Random album reviews

Grace Under Pressure Tour.jpg

Rush
Grace Under Pressure Tour
(2009)

Finally a great live album from Rush. This record is a bit short, but it absolutely transports you right to 1984. Geddy's voice is a little weaker, but it doesn't matter because the energy is all there. "Spirit of Radio" rocks where the Exit... Stage Left version limped. The "Fear" trilogy are awesome and actually work better together as a trio than they did separately on their original albums. Capping them off with "New World Man" is great. "Closer to the Heart" is amazing as ever; the "YYZ"/"Temples of Syrinx"/"Tom Sawyer" medley rocks; and "Vital Signs" has never sounded more vital. Bum ending with "In the Mood" but otherwise, great record.

Total: 84%
 
Power Windows.png

Rush
Power Windows
(1985)

1. The Big Money - Welcome to Corporate America. Synthesizers rise like skyscrapers. Guitars sparkle like casinos. Drums hit you on all sides, just like your bank statements after being sucked into this world of "The Big Money". It's an incredible intro, and it gets quickly replaced by synths and percussion that sounds like scanners and cash registers in a department store, before the guitar pulls everything back to look at the bosses who reap the rewards of low-level people like you and me. "Big Money goes around the world!" Neil takes a critical look at the narratives of the 1%. It's not totally negative, but it's definitely than you would have expected from someone who used to use Ayn Rand as his biggest inspiration. The production is so in-your-face. So much happening at all times. Peter Collins is immediately making himself known. The solo is awesome, Alex just lights it the fuck up and holds those notes for all he's worth. I love how Geddy's voice rises and falls throughout the track, really pulling on the excitement of this rollercoaster ride. Love the return to the intro, and then ending with an extra riff just for shits and giggles? Impeccable. 10/10

2. Grand Designs - Continuing on from the themes of "The Big Money", the band now take a look at the products of soulless consumerism and reject them in favor of producing something of substance. It doubles as a continuation from their motto in "Vital Signs" - "Everybody got to elevate from the norm." It has transformed into a bigger and bolder statement here - "Against the run-of-the-mill, static as it seems, we break the surface tension with our wild kinetic dreams!" And goddamn do they break that surface tension with something kinetic. This song is GORGEOUS. The keys shine like diamonds, the guitar is energetic, Neil is CRUSHING that kit, and Geddy's voice rings like gold. Fuck me, dude. Holy shit. 10/10

3. Manhattan Project - Rush take a step outside of the bubble of greed to look at the Cold War tensions of the time, thinking back to the moment that would shape the rest of the century - the dropping of the atomic bomb. Neil goes through picturesque detail of every step in the chain that led up to the destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the Manhattan Project. Within the song, the lyrics almost border on clumsy at times, but I think they're overall successful. "The pilot of Enola Gay riding out of the shockwave...!" is pretty powerful. The instrumental, complete with a string orchestra, is as haunting as a nuclear winter. The song's biggest issue is its tight grip on a chorus that's decent but doesn't need to be repeated as much as it is. Still a great song though. 8/10

4. Marathon - Whether you're a runner, a politician, a businessman, or some guy writing iffy Rush reviews on an Iron Maiden forum, we all have something driving us to achieve something. And once that thing has been achieved, the moment is over. It's slipped into the past. Some people throw in the towel after that. Others get fired up by the next big thing. Neil perfectly encapsulates this feeling in this song. "One moment's high, and glory rolls on by..." Geddy's voice really lifts off in that chorus (and don't get me started on the key change at the end!). But the secret star of this song is Alex, whose solo is easily one of the best he's ever done thus far. 9/10

5. Territories - A song that pans the tribal, nationalist instincts of so-called 'civilized' nations deserves a suitably tribal rhythm from the percussion, and Neil absolutely locks in to get the job done. It's not overly showy, but it's so tasty. Alex stays out of the way during the first verse but then comes in with some screeching, fiery guitar before laying down a rocking riff in the pre-chorus. The chorus swirls around you, trying to take a step out of the madness. I wish there was a bigger instrumental section to this one, but that's about it - another excellent song. 9/10

6. Middletown Dreams - Beautiful song. The synths dominate this track (probably the most '80s-sounding of this utterly '80s-sounding album). They dance all across this track like the lonely dreamers whose pictures line the track - a salesman, a boy, a middle-aged woman. Lonely people with big dreams who get up each day because they have those dreams. Geddy's voice is once again the perfect instrument to bring across their emotions. The chorus is so tender and heartfelt. My favorite part in this song is the little burst of energy after the bridge, leading into an incredible drum fill before returning to the chorus. Almost wish it was longer. So good. 10/10

7. Emotion Detector - It's so easy to overlook the penultimate track on an album but boy does this one get better with every listen. A call to embrace your emotions filled with really vibrant synths and gorgeous playing from everyone involved. 9/10

8. Mystic Rhythms - I mean, the fucking title says it all. This is a mystically track. A rhythmic track. After an album about business interests, with glimpses into war and an underlying current of a return to hope and feelings over cold unemotional focus, "Mystic Rhythms" is that final glimpse into the unknown that calls us from out of our daily lives. These are the rhythms that feed "Middletown Dreams", that build "Grand Designs", that pull us to not only complete the "Marathon", but to give it up in favor of something bigger. They come calling us from every walk of life, from any "Territory" we might inhabit. For those people who have not fully lost themselves to "The Big Money", they drive us to take the next leap of faith in the darkness.

This track is magnificent. Neil's drumming is so good. Its structure is almost stripped-down, but Peter Collins and the band throw the entire kitchen sink into the production. Every instrument echoes. There are Eastern influences, tribal influences, with plenty of space left to glimpse the Northern Lights or canopies of stars. Geddy's doubled voice in the last chorus is awesome. It's not often that Rush save the best song for last, but this is absolutely that. The cherry on top of an already incredible album. 10/10

OVERALL


I first became interested in Power Windows when Jer gave it his highest rating during his Rush discography run. My knowledge of post-Moving Pictures Rush didn't extend past "Subdivisions", so when I found this CD in a record store I was pretty excited to play it and it did not disappoint. Coming back to it now and dedicatedly uncovering all of its nooks and crannies has been a treat. It's easy to see why some people downplay this album, because it takes the sound of '80s Rush and goes over the top with it, especially in the production side of things, but to me it's also the perfect blend of synths and guitars, of mainstream influence and all the qualities that make Rush so good in the first place. It's almost like you took the great choruses and melodies of Grace Under Pressure, but then took the brazenness that made "Red Lenses" fail, mixed it together and succeeded.

