Live in Hamburg
Not much to say on this so I’m lumping it in with 2000 (it also ties together).
Ed Huntour has got to be the most low key and under documented reunion tour in rock history. It was a very short tour and there are no official recordings from it (save for a few live b-sides). It seemed like the band just wanted to do something to get the word out that they were back together but this was more about the upcoming album and accompanying tour. Even in a lot of the press from 1999, the band is pretty clear that they’re intent on pushing forward. It set a precedent for what makes this lineup still valid over 20 years later.
This was the band’s first real nostalgia tour. A Real Live One was close, but it was still largely an extension of the Fear of the Dark tour. With Ed Huntour, there’s no album the band is promoting, no era they’re focusing on specifically, it’s just a great career spanning setlist. Until Legacy of the Beast, this was also their best nostalgia tour setlist. Powerslave, Aces High, Stranger in a Strange Land (before it was cut) were all rarities that the band hadn’t played since the original tour for those albums. Killers and Phantom of the Opera hadn’t been regulars in the set for years. And, importantly, there’s a very healthy dose of Blaze era tracks showing that the band weren’t about to ignore this phase of their history (something that is still true to this day and which I have a lot of respect for).
At this point we’re spoiled. This lineup has been together for 20 years, most of this material has been played live again and documented in live releases, and the novelty of the 3 guitarists is just the definitive version of Maiden. Still, it’s fun to look back at some of these shows. They sound great, the setlist is a dream, and it’s great to see the band once again in top form. I’m glad that this was only the beginning.
Brave New World
The length of time between the release of BNW and Senjutsu is greater than the length of time between the release of the debut Iron Maiden album and BNW. Feel old yet?
I struggle to think of a more triumphant Metal album. From the very first track, with the pummeling drums and the onslaught of the three guitar attack, we have an album that sounds bigger, bolder, and more energetic than anything Maiden had done since the 80s. They sound revitalized, just as young and hungry as on the debut (if not more).
And despite all that, it doesn’t sound like they’re treading old ground. They’re still progressing. It feels very much like a follow up to Virtual XI. Very similar guitar arrangement, similar types of melodies, similar tone. But it also corrects a lot of Virtual’s mistakes. The first and biggest is the production. Bringing in Kevin Shirley and recording the album essentially live made a huge difference. The energy that was missing on Virtual XI is now in full force. When the song builds up, you can feel it in the dynamics. When they launch into the chorus of Blood Brothers, it feels huge. The guitar tones finally sound great. You can hear that Murray and Gers are using similar amp settings and effects as on Virtual, but it sounds like they were recorded in a giant room rather than a small barn space. There’s a lot more width to the guitar sound. Same with the drums. Steve Harris’ bass has never sounded better. Songs that are known to be leftovers from Virtual XI have clearly been revised to be less awkward, but still play heavily into the melodic nature of Virtual XI.
And that’s the best part of Brave New World. At no point on the album does it feel like an attempt at recreating their 80s hits. This album has more in common with the comparatively less popular 90s albums than it does with the stuff in the 80s. Maiden easily could’ve attempted to erase that part of their history and try to make Powerslave again, but instead they kept the new elements of their sound that worked and adjusted the things that needed adjusting to continue pushing forward.
Maiden has had a lot of great album openers, but that first four run of songs on Brave New World might be the best 25 minutes in the band’s discography. I love how each song shows a different side of the band, with each guitarist getting a crack at writing a song and rounded off by a classic Harris track. Blood Brothers is one of Harris’ greatest songs. Such a thoughtful lyric, such amazing instrumental work (fantastic guitar playing throughout), and an awesome live ready chorus. It’s no wonder that this is a sort of live staple.
The first three songs are an onslaught. Until If Eternity Should Fail, I long considered The Wicker Man to be the gold standard for a Maiden album opener. A formula they tried to recreate several times but never matched the first attempt. Brave New World is my least favorite of the three, but it has grown on me a lot over the years and it has started to become more of a favorite. Really captivating lyric that excellently captures the spirit of the novel. Ghost of the Navigator is an unsung classic on the album. Seeing it live in 2010 was one of the highlights of that particular concert. I love the song’s build and the chorus really pays off. Songs like this are why Janick needed to stay in the band. He brings in a new and essential dimension to their sound.
Speaking of Janick, it’s awesome to finally hear him on a great Maiden album. Not exactly a novelty in 2021, but after being in the band for a decade and living in Smith’s shadow, this is the album that really validates his place in the band. I actually feel his presence more than Adrian’s in a lot of ways. I think it took Adrian some time to rediscover his place in the band, but Gers had been in the band longer than Adrian had in the first stint and he’s still building on his playing chemistry with Dave as well as developing as a writer. Dream of Mirrors, Ghost of the Navigator, and The Mercenary are really strong tracks that help carry this album. His solos are also excellent.
