch-registered would backfire on Canada, which is campaigning against a European ban on seal products.
Helen Morris, Canwest News Service / Published: Sunday, April 13, 2008

The captain and first officer of the anti-seal hunt vessel Farley Mowat are facing charges in a Sydney, N.S. court in connection with a confrontation with a coast guard ship on March 30.

The Mowat, operated by the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, was seized by an armed RCMP team, working with fisheries and coast guard personnel, in the Gulf of St. Lawrence Saturday as it was monitoring the hunt.

The head of the Sea Shepherd Society, Paul Watson called it "an act of war," claiming the Dutch-registered vessel was outside Canadian jurisdiction.

"The Canadian Coast Guard seized a European-registered yacht in international waters which, technically, is an act of war," said Watson.

Canada's fisheries minister dismissed the claim, and in acid tones described the group as "money-sucking manipulators (whose) sole aim is to try to suck as much money out of the pockets of people who really don't know what's going on."

Loyola Hearn said the raid took place in Canadian waters and in accordance with Canadian fisheries legislation.

He said the Mowat was boarded and the captain, Alexander Cornelissen, and first officer Peter Hammarstedt arrested because the Farley Mowat had failed to comply with warnings to proceed immediately to Sydney, N.S., and continued to violate marine and fisheries regulations.

If convicted, the maximum penalty is six months in jail and a $100,000 fine. The vessel is due to arrive in Sydney on Sunday.

Watson, who was not on board either at the time of the arrest or the alleged confrontation with the coast guard vessel, predicted the raid would backfire on Canada, which is campaigning against a looming European Union ban on the import of seal products.

"By arresting us - a European-registered vessel, a European crew - in this way, that pretty much ensures the bill banning seal products in Europe will be passed," Watson told media.

"They did exactly what we thought they might do, but I didn't think would be stupid enough to do."

Saturday's arrests stemmed from an incident involving the Farley Mowat and sealers near Cape Breton on March 30. Nova Scotia sealer Shane Briand said the Mowat endangered the lives of his crew when it came close to them about 60 kilometres off Cape Breton.

He said at one point, the Mowat broke the ice up beneath a sealer as he stood on a floe.

Briand said the much larger Mowat harassed his ship and crew until a coast guard icebreaker arrived and put itself between the two ships.

The Fisheries Department says during the incident the icebreaker was "grazed" by the Mowat, while the Sea Shepherd Society says its ship was rammed.

The arrests drew praise from sealing activist Jim Winter in St. John's.

"If a man walks down the street with a two by four and threatens to hit you over the head, the police will arrest him. If a man takes a steel ship and threatens to run down a wooden ship, he should be arrested, (too)," Winter said.

But Watson said the arrests set a dangerous precedent and the Sea Shepherd Society would be registering protests with the embassies representing the 17 people on the ship, who come from the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, France, Sweden, South Africa, Canada and the United States.

"We have the right of free passage through those waters and Canada was out of order in boarding us," he said, describing how he could hear the raid as it progressed through a phone line from Shannon Mann, the communications officer for the protest ship.

"Shannon said that the icebreaker the Des Groseilliers and the (offshore patrol ship) Sir Wilfrid Grenfell dispatched four small boats carrying officers and they swarmed the vessel and came on board. They seized everything," said Watson.

"While I was talking to her I could hear yelling in the background, telling people to lie down on the deck. The crew were forced down at gunpoint and then the line went dead. So they obviously cut the communications."

Hearn said he wanted the ship stopped before someone got killed.

"The action was taken because the Farley Mowat and its crew, acting under the direction of Mr. Paul Watson, contravened the marine mammal regulations and the Fisheries Act that govern the seal hunt," he said.

The Farley Mowat will be kept in DFO custody until a court orders the release of the vessel upon posting of security, the Fisheries Department said.

The vessel will also be inspected by Transport Canada and police to ensure it and the crew pose no safety or security threat.

The Sea Shepherd Society said that the Farley Mowat had been gathering videotaped proof that seals were being killed in an inhumane manner. Watson said he assumed all the videotapes had been seized by the Canadian authorities.