Neck-and-neck with Hemispheres as the second-best Rush album (at least so far), but Power Windows gets a slight nod for being an impeccable overall package. I also really like the themes within this one as well. There's a cohesive identity to it all. This is the band finally regaining the magic they were firing with on that run that led to Moving Pictures. Some tinkering along the way allowed them to regroup as fresh and as fiery as ever before.

Total: 94%
 
View attachment 45062

Rush
Power Windows
(1985)

1. The Big Money - Welcome to Corporate America. Synthesizers rise like skyscrapers. Guitars sparkle like casinos. Drums hit you on all sides, just like your bank statements after being sucked into this world of "The Big Money". It's an incredible intro, and it gets quickly replaced by synths and percussion that sounds like scanners and cash registers in a department store, before the guitar pulls everything back to look at the bosses who reap the rewards of low-level people like you and me. "Big Money goes around the world!" Neil takes a critical look at the narratives of the 1%. It's not totally negative, but it's definitely than you would have expected from someone who used to use Ayn Rand as his biggest inspiration. The production is so in-your-face. So much happening at all times. Peter Collins is immediately making himself known. The solo is awesome, Alex just lights it the fuck up and holds those notes for all he's worth. I love how Geddy's voice rises and falls throughout the track, really pulling on the excitement of this rollercoaster ride. Love the return to the intro, and then ending with an extra riff just for shits and giggles? Impeccable. 10/10

2. Grand Designs - Continuing on from the themes of "The Big Money", the band now take a look at the products of soulless consumerism and reject them in favor of producing something of substance. It doubles as a continuation from their motto in "Vital Signs" - "Everybody got to elevate from the norm." It has transformed into a bigger and bolder statement here - "Against the run-of-the-mill, static as it seems, we break the surface tension with our wild kinetic dreams!" And goddamn do they break that surface tension with something kinetic. This song is GORGEOUS. The keys shine like diamonds, the guitar is energetic, Neil is CRUSHING that kit, and Geddy's voice rings like gold. Fuck me, dude. Holy shit. 10/10

3. Manhattan Project - Rush take a step outside of the bubble of greed to look at the Cold War tensions of the time, thinking back to the moment that would shape the rest of the century - the dropping of the atomic bomb. Neil goes through picturesque detail of every step in the chain that led up to the destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the Manhattan Project. Within the song, the lyrics almost border on clumsy at times, but I think they're overall successful. "The pilot of Enola Gay riding out of the shockwave...!" is pretty powerful. The instrumental, complete with a string orchestra, is as haunting as a nuclear winter. The song's biggest issue is its tight grip on a chorus that's decent but doesn't need to be repeated as much as it is. Still a great song though. 8/10

4. Marathon - Whether you're a runner, a politician, a businessman, or some guy writing iffy Rush reviews on an Iron Maiden forum, we all have something driving us to achieve something. And once that thing has been achieved, the moment is over. It's slipped into the past. Some people throw in the towel after that. Others get fired up by the next big thing. Neil perfectly encapsulates this feeling in this song. "One moment's high, and glory rolls on by..." Geddy's voice really lifts off in that chorus (and don't get me started on the key change at the end!). But the secret star of this song is Alex, whose solo is easily one of the best he's ever done thus far. 9/10

5. Territories - A song that pans the tribal, nationalist instincts of so-called 'civilized' nations deserves a suitably tribal rhythm from the percussion, and Neil absolutely locks in to get the job done. It's not overly showy, but it's so tasty. Alex stays out of the way during the first verse but then comes in with some screeching, fiery guitar before laying down a rocking riff in the pre-chorus. The chorus swirls around you, trying to take a step out of the madness. I wish there was a bigger instrumental section to this one, but that's about it - another excellent song. 9/10

6. Middletown Dreams - Beautiful song. The synths dominate this track (probably the most '80s-sounding of this utterly '80s-sounding album). They dance all across this track like the lonely dreamers whose pictures line the track - a salesman, a boy, a middle-aged woman. Lonely people with big dreams who get up each day because they have those dreams. Geddy's voice is once again the perfect instrument to bring across their emotions. The chorus is so tender and heartfelt. My favorite part in this song is the little burst of energy after the bridge, leading into an incredible drum fill before returning to the chorus. Almost wish it was longer. So good. 10/10

7. Emotion Detector - It's so easy to overlook the penultimate track on an album but boy does this one get better with every listen. A call to embrace your emotions filled with really vibrant synths and gorgeous playing from everyone involved. 9/10

8. Mystic Rhythms - I mean, the fucking title says it all. This is a mystically track. A rhythmic track. After an album about business interests, with glimpses into war and an underlying current of a return to hope and feelings over cold unemotional focus, "Mystic Rhythms" is that final glimpse into the unknown that calls us from out of our daily lives. These are the rhythms that feed "Middletown Dreams", that build "Grand Designs", that pull us to not only complete the "Marathon", but to give it up in favor of something bigger. They come calling us from every walk of life, from any "Territory" we might inhabit. For those people who have not fully lost themselves to "The Big Money", they drive us to take the next leap of faith in the darkness.

This track is magnificent. Neil's drumming is so good. Its structure is almost stripped-down, but Peter Collins and the band throw the entire kitchen sink into the production. Every instrument echoes. There are Eastern influences, tribal influences, with plenty of space left to glimpse the Northern Lights or canopies of stars. Geddy's doubled voice in the last chorus is awesome. It's not often that Rush save the best song for last, but this is absolutely that. The cherry on top of an already incredible album. 10/10

OVERALL


I first became interested in Power Windows when Jer gave it his highest rating during his Rush discography run. My knowledge of post-Moving Pictures Rush didn't extend past "Subdivisions", so when I found this CD in a record store I was pretty excited to play it and it did not disappoint. Coming back to it now and dedicatedly uncovering all of its nooks and crannies has been a treat. It's easy to see why some people downplay this album, because it takes the sound of '80s Rush and goes over the top with it, especially in the production side of things, but to me it's also the perfect blend of synths and guitars, of mainstream influence and all the qualities that make Rush so good in the first place. It's almost like you took the great choruses and melodies of Grace Under Pressure, but then took the brazenness that made "Red Lenses" fail, mixed it together and succeeded.

