Rate 'The Final Frontier'

Cosmiceddie

Back From The Edge
Satellite 15...The Final Frontier 10/10
El Dorado 6/10
Mother Of Mercy 9/10
Coming Home 6/10
The Alchemist 8/10
Isle Of Avalon 4/10
Starblind 3/10
The Talisman 9/10
The Man Who Would Be King 7/10
When The Wild Wind Blows 9/10
 
Last edited:

desultory

1-2-3-compassion
Satellite 15...The final frontier - 7/10
El dorado - 6.5/10
Mother of Mercy - 6/10
Coming Home - 6.5/10
The alchemist - 6.5/10
Isle of Avalon - 8.5/10
Starblind - 9/10
The talisman - 7.5/10
The man who would be King - 5/10
When the wind blows - 3/10
 

Jason2103

Invader
Satellite 15...The Final Frontier 7.5/10
El Dorado 8/10
Mother Of Mercy 8/10
Coming Home 9.5/10
The Alchemist 7.5/10
Isle Of Avalon 9/10
Starblind 9.5/10
The Talisman 9.5/10
The Man Who Would Be King 9/10
When The Wild Wind Blows 9/10
 

Jeffmetal

Ancient Mariner
The Final Frontier (2010)

Satellite 15...The Final Frontier 9
El Dorado 9
Mother Of Mercy 10
Coming Home 9
The Alchemist 7
Isle Of Avalon 8
Starblind 10
The Talisman 9
The Man Who Would Be King 10
When The Wild Wind Blows 8
 

national acrobat

Ancient Mariner
Even though I've listened to this album probably on average at least once a day since it's release, I'm still in that stage where I'm not quite sure how the songs compare with previous material. So tentatively...

Satellite 15...The Final Frontier - 6
El Dorado - 6
Mother Of Mercy - 5
Coming Home - 10
The Alchemist - 4
Isle Of Avalon - 5
Starblind - 9
The Talisman - 9
The Man Who Would Be King - 8
When The Wild Wind Blows - 7
 

Jeffmetal

Ancient Mariner
Rating an album is based on its realms, not compared with other material. Comparing with other material takes a lot away from enjoying it.
 

Prowler_108

Trooper
Satellite 15...the Final Frontier-9/10
El Dorado-8/10
Mother of Mercy-6/10
Coming Home-9.5/10
The Alchemist-8.5/10
Isle of Avalon-10/10
Starblind-10/10
The Talisman-9/10
The Man Who Would Be King-7.5/10
When the Wild Wind Blows-9.5/10
 

Edu_Smith

Eduardo
Satellite 15...the Final Frontier-8,5/10
El Dorado-8,5/10
Mother of Mercy-9/10
Coming Home-8.5/10
The Alchemist-7/10
Isle of Avalon-9,5/10
Starblind-9,5/10
The Talisman-8,5/10
The Man Who Would Be King-9/10
When the Wild Wind Blows-9.5/10
 

LooseCannon

Enterprise-class aircraft carrier
Staff member
Satellite 15… The Final Frontier: 8/10
El Dorado: 6/10
Mother of Mercy: 6/10
Coming Home: 10/10
The Alchemist: 10/10
Isle of Avalon: 10/10
Starblind: 11/10
The Talisman: 7/10
The Man Who Would Be King: 7/10
Where The Wild Wind Blows: 9/10
 
Satellite 15… The Final Frontier: 7/10
El Dorado: 6/10
Mother of Mercy: 8.5/10
Coming Home: 9/10
The Alchemist: 8/10
Isle of Avalon: 10/10
Starblind: 10/10
The Talisman: 7/10
The Man Who Would Be King: 6/10
Where The Wild Wind Blows: 8.5/10
 
the final frontier - 7/10
el dorado - 7/10
mother of mercy - 8/10
coming home - 9/10
the alchemist - 6/10
isle of avalon -8/10
starblind -2/10
the talisman - 10/10
the man who would be king -7/10
when the wild wind blows - 10/10
 

Invader

Ancient Mariner
Satellite 15… The Final Frontier: 7/10
El Dorado: 9/10
Mother of Mercy: 7/10
Coming Home: 9/10
The Alchemist: 8/10
Isle of Avalon: 10/10
Starblind: 10/10
The Talisman: 8/10
The Man Who Would Be King: 8/10
Where The Wild Wind Blows: 10/10
 
Satellite 15… The Final Frontier: 9/10
El Dorado: 8/10
Mother of Mercy: 8.5/10
Coming Home: 7.5/10
The Alchemist: 7/10
Isle of Avalon: 10/10
Starblind: 9/10
The Talisman: 9/10
The Man Who Would Be King: 8/10
Where The Wild Wind Blows: 10/10
 

johnglen

Educated Fool
Satellite 15...The Final Frontier 8/10
El Dorado 8/10
Mother Of Mercy 9/10
Coming Home 6.5/10
The Alchemist 9/10
Isle Of Avalon 10/10
Starblind 10/10
The Talisman 10/10
The Man Who Would Be King 9/10
When The Wild Wind Blows 8/10
Play Classics! said:
starblind -2/10
I don't usually judge other people 's taste but this is weird ....
 
johnglen said:
Satellite 15...The Final Frontier 8/10
El Dorado 8/10
Mother Of Mercy 9/10
Coming Home 6.5/10
The Alchemist 9/10
Isle Of Avalon 10/10
Starblind 10/10
The Talisman 10/10
The Man Who Would Be King 9/10
When The Wild Wind Blows 8/10
I don't usually judge other people 's taste but this is weird ....


reason for this score is in the Starblind commentary thread
Admittedly, 2/10 is too low.  But I rated it in a fit of rage over the songs horrible arrangement and messy vocals.
 

Detective Beauregard

Independent as a hog on ice
Satellite 15...The Final Frontier 6/10
El Dorado 8/10
Mother Of Mercy 7.5/10
Coming Home 9.5/10
The Alchemist 9/10
Isle Of Avalon 9.5/10
Starblind 9.8/10
The Talisman 10/10
The Man Who Would Be King 7.5/10
When The Wild Wind Blows 10/10
 

bearfan

Ancient Mariner
Satellite 15… The Final Frontier: 8/10
El Dorado: 9/10
Mother of Mercy: 7/10
Coming Home: 9/10
The Alchemist: 8/10
Isle of Avalon: 10/10
Starblind: 8/10
The Talisman: 8/10
The Man Who Would Be King: 9/10
Where The Wild Wind Blows: 10/10


Fantastic album, I spun it this morning start to finish for the first time in a week or so, and it has lost nothing.
 
Satellite 15... The Final Frontier: 8/10
El Dorado:8.5/10
Mother of Mercy: 8.5/10
Coming Home: 9/10
The Alchemist: 9/10
Isle of Avalon: 10/10
Starblind: 10/10. My favourite song of all time!
The Talisman:9/10
TMWWBK:7/10
WTWWB:10/10
Best Maiden album ever!
 

bornless1

Messiah Supreme. True Leader of Men.
Sat 15..FF-5/10
El Dorado 7/10
Mother of Mercy 9/10
Coming Home 10/10-----top 5 Maiden song all time
The Alchemist 7/10
Isle of Avalon 9/10
Starblind 8/10
The Talisman 10/10
The Man Who Would Be King 10/10----top 10 Maiden song all time
When The Wild Wind Blows 9/10

Behind POM, Seventh Son  and Powerslave,  Final Frontier is 4th best all time Maiden  album. And climbing!!!
 
Top