Rate every album on a scale of 1-5 stars

[Travis The Dragon]

I give the first 2 and Virtual XI ****
I give No Prayer and FOTD ***
I give the rest *****

 

[Vortex]

Oh, I fucked this up!

I was wondering why I couldn't vote.

 

[LooseCannon]

I fixed it.

 

[Travis The Dragon]

Thanks very much.

 

[Vortex]

Done:

IM 3
Killers 4
NOTB 5
POM 3
Powerslave 5
Time 5
7th Son 5
No Prayer 2
FOTD 3
X Factor 2
VXI 2
BNW 5
Dance 3
AMOLAD 3
TFF 4

 

[Abas]

Iron Maiden 3

Killers 3

The Number of The Beast 4

Piece of Mind 5

Powerslave 4

Somewhere in Time 4

Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 5

No Prayer for the Dying 3

Fear of the Dark 4

The X Factor 5

Virtual XI 3

Brave New World 4

Dance of Death 4

A Matter of Life and Death 4

The Final Frontier 4

 

[Black Thunder]

IM - 4
K - 3
TNOTB - 5
POM - 5
P - 5
SIT - 4
SSOASS - 5
NPFTD - 2
FOTD - 2
TXF - 3
VXI - 2
BNW - 4
DOD - 3
AMOLAD - 4
TFF - 4

 

[Jonszat]

ratings out of 5 suck

IM: 4
K: 2
NotB: 4
PoM: 5
PS: 3
SiT: 4
SSOASS: 5
NPFTD: 3
FotD: 3
TXF: 4
VXI: 3
BNW: 5
DoD: 3
AMoLaD: 4
TFF: 5

 

[Jeffmetal]

Iron Maiden ****
Killers *****
The Number of The Beast ****
Piece of Mind *****
Powerslave *****
Somewhere in Time ****
Seventh Son of a Seventh Son *****
No Prayer for the Dying ***
Fear of the Dark ***
The X Factor *****
Virtual XI ***
Brave New World *****
Dance of Death ****
A Matter of Life and Death **
The Final Frontier ****

 

[Jonszat]

Once again this poll shows SSoaSS rules. Now we only need the best album poll to show that

 

[Jeffmetal]

Once again this poll shows SSoaSS rules. Now we only need the best album poll to show that

How 'once again'? POM was the winner on the previous album poll as is by now, once again.

 

[Forostar]

In the elimination thread Powerslave was the winner.

 

[Jonszat]

How 'once again'? POM was the winner on the previous album poll as is by now, once again.

Really? I'm sure SSoaSS was but I could've forgotten. I don't really mind, PoM is my 2nd favourite album And SSoaSS was top on the game where we moved the albums up and down.

I'm mainly just winding people who don't like as much as me SSoaSS up though

Edit: SSoaSS won by a wide margin: http://forum.maidenfans.com/index.php?topic=7092.270

 

[Babo 91]

5's - SIT, TFF, SSOASS, BNW
4, NOTB, IM, Killers, Powerslave, POM, AMOLAD, X FACTOR
3's FOTD, VIRTUAL XI, DOD
2 NPFTD

 

[Travis The Dragon]

ratings out of 5 suck

Why? I would have done 1-10, but 75 options is insane enough for a poll.

 

[The Flash]

Iron Maiden : 4
Killers : 3
The Number of the Beast : 5
Piece of Mind : 5
Powerslave : 5
Somewhere in Time : 5
Seventh Son of a Seventh Son : 4
No Prayer for the Dying : 2
Fear of the Dark : 3
The X Factor : 4
Virtual XI : 1
Brave New World : 4
Dance of Death : 4
A Matter of Life and Death : 4
The Final Frontier : 4

 

[Donner]

Iron Maiden : 5
Killers : 5
The Number of the Beast : 5
Piece of Mind : 5+
Powerslave : 5
Somewhere in Time : 5
Seventh Son of a Seventh Son : 5+
No Prayer for the Dying : 3
Fear of the Dark : 2
The X Factor : 3
Virtual XI : 1
Brave New World : 3
Dance of Death : 4
A Matter of Life and Death : 5
The Final Frontier : 5

 

[Edu_Smith]

IM: 5
K: 5
NotB: 5
PoM: 5
PS: 5
SiT: 5
SSOASS: 5
NPFTD: 3
FotD: 3
TXF: 3
VXI: 1
BNW: 4
DoD: 4
AMoLaD: 4
TFF: 4

 

[Travis The Dragon]

VXI sure gets a lot of undeserved hate.

 

[Prowler_108]

IM: 4
Killers: 5
NOTB: 4
POM: 5
Powerslave: 2
SIT: 5
SSOASS: 4
NPFTD: 4
FOTD: 3
TXF: 4
VXI: 3
BNW: 5
DOD: 4 (really a 3.5)
AMOLAD: 4
TFF: 5