Neck-and-neck with Hemispheres as the second-best Rush album (at least so far), but Power Windows gets a slight nod for being an impeccable overall package. I also really like the themes within this one as well. There's a cohesive identity to it all. This is the band finally regaining the magic they were firing with on that run that led to Moving Pictures. Some tinkering along the way allowed them to regroup as fresh and as fiery as ever before.

Total: 94%
Rush has been my lifelong favorite band since I was a 10 year old kid and my older brother made me a cassette copy of his Moving Pictures record which was newly released that year. Having said that, I consider Power Windows to be the last truly great Rush album for my tastes. There's been a lot of good music after that, each (or at least most) album had a few songs I enjoyed, but I believe Power Windows was the last triumph. After that I had to grade on a curve because 'It's Rush'. Ironically I was too young to see them live until the tour for the following album Hold Your Fire.

I very much enjoy all eight songs on this album, but my personal favorite is Grand Designs. Holy crap by the end it sounds like a glorious symphony. Plus extra points for the guitar solo in Emotion Detector.

p.s. Fun Fact when this album was released I had a subscription to Rolling Stone magazine. RS had a longstanding tradition of absolutely loathing everything by Rush. But in the review for Power Windows they called it - I can't remember the exact words so I'll paraphrase it - 'A cross between Yes and the Sex Pistols'. And they meant that as a compliment.
 
p.s. Fun Fact when this album was released I had a subscription to Rolling Stone magazine. RS had a longstanding tradition of absolutely loathing everything by Rush. But in the review for Power Windows they called it - I can't remember the exact words so I'll paraphrase it - 'A cross between Yes and the Sex Pistols'. And they meant that as a compliment.
I was literally reading this on Wikipedia shortly before you posted that! I was like whaaaat? Cross between Yes and the Police would’ve made more sense lol.
 
Did not expect this to be the Knick-certified Rush record…
I wouldn’t actually give it a 10/10 and I agree Red Lenses is pretty weak. Body Electric and Kid Gloves are also a couple notches down from the rest, but still solid.

The other 5 songs are easy 10/10’s though. I rank it 3rd or 4th in the whole discography.
 
Hold Your Fire.webp

Rush
Hold Your Fire
(1987)

1. Force Ten - Shocked to say that this is the weakest opening track on any Rush album thus far, especially because I don’t dislike the song or the way it sets the pace for the rest of the album. This is a synth rocker with a bit of bite to it and actually a ton of groove. Love the “Tough times demand tough talk…” hook and the way Geddy’s voice is just ahead of the music in the verses. Also love the little drum pattern Neil has in the intro and outro. I think the chorus, which represents the eye of a storm, isn’t as interesting and the song makes a mistake by using it again at the end, but this is overall a good song and a good opener. I guess I’m just used to Rush striding right in with big statements on their first tracks, but then again “Force Ten” does represent the more muted approach of the rest of the album while also showcasing some positive notes as well. 7/10

2. Time Stand Still - Every review I’ve seen of this album has basically amounted to “not one of Rush’s best, but ‘Time Stand Still’ is basically the best thing they wrote since Moving Pictures.” I have to say that I completely understand and pretty much agree. This is by far the best track on the album. It is beautiful, dynamic, and so powerful. Alex is always good about sparkly guitar lines and here they shine brighter than ever before. Neil’s lyrics are so thoughtful and Geddy sings them with real emotion - basically everything I like about Rush on full display. The chorus is incredible and super memorable but I also really love the raised doubled line of “I can wait until the tide comes around…” And of course Aimee Mann from ‘Til Tuesday guest stars on this track. She’s used very sparingly, on some a couple lines in the pre-chorus, as part of the instrumental section, and then doubling a couple of Geddy’s lines. The effect works really well. Just an incredible track about wanting time to stop moving for just a moment. 10/10

3. Open Secrets - An attempt at an empathetic approach to understanding each other. It’s a warm, synth-driven ballad, solid but not super memorable. I think “Entre Nous” did it better. 6/10

4. Second Nature - I guess that marveling after those who sought wonders in the world, wonders in the world, wonders in the world can only last until you glimpse the destruction they are just as capable of. Neil decides to right an open letter to those in power and it’s easily the worst lyrics he’s ever written. Honestly I had to go check if he even wrote them, and unfortunately, he did. Stream of consciousness plea to the world and it’s actually so shit. Musically the song is trying really really hard to play on your heartstrings and utterly fails at being interesting. This isn’t just the worst song on the album, it’s one of the worst songs they’ve ever written. 4/10

5. Prime Mover - We’re bringing the energy back up after the last two softer track. “Prime Mover” is a bouncing song but it’s also filled with a ton of ‘80s warmth. I guess the only thing holding me back from saying that it’s good is that it plods a little. There’s some start-and-stop friction with the “Anything can happen…” line and the lines in the verses and chorus don’t vary enough for me. But it’s solid and there are fun aspects to it. 6/10

6. Lock and Key - Geddy’s opening of “I don’t wanna face the killer instinct!” sounds really, really silly, but the song actually manages to make something of itself after that. There’s a really interesting balance between hard rock and synth pop inspiration. The pre-chorus and instrumental section remind me of Guns N’ Roses, meanwhile the chorus is so ‘80s it’s artery-clogging. Not a fan of the fade-out, just as things are getting interesting musically. I like this one overall though. 7/10

7. Mission - Another soft song, with Geddy at his most tender and the music more suffocatingly ‘80s than anything they’ve ever done before. I don’t dislike it, but it’s not a song I’m writing home about. The best thing here is definitely Geddy’s voice, although the instrumental section actually harkens back to the prog days with a little bit of marimba action. 6/10

