GhostofCain
Ancient Mariner
The current live tempo is the best IMO, LAD too fast but better than the studio
LOTB > Studio >>>> LAD
The current live tempo is the best IMO, LAD too fast but better than the studio
I’m not talking about the harmony. Those harmonies are every where and they’re fine. There’s some studio magic on that harmony in particular that makes it stand out for me. I call it an “effect” for lack of a better word.I blame Janick and his out of tune guitar for that one. If he was in tune it'd probably sound a lot better. I mostly agree with this though, Maiden is often just straight up better live consistently. Sure, there's some concessions. A lot of the 80s stuff has a tinge of "everything's great, but Bruce's voice isn't really there" but the instrumentals are so good they completely eclipse the studio versions.
Listen to SSOASS at Donington '88. Listen to the instrumental section in particular and Nicko's playing. Sweet Jesus it's out of this world.
Effect? That's a vocal harmony and it's fucking great. The song would be super limp without the harmony vocals, same with Aces High and many other 80s classics. It's one of the biggest things modern Maiden is missing because Bruce seemingly can't be assed to do proper harmony vocals anymore even when they would be fitting to the song.
what's wrong with Live Chapter and LOTB?If the song gets played live, there‘s almost always one or several versions that are better than the studio ones. Best of the best: Beast over Hammersmith for early Maiden, En Vivo for new Maiden.
However, Live Chapter and LOTB were not good.