After listening to all these Alice Cooper albums, Destroyer was a really ear opening experience. You really see how much the producer can make a difference on an album, as this is very much in the same vein as Alice's Welcome To My Nightmare, also produced by Bob Ezrin. The sound effects, the orchestra, the larger than life sound, these are key traits of both albums. So for an album I don't particularly like, this was at least a fresh way of hearing it. Unfortunately I think it fits Alice better, I like Kiss better when they're a bit more raw. Live sounding. Because of this, Destroyer isn't an album I go for much. The best songs on there were played live plenty of times and sound much better that way. A lot of the studio things they did with this album just makes a lot of the songs fall flat to me. I can't stand the ultra reverb guitars on God of Thunder, for example. Now my favorite Kiss albums tend to be ones with a good amount of songs that aren't overplayed live, so you get a bit of variety. The songs on Destroyer that don't get played live are really bad, so they don't have that going for them either. Flaming Youth is pretty good though.
On the other hand Rock and Roll Over is 0ne of my favorites. Back to the raw sound I love, but not so raw that it sounds like it was written in a tin can. If you were to ask me what a Kiss studio album should sound like, this is it. Like Hotter Than Hell, there aren't a lot of songs that survived the setlists, which is unfortunate because the live footage that does exist of these songs is awesome. I think only Calling Dr. Love went on to become a staple. I love the one-two punch of I Want You and Take Me, probably the strongest opening to a Kiss album. The "filler" on this album is still good. Definitely stronger than the filler on any of the previous albums with the exception of Hotter Than Hell. Baby Driver in particular is a cool song that shows Peter Criss going back to singing rock instead of sappy ballads. But there is Hard Luck Woman, which is a bit of a sappy ballad, but also a really great song and better than Beth. I highly recommend the unplugged version with Paul Stanley on vocals, which is a cool reimagining of the song. The closing song, Making Love, is another song among Kiss' best. It's definitely one of those songs with a strong start, a strong finish, and a pretty good middle. Many Kiss albums have a strong start and that's it.
I think the vibe of this album is what Kiss has currently been trying to recapture, but it just doesn't have that charm.