8. Turn the Page - This song kinda cooks, I’m not gonna lie. Cool bass intro, slowly building verse, and then some awesome keyboard blasts as we enter a big, awesome chorus. Fun to sing along with, fun to bop your head to. The ending is a whirlwind of chorus lines coming at you from all sides. Great song. 8/10

9. Tai Shan - I’d always heard that “Tai Shan” was apparently the worst Rush song so I was curious to finally hear it. It’s really not that bad. It’s just Neil waxing poetic about China over pan flutes, epic synths, and Chinese-inspired guitar. I think it’s just kinda average and doesn’t really go anywhere, but I would take it over the mixed bag that was “Red Lenses”. 5/10

10. High Water - The album ends on a note about the prehistoric call of water that Neil is feeling on a deep level. I really like the conjuring up of images of times we can only imagine, when the whole earth was covered in blue. I think it gets a little clunky with the “Water takes me home, the water takes me home” line, but overall this is a good ending to the album. 7/10

OVERALL


I hope you´ll be gently to Hold Your Fire. That album always gets poor reviews and ranked low in their discography.

I hope this was a gentle enough review. I don't think this is a bad album and I don't think any of the songs are bad (other than maybe "Second Nature"), but it's a lot weaker than Rush have been since their debut. Power Windows works because it uses '80s elements and injects the Rush style, with a shitload of prog nods throughout. Hold Your Fire does that on "Time Stand Still" and... that's about it. Otherwise it's like Rush is sacrificing their style in favor of AOR (the New Wave influence is pretty much absent here). Lots of synths, and a lot of the tracks try to be warm and tender, but they just aren't as interesting as Rush usually are. I like the album, but it's definitely far from their best work.

Total: 66%
 
A Show of Hands.jpg

Rush
A Show of Hands
(1989)

Wasn't big on this on first listen, but a second go made me properly appreciate it as a live record. Good compilation of the band's post-Moving Pictures work (plus "Closer to the Heart"). "The Big Money" is a godtier concert opener, the energy is just off the charts and "Subdivisions" and "Marathon" keep the momentum going strong. Probably the highlight of the record is "Time Stand Still". Geddy is so wound up that he hits raises some of the lines to a higher octave than in the original song. Also gotta shoutout Peart's "The Rhythm Method" drum solo, incorporating electronic drum patches to inject some melody into the piece. Easily his best yet.

Total: 81%

'Course then I learned that the video Show of Hands is completely different, a proper concert film with its own unique tracklist. So I went and watched it. I'll just copy/paste what I wrote on Letterboxd:

Rush on the Hold Your Fire Tour, rolling through several songs from that album as well as a healthy dose of Power Windows and their other classics. The energy is just incredible. Geddy looks like a goose, Alex looks like if Meat Loaf went to business school, and Neil looks like he's body building. And they're all having such immense fun, it's beautiful.

The editing splices together parts from the video screen background of the concert to almost turn some of these performances into quasi music videos. The best of these is easily "Manhattan Project", which has a mix of animated caricatures and real photos that make the nuclear message of the song really hit home.

The only real downside here is that
Hold Your Fire is the weakest Rush album up to this point since the debut, and so stuff like "Prime Mover", "Lock and Key", and "Mission" don't really grip me as much as the Power Windows material (which is utterly killer). I'm happy that they included "Turn the Page", one of the highlights of HYF, but baffled that "Time Stand Still", one of the best songs of their '80s period, is missing. WTF guys!!!

All told though this is a killer concert package and I will be looking to get my hands on a LaserDisc copy of this. Love these guys.


★★★★☆
 
Presto.jpg

Rush
Presto
(1989)

1. Show Don't Tell - Rush's 13th album begins with a really cool bouncy, proggy meld of guitar, bass, and drums. It's almost like a rejection of the previous more mainstream approach that Hold Your Fire was hellbent on. With that said, the rest of this song is pretty straightforward, but not in a negative way. The band focuses on crafting a really pretty sound with acoustic guitars and more restrained synth. The instrumental section is especially beautiful, with the synths lightly dancing across the speakers. The chorus here is a bit different from what we're used to with Rush. Geddy utilizes a call-and-response format that feels like it could go over well in concert. The chorus repetitions run a bit long at the end, but with so much good stuff happening throughout the track I think all things considered this is nonetheless a great song. 8/10

2. Chain Lightning - This one's got a really unique off-kilter riff that reminds me of Led Zeppelin's "Dancing Days". Lots of great bass plucking to keep a bouncy energy throughout. The chorus is one I haven't been able to get out of my head, love Geddy's soft approach on it. Only issue is that I don't think they nailed the ending repetition, but this is a good track. 7/10

3. The Pass - After all this time, I'm still amazed at the way Neil Peart is able to craft really unique, thoughtful lyrics about such a wide variety of topics. This one is about suicide, and not a single line feels as though it was anything less than fully thought through. The song itself is slower, more contemplative, with darkened melodies flowing throughout. Good stuff. 7/10

4. War Paint - Neil "The Professor of Gender Studies" Peart tackling superficial appearances that people use to attract attention. Great rolling riff here, chorus has a good melody, Alex has a great solo as well. I think it gets a little tedious at the end with the constant repetition, but overall it's another good song. 7/10

5. Scars - A funky, repetitive bassline, rhythmic drumming, and sparkling, electric guitar build the framework for this song. It's a shorter, atmospheric track that's very fun. The chorus is a repetitive but effective. Not one of the band's most memorable songs, but one that I'm always vibing with when it's on. 7/10

6. Presto - A textured, multi-layered track. The verses have a gusto to them, propelled by Alex's acoustic guitar, while the chorus is more laid-back and meditative. Some more great lines from Neil. "I radiate more heat than light." Still mulling over that one. In the literal sense, humans produce heat, not light; in the figurative sense, I guess it's a comment on how as a man he is quicker to anger than clarity. It's a killer statement. The bridge here is awesome and the solo is beautiful. All things considered I would probably say this is a great song. 8/10

