Could not agree more. And if he sells his tickets he just might regret it. I think this tour is going to be specialNo disrespect intended here, but as soon as Doctor Doctor starts and the adrenaline kicks in do you really think anyone in attendance is going to hate the fact Nicko isn't there and be thinking "this doesn't feel like Maiden no more" ? All the focus will be on the 5 guys upfront and it will still be an amazing Maiden experience, it seems strange to even think about selling your ticket, but that's just me. There is life without the goat drummer even tho it's sad and less than ideal.
For me, I don’t think I will ever see a Maiden gig as good as the 2018 first night at the O2. Even my uncle, who has been watching from the early days, text me saying ‘that was bloody incredible’. To me, that will be the best tour they have ever done.Retiring after LOTB 2019 would have certainly been going out on a HUGE high point in terms of performance and stage show.
But we wouldn't have had the Future Past tour, which despite Nickos stroke was still a fantastic fan service tour.
I get the principle, but I'm afraid you are giving audiences too much credit. I'm sure a huge chunk of the more casual fans won't know or notice a difference.I gotta be honest: audience reactions be damned, anyone with a working set of ears and a brain to process inputs will notice the difference. Feel isn't something you simply transfer over to another guy. It will be different. Hopefully it won't be worse.
And was not the same from 1995 to 1998, and now we can see that was another age for iron maidenIt’s definitely not going to be the same.
Exactly. Tbese days, half the audience at Maiden shows is normal mainstream audience that usually won't even listen to Metal (pretty much like the Wacken crowd). Many of them won't even know the line up change happened, let alone hear a difference.I get the principle, but I'm afraid you are giving audiences too much credit. I'm sure a huge chunk of the more casual fans won't know or notice a difference.
I don't know what to think now, but by ''getting their man'', I think Rod meant Simon.So do you mean you think Maiden is still working on "getting their man" (strange wording in the announcement, I feel that would fit more if they had convinced a star drummer to join Maiden) and that man is not Simon?
Simon will be under a fairly tight contract regarding interviews, social media etc.
IF Simon does any Maiden related interviews then management will decide what, when and where.
This.Could see him do a interview for the fanclub magazine just before tour start or during the tour.
I still think such a tour would be good in terms of a success, but Maiden to drop all of their classics - I can't see that. They didn't do it in 2010.There is no bloody money in bloody that.
I understand you and I feel the same (it won't be the same), but I think (and hope) I'll enjoy the Maiden show as always. They're magic.One question to all who are going to see Maiden on the upcoming tour, because I asked myself the same question and I'm curious if someone out there might feel the same way I do:
With the new drummer it feels not like Maiden anymore to me. I'm sure the shows will be good, they all give their best - but still, without Nicko it feels to me like this isn't Maiden anymore. It's the other five guys with a new drummer, but not Maiden. Incomplete. The gap just can't be filled, and I don't say that because I had a problem with the new drummer. I have not. I would feel the same way as I described if they had for example even Dave Lombardo or Mike Portnoy on drums - they could have the greatest drummer in the world behind the kit. So I have a feeling that I won't be really able to enjoy the shows, and I was seriously thinking about not going but selling my tickets.
How do you feel about it?
No for me, considering the next tours. TFP was special and I enjoyed it, even with Nicko not at his best (noticeably; as he had said before, he doesn't want to hold the band back, which is understandable and something to praise him for). And I don't think all of the old classic bands retired when they were on top. LOTB was quite the tour and the band sounded great and on form in 2019 (2022 was a bit rough after the long break), but there was no reason for them to do it. And with a new album already recorded. I wanted the Reunion lineup to be the final one, but since Maiden are still going, I have no right to complain, right. The band is not ''too old'', they are still on fire live and doing great.Sometimes I am starting to contemplate that Maiden should have retired right after Legacy of the Beast tour. Yes, Bruce still can sing but i have strange feeling that after LOTB they passed some sort of Rubicon. In the words of Robert Murtaugh "They are too old for this shit"...
(make no mistake, selfish me wants Maiden to carry on, but my impartial part says otherwise)
And yes, Bruce kicked ass on his solo tour.
I will miss that too.I wonder if Nicko will still be the one to drop some setlist spoilers.
It's not about the sight, it's about the feel and the person, the most of all.Same. Not to mention, for 99% of the show, you don't even see Nicko, because he's buried behind a 10,000-piece drum kit.
Agreed here. But this time, perhaps because of the stage of the band's career, it feels very different and difficult to accept.For me, it was still Maiden after Paul and Clive, different but still Maiden after Adrian, very different after Bruce, Maiden again after Blaze.
Well said.All the focus will be on the 5 guys upfront and it will still be an amazing Maiden experience
I think you're right.As wild as it is, I think a lot of how much people in the audience will notice will depend on how high Simon sits compared to Nicko. One of the signature visuals of the Maiden show is the “invisible drummer.”
The hardcore fans, yes. Different, yes. Good, I think so. Worse, I doubt it. Better? No one is Nicko, but he struggled. Let's hear Simon first though.I gotta be honest: audience reactions be damned, anyone with a working set of ears and a brain to process inputs will notice the difference. Feel isn't something you simply transfer over to another guy. It will be different. Hopefully it won't be worse.