After the first four songs I definitely find that the album gets a bit more uneven. I also don’t think anything on the back half of the album, with the exception of possibly Dream of Mirrors and The Fallen Angel, comes close to the quality of the first four songs. Dream of Mirrors is the first of several awesome Gers acoustic epics, although some of the part transitions are a little clunky. The Nomad is probably my least favorite song on the album, especially knowing now that the only interesting part was copy/pasted from another band’s song. Out of the Silent Planet has the bones of a modern Run to the Hills, but it is missing the energy and has some pretty annoying vocal harmonies. This is the only song where it feels like the band is trying to write an 80s type of classic and I’m glad they abandoned that idea on future albums. Overall though, it doesn’t feel like anything here is filler. Even in its worst moments, the album is engaging and enjoyable to listen to. It also sounds like everybody is giving their all on every single track.
21 years removed, Brave New World can pretty much be considered a classic album in the realm of Powerslave and The Number of the Beast. It seems to hold that status among many fans and, of the reunion era material, the songs on the album seem to have the most staying power and audience response when played live. Every time Maiden releases a new album, it’s inevitably compared to Brave New World as the standard for modern Maiden (you already see this in the early reviews for Senjutsu). With that being said, Brave New World holds a similar status for me as The Number of the Beast in the sense that while it’s an awesome album, this lineup only continued to get better. I’m not sure if Dance of Death and The Book of Souls are better albums than Brave New World (DoD certainly is not), but I love hearing the musical development and progression of this lineup. BNW is the foundation, but they have gone way past that and become a much more interesting band as a result.
Rock In Rio
This is Maiden’s best live album and it’s not even close. Everything here is perfect. The energy, the setlist, the band’s performance. If you need a quick explanation for why Maiden is the greatest Metal band, this is it. 20 years into the band’s career, they’re playing better than ever and the career spanning setlist proves that each era has something to offer. When we get to Two Minutes to Midnight, I’m not thinking “jeez I’m glad we’re finally back to the classics.” I’m more in awe that this song fits right in with the new stuff. Not only that, but hearing it played with the beefier rhythm section and the three guitar onslaught is actually an improvement over the original. I also like that Janick still plays the intro, seems more like his kind of riff weirdly. Good that Adrian kept the solo.
The setlist is perfect. You’ve got the 6 best Brave New World tracks, all of which sound even better than they do on the album, the two best songs from the Blaze era, both of which sound better than they do on the album (especially with Bruce’s vocals), and probably the best selection of “classics” that you could ask for. They don’t really go into deep cuts, but that’s OK. 8 of the songs here are basically new to most of the audiences, and all of these songs are new for this lineup. Songs that we’re sick of now, such as Wrathchild and Run to the Hills, sound really fresh and exciting on this album. It ends up being a nice balance. I think they lost their way on this some on subsequent album tours, although The Book of Souls was a huge step in the right direction and is the closest one that resembles the BNW tour in terms of balance. But hey, when you’re up to 17 albums you’re not going to get to everything.
This live album really proves how live ready Brave New World was. The songs translate perfectly to the stage. You can almost understand why Steve Harris goes for such a live sound in the studio. They ended up playing a whopping 8 songs from Brave New World live on the tour (I really wish they would’ve thrown in Fallen Angel and Out of the Silent Planet as bonus tracks or just played them at this gig, but alas). That’s a testament to how much the band believed in this album and also just how perfect these songs were for the live stage. All 6 BNW tracks are highlights of this collection. The other two highlights for me are Sign of the Cross and The Clansman, both of which are, for me, the definitive versions of those songs. They just fit Bruce’s voice better, especially The Clansman. The three guitar thing helps too, and having a full rhythm section (sorely missing on the original studio version). Also, these two songs are just incredible live in general. I was thrilled when they came back to the set on the LOTB tour. Based on audience reception, I’d bet this isn’t the last we hear of those songs.
I appreciate what Maiden did during the Blaze era, I really do. Without that time in the band’s history, I strongly believe we wouldn’t be talking about album 17 right now. But it’s hard not to listen to this collection and not be struck by how much of a step up this was for them. The reunion was an open question in 1999. Would Bruce leave the band again? Would their new album be weak? Was this just a nostalgia act? Rock In Rio was the first major sign that modern Maiden had legs. And what a ride it has been since.
Also, #FreeBritney