Saturday's action comes as the seal hunt is underway in earnest off Newfoundland. But high fuel costs and low pelt prices have sharply reduced the number of boats taking part.

It also follows the tragic beginning of the hunt when four Magdelan Islands sealers died as their vessel capsized while under a coast guard tow.

That incident is the subject of three investigations.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Oh fer crying out loud, not this again. Why can't these idiots leave the hunters alone? It's part of the culture and the tradition. If one person doesn't understand or approve of the culture and tradition of another person, but that culture and tradition doesn't hurt anyone, let it be. I mean, I think auto racing is stupid, but I don't go around trying to disrupt it.

And don't gimme crap about "killing seals inhumanely". We, the human race, are at the top of the evolutionary ladder. The seals aren't. They lose. End of story.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Well, as you might guess, I have a lot to say on this particular subject.

First of all, the seal hunt is generally run by the government in order to reduce the population of seals off Newfoundland and the Great Banks.  The seal population had exploded over the last 4-5 decades due to the reduction of its natural foes, and government studies commissioned in the aftermath of the 1991-93 moratoriums on federal fishing suggested that a prime cause of the reduction of fish was the fact that baby seals were eating fish eggs; indeed, many baby seals were dying of starvation due to their over population.

Thus, a seal hunt.

Now, I am not going to deny that the hunt is graphic.  The official method for killing a seal involves striking it on the crown and slashing its throat (I believe).  Not everyone will do this right all the time.  Just like an average hunter won't always follow the rules for hunting a deer properly all the time.  Sometimes it's accidental, sometimes not.  But no matter what, the seal hunt is going to appear to be gross and gory - because it is.

However, you can't approach sealing vessels for a *reason*.  It's really dangerous.  Earlier this year our own Coast Guard fucked it up, and while towing a disable vessel, caused it to flip and kill four sailors.

I don't care for Sea Shepherd anyway, but it seems very stupid to me that they are patrolling Canada's economic zone and don't expect to be subject to Canadian laws.  The international community has held up our rights within the 200 mile limit before and will do so again.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

The seal hunters are doing what polar bears, orcas and sharks would be doing hadn't they been extincted in those waters.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Perun said:
The seal hunters are doing what polar bears, orcas and sharks would be doing hadn't they been extincted in those waters.

...with the notable difference that the seal hunters don't kill just what they need to survive...nor do they consume the seals themselves.  Yeah, great comparison.

@SMX: Certainly, control of a prey population is a top priority for stabilising the ecosystem, but justifying it just because 'we are at the top of the evolutionary ladder' is horribly narcissistic.  It's also the same mentality that has forced thousands of species to extinction, including those that were in abundance.  Would you say that we should permit Japan to whale illegally? It's part of their culture.

While I don't agree with the methods or the profit of the sealers, I can see the motivation of the local government, with a view to protecting prey species...'three sides to every story', I suppose.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

The topic was not alone about the seal hunt (those products will be banned soon enough anyway, at least where the sane live). It's about scared people who pick up a vessel (with 17 people, who come from the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, France, Sweden, South Africa, Canada and the United States) in international waters, documenting the hunt.

Canada made a big deal of it, Canada blundered. I'm sorry for the supporters of such Chinese methods, but this is not end of story.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

It's not international waters.  It's within the 200 mile economic zone that have been repeatedly recognized as belonging to Canadian jurisdiction.  See the 1995 intervention with the Spanish for precedent.  I don't like the way the Fisheries Minister has handled it, but I don't think it was the wrong thing to do.  Charge them with violating the law for approaching sealing vessels, then let them go.  If footage and stuff is permanently seized, I would consider that an outrage.  This?  Not so.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

200 miles from the coast is an economic zone. Forbidden for foreign ships with cameras?
What's approaching in Canadian law?