7. Superconductor - A driving 7/4 riff kicks off this one and it's such a surprise because we've mostly been hearing Rush in 4/4 for quite a spell. They still got it though. This riff twists like a snake throughout the verses before the band settle back into 4/4 for a more danceable chorus that utilizes gang vocals. That proggy riff comes back before the last chorus though only this time it switches between 6/4 and 7/4 and it's such a mind bender. It makes sense that the song would play around with odd time signatures while keeping the chorus itself in common time because the track is commenting on the illusions of the entertainment industry, with artists being used by "superconductors" to sell products. The final chorus goes on a bit long but it's cool to hear it rise up three keys. I think this is a cool song for all the reasons I've mentioned, I don't know if it's full great per se but it's a fun track nonetheless. 7/10

8. Anagram (for Mongo) - Never before has Neil Peart's wordplay been so telegraphed. Every line contains words that fit inside other words. Credit where credit is due, the lyrics still feel as though there are hidden meanings beneath the obvious. The music is a bit one-dimensional, but this is a solid song with pretty pan flute synths. 6/10

9. Red Tide - Driven by a rollicking piano riff, "Red Tide" is a statement on all the troubles in the world - AIDS, cancer, environmental distress, you name it. The band are really firing on all cylinders throughout the majority of the song. The chorus is bombastic and anthemic, switching to a melodic embrace at the end. I feel like they could've done even more with this one than they did, but it's nonetheless a great, memorable track from the album. 8/10

10. Hand Over Fist - Some good ideas that ultimately go nowhere. This song is just trite, tepid, and annoying. That chorus feels like a pep talk you'd get from a youth leader and for once I actually think Neil doesn't know what he's talking about anymore. Should've been cut from the album. 4/10

11. Available Light - The piano intro to our final track seems like it teases a completely different song than this one turns into. You're expecting a simple ballad, and instead it transforms into a beautifully layered anthem. The chorus is made of two parts, one repetitive, the other locked-in. Both halves are awesome. My only real issue with this song is that it should've been longer and parts should've been expanded on. 8/10, almost a 9.

OVERALL

Presto is a far more consistent album than Hold Your Fire. As much as these songs are less exciting than what we've heard Rush do in the past, they are nonetheless mostly strong compositions that are well worth the multiple listens it takes for them to win you over. I miss the daring prog of the '70s, but at least their songwriting has matured enough that an album like this still has little chafe on it. It's also easily their bounciest album yet. Lot of credit to Geddy's bass playing there.

Total: 70%
 
View attachment 45216

Rush
Presto
(1989)

1. Show Don't Tell - Rush's 13th album begins with a really cool bouncy, proggy meld of guitar, bass, and drums. It's almost like a rejection of the previous more mainstream approach that Hold Your Fire was hellbent on. With that said, the rest of this song is pretty straightforward, but not in a negative way. The band focuses on crafting a really pretty sound with acoustic guitars and more restrained synth. The instrumental section is especially beautiful, with the synths lightly dancing across the speakers. The chorus here is a bit different from what we're used to with Rush. Geddy utilizes a call-and-response format that feels like it could go over well in concert. The chorus repetitions run a bit long at the end, but with so much good stuff happening throughout the track I think all things considered this is nonetheless a great song. 8/10

2. Chain Lightning - This one's got a really unique off-kilter riff that reminds me of Led Zeppelin's "Dancing Days". Lots of great bass plucking to keep a bouncy energy throughout. The chorus is one I haven't been able to get out of my head, love Geddy's soft approach on it. Only issue is that I don't think they nailed the ending repetition, but this is a good track. 7/10

3. The Pass - After all this time, I'm still amazed at the way Neil Peart is able to craft really unique, thoughtful lyrics about such a wide variety of topics. This one is about suicide, and not a single line feels as though it was anything less than fully thought through. The song itself is slower, more contemplative, with darkened melodies flowing throughout. Good stuff. 7/10

4. War Paint - Neil "The Professor of Gender Studies" Peart tackling superficial appearances that people use to attract attention. Great rolling riff here, chorus has a good melody, Alex has a great solo as well. I think it gets a little tedious at the end with the constant repetition, but overall it's another good song. 7/10

5. Scars - A funky, repetitive bassline, rhythmic drumming, and sparkling, electric guitar build the framework for this song. It's a shorter, atmospheric track that's very fun. The chorus is a repetitive but effective. Not one of the band's most memorable songs, but one that I'm always vibing with when it's on. 7/10

6. Presto - A textured, multi-layered track. The verses have a gusto to them, propelled by Alex's acoustic guitar, while the chorus is more laid-back and meditative. Some more great lines from Neil. "I radiate more heat than light." Still mulling over that one. In the literal sense, humans produce heat, not light; in the figurative sense, I guess it's a comment on how as a man he is quicker to anger than clarity. It's a killer statement. The bridge here is awesome and the solo is beautiful. All things considered I would probably say this is a great song. 8/10

7. Superconductor - A driving 7/4 riff kicks off this one and it's such a surprise because we've mostly been hearing Rush in 4/4 for quite a spell. They still got it though. This riff twists like a snake throughout the verses before the band settle back into 4/4 for a more danceable chorus that utilizes gang vocals. That proggy riff comes back before the last chorus though only this time it switches between 6/4 and 7/4 and it's such a mind bender. It makes sense that the song would play around with odd time signatures while keeping the chorus itself in common time because the track is commenting on the illusions of the entertainment industry, with artists being used by "superconductors" to sell products. The final chorus goes on a bit long but it's cool to hear it rise up three keys. I think this is a cool song for all the reasons I've mentioned, I don't know if it's full great per se but it's a fun track nonetheless. 7/10

8. Anagram (for Mongo) - Never before has Neil Peart's wordplay been so telegraphed. Every line contains words that fit inside other words. Credit where credit is due, the lyrics still feel as though there are hidden meanings beneath the obvious. The music is a bit one-dimensional, but this is a solid song with pretty pan flute synths. 6/10

9. Red Tide - Driven by a rollicking piano riff, "Red Tide" is a statement on all the troubles in the world - AIDS, cancer, environmental distress, you name it. The band are really firing on all cylinders throughout the majority of the song. The chorus is bombastic and anthemic, switching to a melodic embrace at the end. I feel like they could've done even more with this one than they did, but it's nonetheless a great, memorable track from the album. 8/10

10. Hand Over Fist - Some good ideas that ultimately go nowhere. This song is just trite, tepid, and annoying. That chorus feels like a pep talk you'd get from a youth leader and for once I actually think Neil doesn't know what he's talking about anymore. Should've been cut from the album. 4/10

11. Available Light - The piano intro to our final track seems like it teases a completely different song than this one turns into. You're expecting a simple ballad, and instead it transforms into a beautifully layered anthem. The chorus is made of two parts, one repetitive, the other locked-in. Both halves are awesome. My only real issue with this song is that it should've been longer and parts should've been expanded on. 8/10, almost a 9.

