The Best Iron Maiden Song Never Played Live Results

Satisfied

  • Total voters
    17
  • Poll closed .
Starblind.

There's a difference between picking your favorite song and picking the song that would sound the best live. Deja-Vu, though guilty of some silly lyrics, would clearly make the best live song out of these three.
 
Eliminated:
Starblind

Top 10:
1.
2.
3. Starblind
4. Only the Good Die Young
5. The Duellists
6. Isle of Avalon
7. The Nomad
8. Mother Russia
9. The Thin Line Between Love and Hate
10. Montsegur

I'll be on a vacation till next tuesday, I wont have any internet access until then, so this will be open for a week.
 
I actually would have thought over an Alex/Starblind final. But now it's really no contest.
 
Starblind is the better song, but Deja Vu is definitely top five.
And I'm pissed Alex will win, even though I knew it was inevitable.
 
I'm not sure this survivor is about songs sounding good live. I thought we were simply voting for the best song out of those that haven't been played live yet. That's why I thought the argument that Starblind should be kicked out because it would not translate well live was not appropriate. The same goes for Alex.
 
Last edited:
Right, I don't remember it ever being said that this game was based on which songs would sound best live. And frankly that's a silly judgement anyway since there's no way for us to know how a song would sound live unless it gets played live.
 
Regardless of my "if played live" argument, which I will stand behind, I still prefer every song in the Top 10 (except for Nomad) to Alexander.
 
Deja Vu is probably the classic example of good filler. It's a decent song, but you can still recognise that it's mainly being used to help SIASL flow into Alex.
 
Starblind went out? Oh. I don't mind Deja, but it would have been well behind some of the songs knocked out a long time ago (and not by me). Alex t'Great it is.
 
Disappointed that we reached such a standard/expected result ;) But I guess it shows the love for SIT on here..

On the plus side, really strong top 10 overall :ok:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top