Here some updates:

Protest vessel towed into Cape Breton port after high-profile RCMP seizure

SYDNEY, N.S. — About a dozen curious onlookers gathered at the Port of Sydney on Sunday as the anti-sealing vessel Farley Mowat was towed into the harbour and moored to a secure jetty 26 hours after the RCMP stormed and seized the protest vessel.

The seizure and subsequent arrest of two senior officers, condemned by the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society as an "act of war," has attracted international attention as the largest part of the annual East Coast seal hunt started off the north coast of Newfoundland.

Early Sunday, a crew member from the Mowat insisted Canadian authorities had no right to seize the ship as it was in international waters beyond Canada's 12-nautical-mile territorial limit.

David Jonas, a New Hampshire resident, described the tense confrontation to The Canadian Press after he was released from custody in Sydney. He and other members of the Mowat's crew were taken to the port the night before.

He confirmed that an RCMP tactical squad boarded the ship at 11 a.m. ADT Saturday while the Mowat's crew members were observing the hunt in the Cabot Strait - the body of water between Cape Breton and Newfoundland.

"We were placed under arrest, forced to lie down on the deck," said Jonas. "We were then escorted to the stern of the ship and kept under armed guard."

Jonas said some of his shipmates were handcuffed once aboard the coast guard icebreaker Des Groseilliers.

Jonas said the Mowat's 17 crew members were told they would be charged with violating Canada's sealing laws.

But the charges were later dropped against all but the captain and chief officer, who both made a brief appearance Sunday in a Sydney courtroom.

Jonas said Canada has no legal grounds to detain them.

"Canada did not have a right to board us and bring us to Sydney. We were in international waters. We're a Dutch-registered vessel and had the right of free passage."

Federal Fisheries Minister Loyola Hearn has insisted the Mowat was seized legally in Canada's "internal waters."

The Mowat's crew maintains their vessel never entered Canada's 12-nautical-mile territorial limit, but Hearn said the Fisheries Act gave him the authority to take action beyond that line.

Still, the Fisheries Department has confirmed that on March 29 - one day after the hunt started - Foreign Affairs issued a diplomatic note to the Netherlands requesting help dealing with the Mowat "as it is flying a Dutch flag."

A former sealer and head of the Canadian Sealers Association said the federal government did the "right and proper thing" by seizing the Mowat.

Frank Pinhorn of Conception Bay South, N.L., said the ice floes are no place for observers.

"We hear tell of them interfering with sealers on the ice, that they're getting between the sealers and their own boats so it's a real nuisance," said Pinhorn, whose association represents hunters from Newfoundland and Labrador.

"It's going to come to a point where someone is going to lose their patience, they're going to be a little bit edgy and they're going to react. That reaction could take any form at all. They got sticks in their hands, they got hakapiks and they got rifles, 'cause that's what they're out there doing."

Paul Watson, head of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, said the high-profile seizure represents a public relations coup for his movement as the European Union contemplates a ban on the importation of all seal products.

Watson, who was in New York when his ship was boarded, said he would drive to Sydney on Sunday.

Watson's group also took a swipe at Hearn on its website.

"The man has not even read Managing Fisheries for Dummies and in his zeal to kiss the bottoms of the seal-killing crowd he has thrown reason out the window ... Loyola Hearn is certainly the latest Nufie joke and the joke is about to backfire in his face."

Hearn heaped scorn on the environmental crusaders.

"These are a bunch of money-sucking manipulators," Hearn told a news conference in Ottawa on Saturday. "They're sole aim is to try to suck as much money out of the pockets of people who really don't know what's going on."

Hearn said the ship's captain and chief officer were arrested for allegedly violating Canada's marine mammal regulations and the Fisheries Act.

The charges stem from a high-seas confrontation in the Gulf of St. Lawrence between the Farley Mowat and the Des Groseilliers on March 30.

At the time, a group of seal hunters called for assistance from the coast guard, complaining that the Farley Mowat was getting too close to them on the floes north of Cape Breton.

The 98-metre icebreaker Des Groseilliers responded to the call and was "grazed" twice by the 54-metre Farley Mowat, the Fisheries Department says.