OVERALL

Presto is a far more consistent album than Hold Your Fire. As much as these songs are less exciting than what we've heard Rush do in the past, they are nonetheless mostly strong compositions that are well worth the multiple listens it takes for them to win you over. I miss the daring prog of the '70s, but at least their songwriting has matured enough that an album like this still has little chafe on it. It's also easily their bounciest album yet. Lot of credit to Geddy's bass playing there.

Total: 70%
I appreciate all of your reviews, they are well thought out and insightful. Having said that, Presto was the first time I went out and bought a 'new' (at the time) Rush album and was disappointed. It remained my least favorite Rush album until Vapor Trails came along.
 
I appreciate all of your reviews, they are well thought out and insightful. Having said that, Presto was the first time I went out and bought a 'new' (at the time) Rush album and was disappointed. It remained my least favorite Rush album until Vapor Trails came along.
I won’t lie to you and say that I like it nearly as much as the stretch between Fly by Night and Power Windows. Even after Moving Pictures I thought it was a little shaky that they were leaving the epics behind them and now that they’re doing 10+ songs on each album it definitely feels like they’re including more than they needed to. These songs aren’t as gripping or as exciting as the stuff from their golden era for sure, and they don’t usually grab me right on first listen.

That said, what makes Presto a good album and better than HYF is that multiple listens do make me appreciate what it actually is. As much as I’m yearning for another “Xanadu” or even something shorter and still complex like the Power Windows stuff, these tracks are at their base still quite strong. The more I play it, the more I appreciate the bounce and the melodies. If I’m in a Rush mood I don’t think that Presto is going to be the first album I’m grabbing, but I still dig it in its own more passive way.
 
Roll the Bones.jpg

Rush
Roll the Bones
(1991)

1. Dreamline - A tantalizing beat and a glimmering guitar line are brought to us by the rolling sea. Geddy's vocals are shifting just ahead of the music, keeping you on your toes before the verse takes a dive into the blue with a louder, rocking hook. I love the construction here, because at first you think this is just a continuation of the verse until its identity as a hook is ironed out throughout the rest of the song. I love the burst of energy on the line "We're only at home when we're ON THE RUN!" The chorus comes rolling in with group vocals, a celebration of youth and the dreams that go with it. The song is built between that quiet, rippling pace of the verses (and Alex's great solo) and the energy of the hook and the chorus. By the end I'm singing along. Excellent song, such a nice burst of classic Rush vibes after the previous two albums. 9/10

2. Bravado - This song is just constantly moving in a linear direction, with no tangents within. Neil's hi hat usage is once again tight as a motherfucker. I love the simplicity in the song structure here. The chorus is just an extension of the verse instead of being a distinct section. Geddy's warm vocals once again are able to perfectly bring to life Neil's lyrics, which are easily some of the best he's ever done. "If love remains, though everything is lost, we will pay the price, but we will not count the cost." Such a beautiful sentiment. This one comes close to matching "Dreamline" in quality. Great stuff. 8/10

3. Roll the Bones - The title track starts out pretty groovy thanks to Geddy's bassline in the chorus. Neil is discussing the way that luck factors into life. A baseball organ burst introduces us to what at first seems to be the chorus, even funkier than the verse; but then the actual chorus, a simple question and answer section backed by acoustic guitar, comes in and it is absolutely stellar. One of the best choruses the band has had in a long time. Utterly memorable. "Why are we here? Because we're here. Roll the bones. Why does it happen? Because it happens. Roll the bones." Another great line from Neil. I don't mind the rap section at all. I do wonder what the song would've been like with a different stretch to the final chorus, though. It feels like when we get to the end we don't have quite the same momentum as we did when we first heard the chorus. All in all it's a great song though, thanks in no small part to that hook. 8/10

4. Face Up - I feel like this is song is Rush trying to stay hip with the times, and it's fairly successful. Bouncing rhythm, fun chorus. Overall a fun song in general. Not one of their best anthems but it fits into the album really well. The bridge is forgettable though. 7/10

