Best Album Ever Survivor: Somewhere In Time wins

[Mosh]

Night At The Opera is near perfect. Top ten easily.

 

[The Flash]

But not as insane as all Pink Floyd classic albums already being eliminated.

Still can't get over that.

 

[Saapanael]

Accident
Operation
Appetite
Chemical
TFF

 

[mckindog]

Rules are here:
http://forum.maidenfans.com/threads/best-album-ever-survivor.25528/

Down goes: The Final Frontier, British Steel, Appetite For Destruction, A Night at the Opera

Twenty albums left, eight of them Maiden.

We want to end up with two top 10s — one including Maiden, one without.
So we are now shifting to a maximum of THREE votes.

 

[mckindog]

X Factor, Rising, Sad Wings

 

[The Flash]

TFF is gone? What a shame.

TXF
Rising
Screaming

 

[Vap]

Accident Of Birth
Sad Wings (careless error, meant to vote for Defenders!)
Number Of The Beast

 

[Forostar]

In the last 20 albums we're having:

8 Maiden albums:
7 Maiden w/Bruce albums (all 1980s + BNW & AMOLAD)
1 Maiden w/Blaze album (The X-Factor)

12 non-Maiden albums, represented by 7 different acts.
Band with 5 albums:
Painkiller — Judas Priest
Sad Wings of Destiny — Judas Priest
Screaming for Vengeance — Judas Priest
Sin After Sin — Judas Priest
Defenders of the Faith — Judas Priest

Band with 2 albums:
Chemical Wedding — Bruce Dickinson
Accident of Birth — Bruce Dickinson

Bands with 1 album
Heaven and Hell — Black Sabbath
Moving Pictures — Rush
Operation Mindcrime — Queensryche
Rising — Rainbow
Ride the Lightning — Metallica

 

[Cornfed Hick]

X Factor, Rising, Sad Wings

What is it about Operation Mindcrime that could make anyone possibly think it is better than Rising (or A Night at the Opera or Dark Side of the Moon)? Not a rhetorical question, I'm genuinely curious. It's a solid album, yes, but wow. And here I was thinking that Maiden fans had good taste!

X Factor, Sad Wings, Mindcrime

 

[SixesAlltheway]

Always thought Mindcrime was totally overrated. Queensryche too for that matter

 

[Forostar]

1. Operation Mindcrime — Queensryche
2. Rising — Rainbow
3. Screaming for Vengeance — Judas Priest

 

[Unknown One]

Rising and Sad Wings on the chopping block?

 

[Unknown One]

X Factor, Number, Mindcrime

 

[Saapanael]

Accident
Operation
Sin
Chemical
A Matter of

 

[Forostar]

@Saapanael: only 3 choices!

 

[Saapanael]

@Saapanael: only 3 choices!

Oh, damn, didn't notice. In that case, I'll eliminate Accident, Chemical and Operation.

 

[Forostar]

Saapanael, but then you have only 2 votes left (you did 5?), which is allowed of course.

Alert !!
At the moment, the standings are not what they look like:
Ariana, Collin, Mosh and Cosmiceddie also voted more than 3 times.
I guess all votes by anyone who does not correct it, will be erased.
(And naturally, in such occasions, let's not forget these persons should also not be counted in the total amount of voters, which decides which albums are eliminated)

 

[Saapanael]

Saapanael, but then you have only 2 votes left (you did 5?), which is allowed of course.

Alert !!
At the moment, the standings are not what they look like:
Ariana, Collin, Mosh and Cosmiceddie also voted more than 3 times.
I guess all votes by anyone who does not correct it, will be erased.
(And naturally, in such occasions, let's not forget those persons should also not be counted in the total amount of voters, which decides which albums are eliminated).

No, I mean, I'll eliminate Accident, Chemical and Operation from the game. Sin and Matter can stay in the survivor.

 

[Forostar]

Aha, you mean I vote for these three albums?
In the past, I think people mentioned which votes should not be counted.

 

[Saapanael]

Aha, you mean I vote for these three albums?
In the past, I think people mentioned which votes should not be counted.

Now I know.