But the conservation group disputes that claim, saying its ship was instead rammed twice by the icebreaker.

Last week, Hearn's department alleged the Farley Mowat's captain, Alexander Cornelissen, and First Officer Peter Hammarstedt broke rules that prohibit anyone from coming within 900 metres of the hunt unless they have an observer's permit.

Cornelissen is also charged under the Fisheries Act with obstruction or hindrance of a Fishery Officer or inspector.

Hearn said the Mowat came within nine metres of a group sealers at one point on March 30.

The charges could result in fines of up to $100,000 or up to one year in jail, or both.

"We did the right thing," Hearn said, noting that the seizure and arrests were made on the opening day of the largest phase of the East Coast seal hunt.

"I'd rather act when nobody is hurt, rather than react when somebody got killed."

In Sydney, several members of the Mowat's crew were detained Sunday after they refused to comply with immigration and customs checks, Jonas said.

"Half of us have denied that opportunity, and will be interned," he said. "It's clearly an unusual circumstance for all involved."

Until they're released, the crew is going on a hunger strike, Jonas added.

The Mowat will be detained in Sydney for as long at it takes Transport Canada officials to conduct a full inspection, Hearn said.

The seizure effectively sidelines Watson's group as hunters start killing seals in a vast area north of Newfoundland known as the Front. About 70 per cent of the slaughter typically takes place in this area.

Under federal rules, seal hunters can take up to 275,000 harp seals this season, but low pelt prices and steep fuel costs have made the hunt a money-loser for many hunters. As a result, far fewer seals are expected to be slaughtered this year.

The pelts are primarily sold to buyers in Norway, Russia and China, who in turn use the fur to produce coats and other clothes. As well, there is a growing market for seal oil, which is high in a fatty acid that may prevent heart disease.

Federal officials say the harp seal population stands at about 5.5 million.

The Fisheries Department insists the hunt is sustainable and humane, providing much-needed income in the winter months to coastal communities where unemployment remains high.

Animals rights groups say the hunt is a barbaric, senseless slaughter that is poorly monitored.

Watson's group argues that the hunt is a threat to the harp seal species and that almost half of the seals killed are skinned alive, but Ottawa vehemently denies these claims.

The United States has banned Canadian seal products since 1972. The European Union banned imports of the white coats from the youngest harp seals in 1983.

----
+

Anti-sealers to be released on bail

Captain Alexander Cornelissen and first officer Peter Hammarstedt will be released on $5,000 bail, a spokeswoman with the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society said Sunday.

"They haven't been released yet," Allison Lance said Sunday. "We're posting bail and they will be released as soon as that happens."

If convicted, the maximum penalty is six months in jail and a $100,000 fine.

A criminal trial has been set for May 1.

Cornelissen and Hammarstedt were the only two who were criminally charged after armed RCMP officers seized the Farley Mowat, and arrested 17 of its crew members.

Everyone was brought into Sydney late Saturday night.

Lance said six crew members remain in custody by Canada Customs and Immigration because they declined to fill in immigration papers.

"They have refused to sign themselves into Canada," she said. "They didn't want to come into Canada. They were brought at gunpoint into Canada."

The six have been identified as Amber Paarman of South Africa, Dan Villa, Greg Hager and Merilee Nyland of the United States, Anne Fournier of France and Merryn Redenbach of Australia.

The group have gone on hunger strike to protest their situation.

The 11 who have been released, have also staged a hunger strike in front of the jail where their fellow crew members are being detained.

Lance said the seized Farley Mowat is expected to arrive at the Sydney harbour later Sunday.

Canada's fisheries minister Loyola Hearn defended his decision to raid the anti-sealing ship Saturday, saying that it had taken place in Canadian waters and in accordance with Canadian fisheries legislation.

He said the ship had failed to comply with warnings to proceed immediately to Sydney and continued to violate marine and fisheries regulations.

Canadian authorities allege that the Mowat endangered lives when it came close to a group of sealers on March 30, about 60 kilometres off of Cape Breton.