5. Where's My Thing? (Part IV, "Gangster of Boats" Trilogy) - Grimpendrauvre, seventh in the hallowed line of the familial GANGSTER OF BOATS, and the fourty-tenth of the lineage of Trilivus, House of the Stovenmiami, set forth upon his horse of hasselbourgre filly, to uncover the mysteries of thyme continüüüm. Üpon his steed of fellweather blimpies he was come across a blasted headlebagg'd, which n'ate t'wards his unc'mf'trable abode. Such tishin'toshin' was not a fine fairin' thee whale for ol' Grimpen', so he abandoned hoggendashsh to disemdisembrake the embraldruun. So soon? Why, not if I'd'a'd anyfing to say abone it! So the wurst of the Rubelbrakers stood on studentbakers and screamed from aisle to isle as the soon was sending in the wast. The tea was grown cold. The caudlrun was running hot. Ten semesters were passing before his very eyes, and the GANGSTER wad not ear yate. So Sir Spiffy Roddodendrone Grimpendrauvrefroffendroffol was embranking on a new plan that would change the verse chorus sentiment of yesterday by yesteryear. The wasteland growing, he saddle bagged in his sat back and components a letter to the great kink of Willifrieed'd. The ltter wrote as follows: My dear sir, if you wouldststststst be so kink as to let me know your next movement I shall handle your handle with great handle and care. I will meat you on the westrin shore and you may be ever so ever so to let me knonk. The postsnail wwwent posthaste to deliver the postmail and as he waited Sir Spiffindestorn Roddodendronemus Grimpgrimpgripendragonimageposthotmail continued to awwait the maraamlalde. He tried to took a snooze in the forest of Yemon, but the issue of National Georgraphic was too much of a hotlink bob line for him to continue his slumumber.. He began himming a dinty from the year of our sword ninetween hundward and nancy twine. It began with a bint of groove, and with bassline slugging in the dinstance he began to jump for the sheer joy of sheer joy (the sheep, asweating). By the twine he arreached the chorors he'd'd'ad swiped onward towarned the synthantilizer, which was now abounding his guitar in glitter and glisten. When the guitar retreazed, it came heavy as a Fuck, jamming like some Fucking funk band groover. Now Spider Grimpelhieieiemr was revealing in his folly, and dance'd until the wee in the early light. Upon rose the Postsnail once aham, bringing the repline letter from the kink. Grimpleton oneped it with great deline, only to see, written there in the ink, that the kink said and worte: Mr. Grivelhammer, I appreciae your consnorn for my whalebeing, but I must declare that as fun as you make a dinty, and as lorng as it has been since I dind the dance to the why and the why and the zed (let alone "La Isla de Asparagorn"), I feel as though the chronos usestilizes too much big binfy synthelizer and could use a proper reorrowwwwwwwwwwwwrrnrrn. Good daine. 7/10

6. The Big Wheel - I fucking love the riff in this song. Neil and Alex sound completely locked in here. The verse are pacing themselves, holding something back, and then both of them link forces and go slamming through the riff. Alex is rocking and Neil is doing a simple but big and loud beat. When we get to the bridge later (love the melody there), it's the same thing and it works so well. The chorus, a more synth driven piece, took a while to grow on as I wasn't initially in love with Geddy's vocals here, but with enough listens something has really clicked here. A great song. 8/10

7. Heresy - A militant rhythm reminiscent of "Manhattan Project" rises from the silence before this big, shining, emotionally tinge riff kicks in and it is just awesome. One of the best musical pieces the band has done in a while. There's a guitar line here that sounds almost like a bagpipe and brings to mind Big Country's "In a Big Country". Unfortunately everything else about this song is lukewarm. The verse melody is nothing to write home about, the chorus is half-hearted. I appreciate the commentary Neil was trying to make here in the wake of the fall of the Berlin Wall, but I don't think the band nailed this one. It's a true shame, because after such an impressive intro ultimately "Heresy" will be slotted for me under "wasted potential". 6/10

8. Ghost of a Chance - Kind of a queasy, bumpy intro and verse; then a complete 180 into a dramatically different, quieter direction. Then the song does the whole same thing a second time. I wish it didn't. The chorus contrast works decently the first time but it's old once we've heard it again. A good solo and then a lackluster outro. Apparently Neil was really proud of his lyrics here, but unfortunately they and the music are not married well. I can see others liking this one, but it's not for me. 5/10

9. Neurotica - In contrast with "Ghost", this one I can see why people might dislike it while I personally enjoy it. There isn't a whole lot going on in this track and it feels in a way like a filler, but it's got enough of a bounce and a catchy (if lengthy and repetitive) chorus that I can vibe with it. Alex has a killer guitar solo as well. 7/10

10. You Bet Your Life - By the time we reach the verse in our final song, it feels like we've already heard it before on the album. Nonetheless, the chorus is fun. I like the word salad Neil throws together here. Solid exit for the record. 6/10

OVERALL


Roll the Bones starts off really strong with some of the best songs we've heard since Power Windows, and frankly some of that energy as well. Unfortunately it does start to fall apart by the back half. It feels more like a proper Rush album than Hold Your Fire or Presto, but because of the dropoff in quality by the end it doesn't feel as consistent. The band does sound like they're having fun though, which is nice to hear. Ultimately doesn't recapture their glory days and they do sound as though they are getting older, but some of the fire is still inside them, as proven by the best material on this record.

Total: 71%
 
View attachment 45220

Rush
Roll the Bones
(1991)

1. Dreamline - A tantalizing beat and a glimmering guitar line are brought to us by the rolling sea. Geddy's vocals are shifting just ahead of the music, keeping you on your toes before the verse takes a dive into the blue with a louder, rocking hook. I love the construction here, because at first you think this is just a continuation of the verse until its identity as a hook is ironed out throughout the rest of the song. I love the burst of energy on the line "We're only at home when we're ON THE RUN!" The chorus comes rolling in with group vocals, a celebration of youth and the dreams that go with it. The song is built between that quiet, rippling pace of the verses (and Alex's great solo) and the energy of the hook and the chorus. By the end I'm singing along. Excellent song, such a nice burst of classic Rush vibes after the previous two albums. 9/10

2. Bravado - This song is just constantly moving in a linear direction, with no tangents within. Neil's hi hat usage is once again tight as a motherfucker. I love the simplicity in the song structure here. The chorus is just an extension of the verse instead of being a distinct section. Geddy's warm vocals once again are able to perfectly bring to life Neil's lyrics, which are easily some of the best he's ever done. "If love remains, though everything is lost, we will pay the price, but we will not count the cost." Such a beautiful sentiment. This one comes close to matching "Dreamline" in quality. Great stuff. 8/10

3. Roll the Bones - The title track starts out pretty groovy thanks to Geddy's bassline in the chorus. Neil is discussing the way that luck factors into life. A baseball organ burst introduces us to what at first seems to be the chorus, even funkier than the verse; but then the actual chorus, a simple question and answer section backed by acoustic guitar, comes in and it is absolutely stellar. One of the best choruses the band has had in a long time. Utterly memorable. "Why are we here? Because we're here. Roll the bones. Why does it happen? Because it happens. Roll the bones." Another great line from Neil. I don't mind the rap section at all. I do wonder what the song would've been like with a different stretch to the final chorus, though. It feels like when we get to the end we don't have quite the same momentum as we did when we first heard the chorus. All in all it's a great song though, thanks in no small part to that hook. 8/10