New age would be if they work with Simon in the studio for 2 more albums. 1995-1998 was a different moment in time, but there are some connections, live the most.And was not the same from 1995 to 1998, and now we can see that was another age for iron maiden
About the first comment - agreed, but Nicko is essential for sure. As for the second comment - I wouldn't say so.I am not a line up completist, but I understand them. With any band that you are fan of, there are some factors that define the very essence of he band for you. If those factors are gone, the band has lost its soul for you. Wether or not Nicko is such an essentialfactor...
Maiden's fan base is - no judgement, just observation - generally very uncritical about the band and tends to glorify or at least justify anything the band does, so losing Nicko won't cause the band much trouble.
Priest are still killing it. A lot of fans though gripe that it's a tribute band because of no Glen or KK, it's just Rob and Ian from the "classic" line up, though I consider Scott a bonafide member as he's been there a very long time (like Janick)I'm just happy they didn't retire. Maiden with a new drummer is better than no Maiden at all. Judas Priest are still touring without KK and Tipton and they still sound amazing. Maiden will be better with a new drummer to be honest as mush as I'll miss Nicko.
massive (lack of) shoesIf anyone is really upset about Simon coming on board and wants to sell their tickets to Copenhagen, let me know, I will buy them.
Everyone else, I'm sorry to say this: it wasn't the same with Nicko, either. I love the guy, and salute him for getting through this last tour, but he wasn't the same. I saw this show four times and all four had drumming issues. The show in Montreal was a peak "Adrian is furious constantly" show, and even when Nicko was on, he couldn't use the drum kit fully, not even close.
So yes, Simon won't be the same. Guy has to fill some massive (lack of) shoes, too, so I don't envy him. But Nicko couldn't anymore, and I'm glad he saw the writing on the wall, y'know?
I would just love to see a Maiden concert that no longer uses the 2003 Dance of Death tour stage set up.Whats everyone's thoughts on the stage production for this?
I think the chat about them using big screens in the place of backdrops is likely accurate. TFPT was almost like a test run to see what they could do with it.
I'm looking at things like the giant CGI characters and landscapes that are being put on at the sphere in Vegas. Maiden could totally do something like this for each song.
We know the LOTB game team are available and have mentioned doing something with Maiden in the future, I think they're prepping graphics for the new tour.
I just hope if that's the route they're going down that it's done to a really high quality.
If anyone is really upset about Simon coming on board and wants to sell their tickets to Copenhagen, let me know, I will buy them.
Everyone else, I'm sorry to say this: it wasn't the same with Nicko, either? ...
Yeah, for me, it comes down to meeting a certain technical level. And Nick isn't there anymore. He was playing drum solos on one snare. Again, very game to try and do his best, but it is clear that his time has passed for live performances. I would rather see someone come in and play than the band stop. And frankly, if that person comes in and is different...that's fine, too! We haven't gotten the original drumming intent for Hallowed since 1982...That's an interesting question: does it only depend on the fact that a certain person is on stage?
A band member can have problems, e.g. health or drug problems, so that the band sounds different because of that, not because of a new member. Is it just a matter of a certain person being there to still make it the same band, not really how they sound?
If anyone is really upset about Simon coming on board and wants to sell their tickets to Copenhagen, let me know, I will buy them.
Everyone else, I'm sorry to say this: it wasn't the same with Nicko, either. I love the guy, and salute him for getting through this last tour, but he wasn't the same. I saw this show four times and all four had drumming issues. The show in Montreal was a peak "Adrian is furious constantly" show, and even when Nicko was on, he couldn't use the drum kit fully, not even close.
So yes, Simon won't be the same. Guy has to fill some massive (lack of) shoes, too, so I don't envy him. But Nicko couldn't anymore, and I'm glad he saw the writing on the wall, y'know?
Yeah, I mean, ultimately, you get to vote with your wallet if you think Maiden shouldn't be touring anymore. They have the right to do as they see fit, and so do you. The lineup is no less special to me, and it was, at times, painful to see Nicko struggling on the past tour. I am glad he saw sense and decided to call it a day, though.I guess at the end of the day it all depends on how each of us sees the band and the emotional connection with the different line-ups. I have been a fan since 1991, so Nicko has always provided the backbone to the Maiden sound with Steve. I have seen the band live 35 times, 33 of them with the Dickinson-Harris-Murray-Smith-Gers-McBrain line-up, and Nicko has always been there with his immense skills providing some very special drumming and his larger-than-life character. A unique musician (I must admit I was not a big fan of his jokes).
Sure enough, his stroke meant that his abilities were affected on the Future Past tour. However, I was still hoping he would be playing drums for Maiden until they called it a day but, alas, I was wrong. His retirement is understandable, but I am not sure I would have played £100 for a ticket to see them in 2025 had I known what was coming.
Bottom line is I was probably naïve (and obviously wrong) to think that Maiden would be different to other old bands who would keep on replacing band members for the sake of carrying on. They are printing money in the final lap of their career, so I cannot see them stopping anytime soon. I hope the final concert is not with the guitar player with the Churchill tattoo from British Lion prancing instead of Janick, or some other random musician smiling instead of Dave though.
Yeah, I mean, ultimately, you get to vote with your wallet if you think Maiden shouldn't be touring anymore. They have the right to do as they see fit, and so do you.