Nova Scotia sealer Shane Briand said at one point, the Mowat broke the ice up beneath a sealer as he stood on a floe.

Briand said the much larger Mowat harassed his ship and crew until a coast guard icebreaker arrived and put itself between the two ships.

The Fisheries Department says during the incident the icebreaker was "grazed" by the Mowat, while the Sea Shepherd Society says its ship was rammed.

In a news release Sunday, Captain Paul Watson, head of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, said he is worried about images and video that were contained on computers and laptops on the Mowat now under the possession of the Canadian Department of Fisheries.

"It is these images of brutal sadistic slaughter on the ice floes that Canada is desperate to keep hidden," he said in the statement. "What the Sea Shepherd crew have witnessed over the last two weeks has exposed the lies of Canadian government claims that the seal slaughter is inhumane."

Watson who was en route to Sydney Sunday, called the arrests "an act of war," claiming that the vessel had been out of Canadian jurisdiction when it was seized.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Forostar said:
200 miles from the coast is an economic zone. Forbidden for foreign ships with cameras?
What's approaching in Canadian law?

I believe approaching is being within 200 metres of a landed sealing vessel currently engaged in seal culling without an appropriate observation license (like those issued to DFO or Coast Guard ships by default, or issued to other watchmen who keep track of the hunt).  And yes, since this constitutes interference in a Canadian economic activity, the economic limit of 200 miles counts.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

It's all fear. They try to cover up their immoral beastly work.

Canada slammed for baby seal cull images

resize.php


Canada is trying desperately to block the release of seal cull images because of their potential damage to the nation's image.

The Canadian Government will this season kill hundreds of thousands of baby seals in the name of over-population.

Animal right's groups however say that the cull is a lie, and that the seal's fur is used in products around the world.

Environmental group the Sea Shepherd says it has footage of Canadian authorities bludgeoning the seals, and then skinning them while still alive.

Sea Shepherd leader Paul Watson said that such images could put Canada in strife with Europe.

"Last week we filmed a seal pup being skinned while it was still alive, these are the kind of images that the Canadian Government does not want us sending back to the European Parliament because they're on the verge of passing a bill to ban Canadian seal products," Mr Watson said.

It comes as Canadian authorities seize a Sea Shepherd boat as part of a law disallowing the photography or video observance of the seal cull.

The crew now claim the Canadian coast guard rammed their ship before boarding and arresting some of it's crew.

Captain Watson said the act could be seen as piracy, given the ship's Dutch registration.

The seal cull has been slammed around the world as inhumane and unacceptable.


-------------
+

IFAW: Shocking new footage from seal hunt refutes ‘humane hunt’ claims of Canadian delegation touring Europe

(Ottawa, Canada – April 4, 2008) – As Canadian government officials tour Europe in a bid to forestall an EU ban on seal products, the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW) released shocking new video evidence refuting the government’s claims that Canada’s commercial seal hunt has been made more humane.

Unacceptable cruelty, including wounded but conscious seals struggling in agony on the ice and the hooking and hoisting of a live seal into a boat has been documented at the hunt this week, at the very same time Canadian officials are heralding this year’s seal hunt as the most humane ever.

“The cruelty we witnessed earlier this week should not be tolerated anywhere in the world,” said Sheryl Fink, IFAW senior researcher and veteran seal hunt observer. “Once they see the evidence for themselves, it will be hard to convince Europeans that this hunt is anything other than inherently inhumane.”

Video evidence from the 2008 seal hunt clearly shows that the Canadian government’s new condition of licence - that seals should be bled out at some point ‘where possible’ - is not being followed by sealers.

“The Canadian Government can spin all the stories it wants in Europe, but our observations reveal the truth - no new condition of licence will make this hunt more humane,” said Robbie Marsland, Director of IFAW UK. “The rule is a sham and the cruelty is continuing.”

“The highly-touted condition of licence was obviously meant to convince Europeans that things have improved here in Canada. Our videos show that the new condition is not being followed, and that the rule is not being enforced. The Canadian delegation in Europe must be having a hard time explaining this one,” added Fink.

