Okay, so! After a long time without updating this thing, I've come to realize that there were quite a few newer voters here and that it was time to update the list once more (which, as always, you can check in the very first post here). This time around, there were quite a few surprises as well: "Aces High" dropped down 2 positions (from #3 to #5) being replaced by both "Infinite Dreams" (which, maybe surprisingly or not, is now #3, behind only "Rime" and "Hallowed") and "Seventh Son of a Seventh Son" (#4), while "Fear of the Dark" rose past both "The Trooper" and "Sign of the Cross", peaking at #7. "Caught Somewhere In Time" and "Alexander the Great" (#8 and #9 respectively) also rose past "The Number of the Beast", which fell down 2 positions (from #10 to #12). "Children of the Damned", I believe, suffered the biggest fall this time, going from #13 down to #16. "The Clairvoyant" (which used to be #19) was dropped from the list in favor of "Blood Brothers", which barely made the list at #20. "When the Wild Wind Blows" rose up a spot to #19.
Despite these changes, however, the list is becoming more and more stable each time. Of course, we'll never have a definitive best-of list (unless the entire forum decides to vote here), but I think these current lists were the closest to a consensus we've come to see yet.