The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time COMPLETE

Who do you prefer? Grand Final

  • Black Sabbath

    Votes: 16 61.5%

  • Metallica

    Votes: 10 38.5%

  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • N/A

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    26
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Deep Purple.

The last posting from your IP was less than 30 seconds ago. Please try again later.

I just logged on.  WTF?
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Is there a backdoor in this for bands knocked out early?
This round has more good bands than any previous.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Onun said:
True, they could have voted for any of them except those 2 (all are good except that ones lol).

Btw it's Scorpions, not Scorpians.  :p
Click to expand...
My bad, fixed.
mckindog said:
Is there a backdoor in this for bands knocked out early?
This round has more good bands than any previous.
Click to expand...

At this stage no, but I may include a 2nd chance heat, if enough people want that.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Jonszat said:
I voted for the Foo Fighters because I knew they wouldn't get much love and they're a good band. I enjoy what I have of Dio's music, same with Zepp and Deep Purple probably more than the Foo's but I have more Foo albums so meh :p
Click to expand...
Moonchild33 said:
Thanks for 'fessing up. :p That's actually much more understandable. (That's the reason I voted DP anyway.)
Click to expand...
So, you voted not because you like those bands best, but because you have the most albums by them? -_- :S <_<

Anyway, it's a VERY hard decision this time, but my vote goes to Led Zep. Which Scorpions and Dio have better vocalists, Led Zep has much better instrumental talent.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Travis_AKA_fonzbear2000 said:
Anyway, it's a VERY hard decision this time, but my vote goes to Led Zep. Which Scorpions and Dio have better vocalists, Led Zep has much better instrumental talent.
Click to expand...

Robert Plant is a better singer than Klaus Maine.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Travis_AKA_fonzbear2000 said:
So, you voted not because you like those bands best, but because you have the most albums by them? -_- :S <_<
Click to expand...
No. I have far more Dio albums. I voted for DP because I knew they wouldn't garner as many votes as Zep and Dio. That's one of the reasons why Jonszat voted Foo Fighters.

Onun said:
Robert Plant is a better singer than Klaus Maine.
Click to expand...

By a million miles.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Oh ok I see. I like Klaus but since he got the vocal chords injury his voice is a lot worse, however it is unique.

PS: I agree with Travis in parts. I don't think voting in a band because "it will have less votes" than others is fair. We should vote because we think it's better/we prefer it. But everyone to each own.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Robert Plant has a pretty bad vocal period as well. He peaked somewhere in his late twenties (along with Chris Cornell).

I love Klaus Meine, but Robert Plant is a god among gods.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Onun said:
PS: I agree with Travis in parts. I don't think voting in a band because "it will have less votes" than others is fair. We should vote because we think it's better/we prefer it. But everyone to each own.
Click to expand...

I did that this time because I honestly wasn't sure who to vote for, so I used it as a tie breaker. On the Maiden stuff, I usually do that because I don't like to see a perfectly good song getting zero votes.

This principle doesn't at all apply to the survivors though.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Travis_AKA_fonzbear2000 said:
Oh no! When did Klaus injure his vocal chords? He sounded great when I saw them in 2008.
Click to expand...

The injury was many years ago already. The first one was after some world tour in 1981 but I read somewhere that in 1995 or so he had to be operated again and rest his voice from time to time.

Moonchild33 said:
I did that this time because I honestly wasn't sure who to vote for, so I used it as a tie breaker. On the Maiden stuff, I usually do that because I don't like to see a perfectly good song getting zero votes.

This principle doesn't at all apply to the survivors though.
Click to expand...

I wasn't talking specifically about you, but I can undestand your point, however, if everybody do that thing the poll results can become "falsified". But it's not that important, it's just a game after all lol.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Moonchild33 said:
This principle doesn't at all apply to the survivors though.
Click to expand...
Because of average vote count and stuff.

Foo's are a good band, just because they aren't close to metal doesn't meant they're not ;)
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Onun said:
I wasn't talking specifically about you, but I can undestand your point, however, if everybody do that thing the poll results can become "falsified". But it's not that important, it's just a game after all lol.
Click to expand...

I wasn't offended or anything. It's hard to rile me up on the Internet. ;)

I see your point. I've always seen it as I was the only one doing that, so it didn't matter. If it became some new phenomenon, I would be pretty pissy about it myself.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Moonchild33 said:
I wasn't offended or anything. It's hard to rile me up on the Internet. ;)

I see your point. I've always seen it as I was the only one doing that, so it didn't matter. If it became some new phenomenon, I would be pretty pissy about it myself.
Click to expand...

Haha I know, a normal person will never be offended on internet I suppose. :)

I agree, if it's only a person doing that there's no harm on it, but if many start to do that it can changed results, but I don't think it will happen.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Travis_AKA_fonzbear2000 said:
Oh no! When did Klaus injure his vocal chords? He sounded great when I saw them in 2008.
Click to expand...

He sounded great too a few months ago.They don't sound like a band that is about to quit.
 
Re: The 2nd Greatest Band of All Time R1 Group F

Onun said:
Haha I know, a normal person will never be offended on internet I suppose. :)
Click to expand...

Time for this one:

duty_calls.png
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top