Fink also said she was “disgusted” by the Canadian government’s insistence on confusing the commercial seal hunt off Canada’s east coast with hunting by aboriginal peoples in Canada’s north.

“Inuit seal hunting and Canada’s commercial seal hunt are two completely different hunts, for different seals, in different places, at different times of the year,” said Fink. “This is a shameless attempt to play on the concerns of Europeans for aboriginal peoples, and to pass off the commercial hunt for fur coats as an Inuit hunt.”

IFAW is campaigning for an EU-wide ban on the trade in harp and hooded seal products to help end Canada’s commercial seal hunt. The campaign is gathering momentum with Belgium and the Netherlands having introduced national trade bans, and Germany and Italy working towards similar legislation. Trade bans are also in place in the US, Mexico, Croatia and Slovenia.

....Continued
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Less seals are killed in Canada's yearly seal hunt than die weekly in European fur farms.  And it's not "fear".  Canada has had four successive government run the seal hunt.  Knowing the way our internal politics work, someone would have cried foul if there was no real reason for doing a seal hunt.  The image you posted is of skinned seals, so yeah, there's going to be blood.

Each year DFO releases dozens of studies and documents done by both government-funded and independent ecologists.  There's even an international body that regulates the seal hunt, which Canada consults with yearly to set a quota.  This is based on the estimated health of the seal population.The numbers reflect that: quotas are reduced if there are natural reductions of the seal pup population, such as in 2007. 

International trade bans won't end the seal hunt.  Because that was never the real purpose to begin with.  The real purpose was to reduce the amount of baby seals that feed off of fish eggs around Newfoundland and reduce the fish population.  The seal hunt is simply designed to keep harp seals from overpopulation in the St Lawrence and Grand Banks areas, where they did rather severe damage to an already hurting fish population.  The harp seal has no natural predators due to whaling, and the harp seal isn't endangered nor has it ever been.

And when it comes down to it, whereas these intergovernmental environmental bodies are saying they have video, they observed, it'd be nice to see it.  (not nice, but it would be rather kind of them to produce evidence).  I have no doubt that some sealers have made mistakes, or are even cruel people, and as a result, regulations have not been followed, just like in any industry.  Certainly, I hope these ships kept numbers.  How many proper cullings vs. how many improper cullings.  If they can show that a large minority or majority of sealers are not following the rules?  Then we have an issue.  But one video after 2 weeks at sea, observing dozens or hundreds of seal hunters (remember, there's only 2,500)?  It suggests an isolated incident in which the perpetrators should certainly be punished.

But if these groups start putting out videos of what they want people to see without giving any support to the "other side", or without showing they even cared to track that?  Then it's spin.  It could be indicative of a problem or not, but it's still spin.  Maybe someone doesn't like the idea of a seal hunt, but just because someone shows you what you want to see, that doesn't make it unbiased or even attempted at unbiased.
In addition, for your viewing pleasure, let me link for you the Independent Veterinarians Working Group report of 2005, commissioned by the World Wildlife Fund, on the seal hunt.  A highlight of this report is, "Perception of the seal hunt seems to be based largely on emotion, and on visual images that are often difficult even for experienced observers to interpret with certainty. While a hakapik strike on the skull of a seal appears brutal, it is humane if it achieves rapid, irreversible loss of consciousness leading to death."

http://www.thesealfishery.com/files/IVW ... ug2005.pdf
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Whoa.  I am not, in any way, discouraging you from voicing your opinion, nor am I closing the thread because I disagree with it.  I am posting my own viewpoint.  Perun has posted his.  His was just more....sarcastic.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Right, I was just stating my opinion. I have now removed it since it seemed to be offensive.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

LC, I indeed have no problems with the way you act in this topic.

I am not a big fan of sarcasm, and especially not when it's related to people or animals who suffer. Other forummers don't have to take account with that. They don't have to, it's all opinion isn't it? Fine, I realize that.

