Rate every album on a scale of 1-5 stars

[lordantwarrior]

IM: 5
Killers: 4
NOTB: 5
POM: 4
PS: 6 
SIT: 5
SSOASS: 4
NPFTD: 3
FOTD: 3
TXF: 3
VXI: 2
BNW: 3
DOD: 3
AMOLAD: 4
TFF: 5

 

[Holy Smoke]

I give the first 2 and Virtual XI ****
I give No Prayer and FOTD ***
I give the rest *****

I give everything without Bruce -1.

 

[Dr. Eddies Wingman]

So you think songs like Phantom of the Opera, Killers, Sign of the Cross and The Clansman suck because they don't feature Bruce? I feel sorry for your lack of ability to appreciate music.

 

[Taker]

Hmmmm. interesting curve for me... peaks at each end with a valley in the middle...

 

[Prowler_108]

So you think songs like Phantom of the Opera, Killers, Sign of the Cross and The Clansman suck because they don't feature Bruce? I feel sorry for your lack of ability to appreciate music.

Amen.

 

[desultory]

Iron Maiden 5

Killers 4.5

The Number of The Beast 4.5

Piece of Mind 5

Powerslave 5

Somewhere in Time 5

Seventh Son of a Seventh Son 5

No Prayer for the Dying 4

Fear of the Dark 3.5

The X Factor 4

Virtual XI 2

Brave New World 4

Dance of Death 3

A Matter of Life and Death 3.5

The Final Frontier 3.5

 

[Travis The Dragon]

Who gave SIT 1 star?

 

[Kauha-Apina]

Iron Maiden: 5
Killers: 3
The Number of the Beast: 4
Piece of Mind: 3
Powerslave: 4
Somewhere in Time: 5
Seventh Son of a Seventh Son: 5
No Prayer for the Dying: 2
Fear of the Dark: 3
The X Factor: 4
Virtual XI: 3
Brave New World: 5
Dance of Death: 3
A Matter of life and Death: 4
The Final Frontier: 3

 

[Rotam]

Who gave SIT 1 star?

Who gave IM 1 star ?    such a powerful start for this band. Imagine IM with a "regular" production.

 

[Mosh]

Iron Maiden: 4
Killers: 5
Number Of The Beast: 5
Piece of Mind: 5
Powerslave: 5
Somewhere in Time: 4
Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son: 5
No Prayer For The Dying: 3
Fear of the Dark: -1 (AFTSS saves it from -2)
X Factor: 4
Virtual XI: 5
Brave New World:4
Dance of Death:4
A Matter of Life And Death:5
The Final Frontier: 10

 

[bearfan]

This is tough

Iron Maiden: 5
Killers: 4
Number Of The Beast: 5
Piece of Mind: 5
Powerslave: 4.5
Somewhere in Time: 3
Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son: 5
No Prayer For The Dying: 3  (when it came out, I would have given it a 1.5 or 2, I have grown to appreciate it over the years)
Fear of the Dark: 2
X Factor: 3
Virtual XI: 2
Brave New World:5
Dance of Death: 3.5
A Matter of Life And Death:5
The Final Frontier: 4.5