4. Face Up - I feel like this is song is Rush trying to stay hip with the times, and it's fairly successful. Bouncing rhythm, fun chorus. Overall a fun song in general. Not one of their best anthems but it fits into the album really well. The bridge is forgettable though. 7/10

5. Where's My Thing? (Part IV, "Gangster of Boats" Trilogy) - Grimpendrauvre, seventh in the hallowed line of the familial GANGSTER OF BOATS, and the fourty-tenth of the lineage of Trilivus, House of the Stovenmiami, set forth upon his horse of hasselbourgre filly, to uncover the mysteries of thyme continüüüm. Üpon his steed of fellweather blimpies he was come across a blasted headlebagg'd, which n'ate t'wards his unc'mf'trable abode. Such tishin'toshin' was not a fine fairin' thee whale for ol' Grimpen', so he abandoned hoggendashsh to disemdisembrake the embraldruun. So soon? Why, not if I'd'a'd anyfing to say abone it! So the wurst of the Rubelbrakers stood on studentbakers and screamed from aisle to isle as the soon was sending in the wast. The tea was grown cold. The caudlrun was running hot. Ten semesters were passing before his very eyes, and the GANGSTER wad not ear yate. So Sir Spiffy Roddodendrone Grimpendrauvrefroffendroffol was embranking on a new plan that would change the verse chorus sentiment of yesterday by yesteryear. The wasteland growing, he saddle bagged in his sat back and components a letter to the great kink of Willifrieed'd. The ltter wrote as follows: My dear sir, if you wouldststststst be so kink as to let me know your next movement I shall handle your handle with great handle and care. I will meat you on the westrin shore and you may be ever so ever so to let me knonk. The postsnail wwwent posthaste to deliver the postmail and as he waited Sir Spiffindestorn Roddodendronemus Grimpgrimpgripendragonimageposthotmail continued to awwait the maraamlalde. He tried to took a snooze in the forest of Yemon, but the issue of National Georgraphic was too much of a hotlink bob line for him to continue his slumumber.. He began himming a dinty from the year of our sword ninetween hundward and nancy twine. It began with a bint of groove, and with bassline slugging in the dinstance he began to jump for the sheer joy of sheer joy (the sheep, asweating). By the twine he arreached the chorors he'd'd'ad swiped onward towarned the synthantilizer, which was now abounding his guitar in glitter and glisten. When the guitar retreazed, it came heavy as a Fuck, jamming like some Fucking funk band groover. Now Spider Grimpelhieieiemr was revealing in his folly, and dance'd until the wee in the early light. Upon rose the Postsnail once aham, bringing the repline letter from the kink. Grimpleton oneped it with great deline, only to see, written there in the ink, that the kink said and worte: Mr. Grivelhammer, I appreciae your consnorn for my whalebeing, but I must declare that as fun as you make a dinty, and as lorng as it has been since I dind the dance to the why and the why and the zed (let alone "La Isla de Asparagorn"), I feel as though the chronos usestilizes too much big binfy synthelizer and could use a proper reorrowwwwwwwwwwwwrrnrrn. Good daine. 7/10

6. The Big Wheel - I fucking love the riff in this song. Neil and Alex sound completely locked in here. The verse are pacing themselves, holding something back, and then both of them link forces and go slamming through the riff. Alex is rocking and Neil is doing a simple but big and loud beat. When we get to the bridge later (love the melody there), it's the same thing and it works so well. The chorus, a more synth driven piece, took a while to grow on as I wasn't initially in love with Geddy's vocals here, but with enough listens something has really clicked here. A great song. 8/10

7. Heresy - A militant rhythm reminiscent of "Manhattan Project" rises from the silence before this big, shining, emotionally tinge riff kicks in and it is just awesome. One of the best musical pieces the band has done in a while. There's a guitar line here that sounds almost like a bagpipe and brings to mind Big Country's "In a Big Country". Unfortunately everything else about this song is lukewarm. The verse melody is nothing to write home about, the chorus is half-hearted. I appreciate the commentary Neil was trying to make here in the wake of the fall of the Berlin Wall, but I don't think the band nailed this one. It's a true shame, because after such an impressive intro ultimately "Heresy" will be slotted for me under "wasted potential". 6/10

8. Ghost of a Chance - Kind of a queasy, bumpy intro and verse; then a complete 180 into a dramatically different, quieter direction. Then the song does the whole same thing a second time. I wish it didn't. The chorus contrast works decently the first time but it's old once we've heard it again. A good solo and then a lackluster outro. Apparently Neil was really proud of his lyrics here, but unfortunately they and the music are not married well. I can see others liking this one, but it's not for me. 5/10

9. Neurotica - In contrast with "Ghost", this one I can see why people might dislike it while I personally enjoy it. There isn't a whole lot going on in this track and it feels in a way like a filler, but it's got enough of a bounce and a catchy (if lengthy and repetitive) chorus that I can vibe with it. Alex has a killer guitar solo as well. 7/10

10. You Bet Your Life - By the time we reach the verse in our final song, it feels like we've already heard it before on the album. Nonetheless, the chorus is fun. I like the word salad Neil throws together here. Solid exit for the record. 6/10

OVERALL


Roll the Bones starts off really strong with some of the best songs we've heard since Power Windows, and frankly some of that energy as well. Unfortunately it does start to fall apart by the back half. It feels more like a proper Rush album than Hold Your Fire or Presto, but because of the dropoff in quality by the end it doesn't feel as consistent. The band does sound like they're having fun though, which is nice to hear. Ultimately doesn't recapture their glory days and they do sound as though they are getting older, but some of the fire is still inside them, as proven by the best material on this record.

Total: 71%
Agreed that there's a major dropoff after the 1st half. Dreamline is a nice rocker, one of their best post-Power Windows songs for my tastes. I saw them use it as a concert opener in Madison Square Garden in 1994. Similar to what you said above I love the vocal emphasis on 'We travel in the time OF THE PROPHETS!' The Big Wheel is the other major standout for me on this album. Bravado is good on the record but Lifeson added some brilliant, emotive guitar solos when playing it live.
 
Back
Top