Still, I found SMX's post pretty disturbing (and a lot more, but it's better not to state this here), and Perun's  post led me to say my previous one.

Thanks Per, I removed my previous post as well.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

I stand by my opinion, though.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

I can't really agree because in all food/meat industries the sufferings should be kept to the minimum. At the moment in the Netherlands the transports in the pig industry is under a sharp view because in some companies they put toomany pigs in one truck, causing unnecessary suffering.

varkenstransport.jpg


That's also wrong.

In the end it comes down to:

A. I don't mind the suffering &
B. I do mind the suffering.

From there, we can talk further.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Well, I agree with what Perun said, and I disagree with what SMX said, but that's not the point of the topic.  I simply believe that when a group like Sea Shepherd goes to videotape the seal hunt for the sole purpose of exposing how terrible it is, they are unlikely to present a balanced or fair point of view.  When governments clash with IGOs (intergovernmental organizations), usually the differences are in the PhDs.  If the hunt hadn't been monitored by international bodies of veterinarians who have assisted in ensuring and regulating the hunt, or if those people found it to be generally inhumane, then major international organizations like the WWF would be very loudly against the hunt.

I disagree with SMX in that it's part of the culture (it's not), though this is an argument often made, in error, by Canadian governmental supporters.  They should just stick to the facts.  Similarly, I think any culling of any animal needs to be done humanely; however, it is an industry, and not everything will be perfect every time.  This is why constant regulation by accredited bodies, both nationally and internationally, should be encouraged.  But Sea Shepherd, as a group, is not an accredited body, nor is it interested in scientific research.

Forostar, in general, the seal hunt is considered most humane (if appearing brutal) by international bodies.  The international standard for a humane death is actually set very high, at around 400 seconds by the loosest of standards and methods, and as low as 40 seconds; death in the seal hunt is between 20 and 40 seconds when done right.  Again, I certainly think we need to go after people who don't do it right.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Then you don't understand my opinion.

In nature, sharks and whales feed on seals. Sharks and whales have been extinced in the waters we are talking about (yes, by man). Hence, seals have no natural enemies. So, they can happily swim about and eat all the fish they like, and spread without limit. That means, there are more and more hungry seals who need to feed on fish. What has happened was that the seals have fed on fish faster than they could reproduce, thus endangering the fish in this area. The end of the song would be that the seals would have eaten all of the fish -hence the fish would be extinct- and would starve to death. Natural population control, in the shape of sharks and whales, would have eliminated that effect. The only thing that man can do to save the fish and the seals is to, sadly, kill some of the seals, precisely that share that would be killed by sharks and whales in nature.
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

I wonder if you have understood or even read my previous posts as well. Have you read the articles?

S U F F E R

I N H U M AN E way of hunting

No monitoring

No witnesses allowed


I can go on and on (heaven and hell!) repeating some of these things, if you wish.

I am posting actual news, not only theories. The US bans this crap already sinçe the seventies but Europe will follow soon enough. You think they want to risk a trade war with Canada, without looking well into it?
 
Re: O Canada, we stand on guard for thee...

Forostar said:
I can't really agree because in all food/meat industries the sufferings should be kept to the minimum.

I think that's fair.  But like I already said, in the report I posted earlier, the group found that the majority of cullings occurred well within internationally set guidelines, similar to the guidelines set for beef, ham, etc.  Even if those guidelines aren't always met in that particular industry.  But yes, I think that it is fairly easy to do it humanely, so it should be done so.

Forostar said:
I wonder if you have understood or even read my previous posts as well. Have you read the articles?

S U F F E R

I N H U M AN E way of hunting

No monitoring

No witnesses allowed

Those allegations aren't true.  This year alone Canada issued over 60 observation tickets to various NGOs and IGOs.  Canada has constantly hired veterinarians and wildlife experts to monitor the hunt and has encouraged monitoring from sanctions NGOs like WWF.  And SCIENTIFICALLY the generally accepted method for culling seals is considered humane.

Some crazy eco-nuts with a camera doesn't change that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top